Alright Rev, I need some help.
Going to Nags Head with my wife's family in 2 weeks and each day down there dinner responsabilities fall on the shoulders of one of the family members. My Wife's thought, since usually there's a day or two that people eat at the house, was to try and do ribs like I did over the 4th of july.
The method was kind of simple. Season the ribs (3 big racks), put them into a tinfoil container, pour about 3 beers over (We ended up using Woodchuck Amber hard cider), cover with foil, and cook them on the grill with indirect heat at around 350 for about three hours turning a quarter turn every 30 minutes.
Cider yes! pork and apple goes well together, I'd stay away from beer here. Also, 350 is too high. 225 is how I roll, 275 MAX.
Aside from buying too big of a tinfoil container and thus not being able to have enough burners and space to get the temp needed with indirect heat (end up doing two burners under it on low and the far one on high) they turned out well. The bottoms were badly singed because of the heat, but they pretty moist and fell off the bone. I figure this time I'd buy the right sized container.
use 1 burner. keep everything indirect, don't use a container, double wrap in HEAVY DUTY reynolds aluminum foil... the Reason they "fell off the bone" is that you braised them instead of smoked them... texture was probably mushy, (no one would have noticed, but once you nail it down right, you will tell night and day)..
3 hours not wrapped, 2 hrs wrapped, 1 hr not wrapped. is standard, I do 3-1-1(1-till done)... Ribs are done when the meat pulls back 1/4 inch from the bone.
So here's my few questions...
1. Do you have a rub you'd suggest to make to put on the ribs and how much seasoning do you tend to put on? I tried using some montreal steak seasoning but obviously went way to light because there wasn't a lot of taste.
Dizzy Pig BBQ Home. The freshest award winning all natural BBQ Rubs.
More sweet, granular
Seafood & Barbeque Rubs and Seasonings Source - Butt Rub.com
More salty, spicier.
Pull the membrane off the back, rub the ribs with mustard, apply fairly liberally with seasoning, let sit in fridge for a few hours to overnight... Though often I throw the rub on right before I smoke em.
Mustard:
Rub:
Also I'd use a packet of cherry and hickory chips, put it in an aluminum foil packet, poke a hole in it and throw it on the direct side of the grill on the fire if you can. Or use a smoker tray.,
2. Do you have a go to BBQ sauce you make? I figure I can always do store bought but would be neat to do my own. You don't baste the ribs with the BBQ till like 10 minutes from removing them, yes?
Yes, I do, It's a bit complicated and you would be hard pressed to find what you need on the OBX...
What I would do is find a local sauce, out there it's probaly thin and vinegary, add brown sugar, honey, and red pepperflake to tase to create a glaze if you have the temp at 250 or so, put it on for the whole last hour, it wont burn at all.
3. No clue how many burners the grill at the beach house is going to have but its propane. I have one of the little metal grates you can put at the bottom with woodchips to cause it to smoke a bit. Would that be something to try, or with them being sealed tight in the tinfoil make it pointless.
Use the 3-2-1 method..... and yes use smoke absolutley. It will come out great even on a gasser.
4. Any suggestions on what to do better or differently?
Summary.
1. use 3-2-1 method 225-275 (275 MAX), 1 burner, indirect. (don't peak!)
2. Remove membrane, rub with yellow mustard, rub with rub.
3. Use hickory, and apple or other fruitwood.
4. Ribs on a rib rack, indirect side, 3 hrs
5. after 3 hrs double wrap in HD aluminum foil, pour cider, sugar, and honey over ribs, just a little you don't need to have them at braising level, slightly lower. Cook for 1-2 hrs, the longer the more they will braise.... Not always the texture you want.
6. last hour can be a crap shoot, they could almost be done at this point or need an hr or more, sauce em at let it tighen up. for sauce, I'd go local, and add honey, sugar and red pepper flake, to taste.
7. they are done when you get 1/4" pullback, careful though you can get more pullback during the "2" part, which is why when I crutch my ribs (foil is called a "texas crutch), I tend to only do it for an hr... if there is more than a 1/4 inch, they will be super tender, I like a little more bite to my ribs....
here is an example.
Crutched ribs:
Straight 7-8 hr's without foil, note the slight pull back:
Both of these tasted excellent and had the right bite, with the top ones being a little softer than the bottoms.
Also you'll note the char marks on the crutched ribs, These were done real fast after the foil period, I sauced them and kissed them on a direct medium hot grill for a few seconds to create a char-glazed texture that meshed well with the soft ribs.
Are you thinking loin backs or spares?