Fledermaus
DP Veteran
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2014
- Messages
- 121,426
- Reaction score
- 32,423
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Libertarian - Right
Ah, because of word-character count posting the Trafalgar Square video I had to omit my judges scoring of the multi service cadet platoons passing in review. I know that as a judge sitting here gawking into a tube I miss a lot of minutia that I know I would see if I were right there with my feet on the ground and eyes on.
I've judged these ceremonial/commemorative events, yet and by far I too have been judged. Being stationed in active service in the Military District of Washington (DC) I (among others) were invited several times to judge cadet parades at USNA Annapolis which I did do. Went twice to West Point to judge honors parades. And during my fourth and final year in The Old Guard of the Army at Ft. Myer in MDW, when I was BN asst.Adjutant I did a lot of judging and scoring throughout the Regiment. Ha, I wasn't marching out front of a platoon or company any more.
This one of Trafalgar Day is tough though from where I sit now. In respect of UK Cadet Force and in general, on most occasions, the drill&ceremony and marching&maneuvering champs are the Army Force cadets and the Air cadets of RAF. When it comes to cadet Marines in UK they're good but the London Area marching platoons are head and shoulders above their fellow cadet Marines.
So with the 2nd cadet Marine platoon from London Area I've got three platoons elbowing for 1st place with the scoring, the difference being to the right of the decimal point. So and well, if ten cadets were twisting my arm I'd stack 'em this way:
1st: Cadets of Army Force
2nd: Cadets of RAF
Cadet Marines of London Area
The reason I don't number the cadet Marines as #3 is that there are only 7 formal marching platoons. Seven platoons/marching units aren't enough by the Book to have 3 numbered top platoons. Three of seven is almost 50% when the Book says one platoon/company in four to get a win, place, show. That's two of eight platoons by the Book yet all there are in this vid is 7 scoring eligible platoons. Yet the Book is flexible on that. Two officially to win and place and one informally to score as show. But in this scoring they need to be a cluster rather than a stacking, which the three of 'em are. A tight cluster indeed.
The question remains "1909 was GSP class year and what were the US Army‘s “inclusion policies” that got “Georgie” 4 stars?"