• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling companies

Slartibartfast

Jesus loves you.
Supporting Member
DP Veteran
Monthly Donator
Joined
Jan 8, 2010
Messages
72,139
Reaction score
58,870
Location
NE Ohio
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Liberal
Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling companies - Yahoo! News


I am not a legal expert, but at what point must a judge recuse himself? Ultimately, while I do agree with the judgment made, I am a bit nervous about the objectivity that can be maintained by any judge who has a possible personal reason to make a ruling.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

Well, Well, Well... ain't that some ****...

Associated Press investigation found earlier this month that more than half the federal judges in the districts affected by the BP spill have financial ties to the oil and gas industry.

I really wonder how this is going to play out.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan


So in any case...any judge with some form of personal investment in the result should recuse themselves...
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan


Before jumping to any conclusions, I would have to ask this: does he manage his own financial portfolio or does someone else do that for him? If so, how involved in the picking of his own stocks is he? And finally, what stake in each company does he have? Is it less than a percent? More than 10%? How much of his entire portfolio is invested in those particular stocks?

Just because he has stocks in drilling doesn't mean that those stocks were even in his thoughts when he ruled.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

I mentioned this in another thread. My 401k has money in index funds. I therefore own indirectly some oil stocks. Would I have to recuse myself? Is there any evidcne the judges ruling was not based on sound legal precedent?
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan


I mentioned this in another thread. My 401k has money in index funds. I therefore own indirectly some oil stocks. Would I have to recuse myself? Is there any evidcne the judges ruling was not based on sound legal precedent?
I was about to deliver the bad news to everyone that if you own a retirement portfolio you have some investment in oil.......but you two beat me to it. Even if you manage your own fund.......somewhere down the line it has a tentacle in oil.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

I was about to deliver the bad news to everyone that if you own a retirement portfolio you have some investment in oil.......but you two beat me to it. Even if you manage your own fund.......somewhere down the line it has a tentacle in oil.

I inherited some oil investments.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan




It does, however raise the spectre of impropriety, to avoid it, he should recuse himself.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

It does, however raise the spectre of impropriety, to avoid it, he should recuse himself.
Then the case couldn't be heard.....because everyone who invests has money in oil in one way or another.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

It does, however raise the spectre of impropriety, to avoid it, he should recuse himself.

No, and in fact, in looking at the report, he owned the stocks in 2008, it isn't even clear if he still owns them or not, and his stake in each company was in the "less than $15k" range.

He has no need to recuse himself.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

I inherited some oil investments.
Well, the whole point is that every company diversifies, so if you are in a stocks portfolio you have money in oil somehow, if you are in mutual funds and not the manager then you have money in oil, if you are the manager the companies you have in the fund have money in oil. You simply have the most direct route.:mrgreen:
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan


If a judge ruled in favor of the moratorium and owned stock in windmills, or solar panels. Would he have to recuse himself?

How much of his own money has Obama invested in green energy? Hmmm???

Or, is that different?
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

From the other thread:


Edit: If you look at the dude's disclosure, he had stated positions in 125 different companies across every industry in the country.
 
Last edited:
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

From the other thread:



Edit: If you look at the dude's disclosure, he had stated positions in 125 different companies across every industry in the country.

I think that makes this a "much to do about nothing" story.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

Agreed with others on this broad this is a nothing kind of story. All people who invested have some ties to Oil this I agree with.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

I mentioned this in another thread. My 401k has money in index funds. I therefore own indirectly some oil stocks. Would I have to recuse myself? Is there any evidcne the judges ruling was not based on sound legal precedent?

Your only a moderator.
Your never likely to be a Judge, so in your case it is immaterial.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

Your only a moderator.
Your never likely to be a Judge, so in your case it is immaterial.

You're kinda missing the point here...
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

Look at all of the apologists coming out to defend this judge.

There is a clear conflict of interest. His ruling on the moratorium should be voided and reviewed by a different judge who doesn't have a history with the oil companies.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

Look at all of the apologists coming out to defend this judge.

There is a clear conflict of interest. His ruling on the moratorium should be voided and reviewed by a different judge who doesn't have a history with the oil companies.

Nope this is not a clear conflict of interest it depends, if he even knew he had stocks in oil. Look I am a environmentalist myself, and I am not judging this without more prof that it conflicted his thought process. I also doubt that $15,000 is enough to sway a judge to their favor.....
 
Last edited:
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

Look at all of the apologists coming out to defend this judge.

There is a clear conflict of interest. His ruling on the moratorium should be voided and reviewed by a different judge who doesn't have a history with the oil companies.

Let me get this straight...

A judge makes on this court would make around $170,000 a year. However, according to you, his decision was swayed by "less than $15,000" invested in an oil company? So, in what will be a multi-billion dollar event, you claim the judge was influenced in a major way in his decision making for the value of around what he makes in one month? (Assuming he even still owns the stock)

Pretty thin.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

Does not matter Salazar said he will reinstate it.

Salazar seeks to reimpose drilling moratorium

Interior Secretary Ken Salazar says he will issue a new order imposing a moratorium on deepwater drilling after a federal judge struck down the existing one.

Salazar said in a statement Tuesday evening that the new order will contain additional information making clear why the six-month drilling pause was necessary in the wake of the Gulf oil spill. The judge in New Orleans who struck down the moratorium earlier in the day complained there wasn't enough justification for it.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan

Look at all of the apologists coming out to defend this judge.

There is a clear conflict of interest. His ruling on the moratorium should be voided and reviewed by a different judge who doesn't have a history with the oil companies.

 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan


Bogus, he cites safety reasons, but ignores that his own department stated all rigs had no real safety problems after reinspection.

Then, Gibbs says Obama believes that until investigations can determine why the spill happened, continued deepwater drilling exposes workers and the environment to "a danger that the president does not believe we can afford.... ignoring that his own department has issued a report saying they are fine.
 
Re: Judge who overturned drilling moratorium reported owning stock in drilling compan


I'm really looking forward to the explanation for that.

Salazar Launches Safety and Environmental Protection Reforms to Toughen Oversight of Offshore Oil and Gas Operations

 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…