- Joined
- Jul 15, 2005
- Messages
- 28,133
- Reaction score
- 15,017
- Location
- Canada's Capital
- Gender
- Female
- Political Leaning
- Progressive
Simon W. Moon said:could we please have a citation for this assertion?
I found this interesting article out of many hits. Isn't it interesting that a little sugar will get you much further ahead.
link: http://www.budiansky.com/atlantic0506.html
The Atlantic Monthly | June 2005
The Agenda
Intelligence
Truth Extraction
A classic text on interrogating enemy captives offers a counterintuitive lesson on the best way to get information
by Stephen Budiansky
.....
Six months before the abuses at Abu Ghraib prison broke into public view, a small and fairly obscure private association of United States Marine Corps members posted on its Web site a document on how to get enemy POWs to talk.
The document described a situation very similar to the one the United States faces in the insurgencies in Iraq and Afghanistan: a fanatical and implacable enemy, intense pressure to achieve quick results, a brutal war in which the old rules no longer seem to apply.
<snip>Marine Major Sherwood F. Moran, the report's author, noted that despite the complexities and difficulties of dealing with an enemy from such a hostile and alien culture, some American interrogators consistently managed to extract useful information from prisoners. The successful interrogators all had one thing in common in the way they approached their subjects. They were nice to them.<snip>
<snip>But it is hard to imagine a historical lesson that would constitute a more direct reproach to recent U.S. policies on prisoner interrogation. And there is no doubt that Moran's report owes more than a little of its recent celebrity to the widespread disdain among experienced military interrogators for what took place at Abu Ghraib and Guantánamo when ill-trained personnel were ordered to "soften up" prisoners. Since the prison scandals broke, many old hands in the business have pointed out that abusing prisoners is not simply illegal and immoral; it is also remarkably ineffective.<snip>
<snip>"The torture of suspects [at Abu Ghraib] did not lead to any useful intelligence information being extracted," says James Corum, a professor at the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College and the author of a forthcoming book on counterinsurgency warfare. <snip>
*(bold emphasis mine)