But masks were prescribed as one part of a series of precautions, and no one claimed masks “stopped” covid. I’m sorry you borrowed something so banal, you had a plethora of options and you went with that.
So okay: I think what your’re realling saying is you don’t care how many folks die to get to herd immunity, correct? If I have you wrong, just say so, but I don’t think so. And if that’s the case, why waste time on “science” you’re not interested in? Just make the philosophical argument, and then explain how it would be executed and what that would look like.
Here, I’ll go first: herd immunity, putting aside how cruel and inhumane it is, is just bad policy. It will wipe out entire workforces in sickness just to get there. Entire departments down for the count for a week or more. That’s if they don’t have long term complications. Employers will have to stop and start projects as different key players get sick. The effect on mulitimilliom dollar personality/athlete driven industries is that they will be effectively halted for a few years.The won’t be any confidence among consumers either as *you* may be willing to Stand Up To A Virus, but others just aren’t as brave and rugged. And they get to decide where to spend their money. Theaters in states that opened too early are still struggling, for example. Our passports will still be worthless as the rest of the world is not going to allow a viral shithole of 300m people come near their own countries any time soon.
And then there’s the psychological consequences of Americans just passively accepting millions dead from a preventable virus. What parent would support any war ever again? Why would we risk our lives for a country that gave up on us so easily? If you think we’re just a collection of selfish entitelment now, just wait until we are post a time where folks like you told us our grandparents, children, wives, husbands, etc aren’t worth it and we need to just get over it. What will empathy or sympathy even look like in this country? How would we explain it to our children?
Herd immunity is bad economically and socially.