• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

[W:371]Twenty Generals Call for Coup Against Macron Warning of ‘Civil War’ and ‘Disintegration of France at Hands of Islamists’

No, they’re saying that allowing Muslims to live in France is destroying French culture. Muslims should be perfectly welcome to be human beings in whatever craphole country they came from. You have no inherent right to live in any specific place on earth and it’s pretty apparent immigration is not helping France

Which is racist and xenophobic, as well as moronic. France suffered enough at the hands of the far right fifth columnists in the 20th century already.
 
I ask again, what blasphemy laws are being proposed?

Christians murder people in America by bombing abortion clinics. Should Christians be banned from living in America?
America is an inherently Christian nation.

Islam is a foreign ideology. False equivelance dismissed
 
I ask again, what blasphemy laws are being proposed?

Christians murder people in America by bombing abortion clinics. Should Christians be banned from living in America?

If Christians murdered people in the name of their God the response should not be "Well, just stop disrespecting their God!"

That is precisely what has happened in France. It is not a de jure law, but it is a different code for Islamist areas. There have been a constant drumbeat of Islamist attacks on free society for years.

Which is exactly what the letter addresses. The central point, really.

If dozens of former US military officials wrote a letter saying they believed Christian Fundamentalists posed a massive threat, I doubt you'd be anywhere near as dismissive.
 
If Christians murdered people in the name of their God the response should not be "Well, just stop disrespecting their God!"

That is precisely what has happened in France. It is not a de jure law, but it is a different code for Islamist areas. There have been a constant drumbeat of Islamist attacks on free society for years.

Which is exactly what the letter addresses. The central point, really.

“If”?

Christian terrorism has been a serious threat in many areas for a long time now.
 
religion is always enforced by law. Like diversity and gender theory are religious ideas and enforced by law.
retroactively changing nationality law can be done. The Dominican Republic has done it for example.

The colonization argument is irrelevant. Your region being colonized is not a valid reason for you to be allowed to live in the Colonial power, in fact it’s a reason not to because it’s obvious by the number of youths who went to join ISIS that these people are not grateful and often disillusioned when allowed to live there.

The French colonization was necessary to stop Muslim piracy in the Mediterranean, to end the North African slave trade, and to bring modern rule. The Muslim nations colonized by France have only their selves to blame for it.
Neither diversity nor gender theory are religious ideas and freedom forces nothing on anyone.

Really? How much piracy was Morocco engaged in when France colonized it?
 
If Christians murdered people in the name of their God the response should not be "Well, just stop disrespecting their God!"

That is precisely what has happened in France. It is not a de jure law, but it is a different code for Islamist areas. There have been a constant drumbeat of Islamist attacks on free society for years.

Which is exactly what the letter addresses. The central point, really.

If dozens of former US military officials wrote a letter saying they believed Christian Fundamentalists posed a massive threat, I doubt you'd be anywhere near as dismissive.
Dozens of former US military officials wrote a letter saying Trump was a massive threat and it was ignored, so it would seem that’s not accurate.
 
America is an inherently Christian nation.

Islam is a foreign ideology. False equivelance dismissed
The Treaty of Tripoli counters your claim that America is inherently Christian as a nation and it is part of the Supreme Law of the Land.
 
“If”?

Christian terrorism has been a serious threat in many areas for a long time now.

If there were regions of the country were teachers were murdered for mocking Jesus (there aren't, but let's play along) I'd say we need to address the problem at the root.

If trucks were being driven through crowds of people by Jesus Freaks (there aren't) and dozens of police officers stabbed (there aren't) and cartoonists being massacred (there aren't) by Christians and dozens of military officials warned of a possible civil war I'd say we should listen.

But the muzzies are brown so it's "boo hoo they got hurt feelings"

If a Frenchman is not free to mock religion in all of France without risking his life then something sacred has been lost.
 
Dozens of former US military officials wrote a letter saying Trump was a massive threat and it was ignored, so it would seem that’s not accurate.

Was that letter a coup attempt?
 
The Treaty of Tripoli counters your claim that America is inherently Christian as a nation and it is part of the Supreme Law of the Land.
No; the treaty of Tripoli is not supreme law of the land. Foreign treaties are not binding law without congressional legislation.

Plus even if it were, the treaty and not the history would be wrong
 
If there were regions of the country were teachers were murdered for mocking Jesus (there aren't, but let's play along) I'd say we need to address the problem at the root.

If trucks were being driven through crowds of people by Jesus Freaks (there aren't) and dozens of police officers stabbed (there aren't) and cartoonists being massacred (there aren't) by Christians and dozens of military officials warned of a possible civil war I'd say we should listen.

But the muzzies are brown so it's "boo hoo they got hurt feelings"

If a Frenchman is not free to mock religion in all of France without risking his life then something sacred has been lost.

Lol yeah, Christians stick to tossing bombs and shooting places up. Sooo much better😂🙄

“Muzzies”? Really bud?
 
Lol yeah, Christians stick to tossing bombs and shooting places up. Sooo much better😂🙄

“Muzzies”? Really bud?
Christians generally do well in terms of killing, but then a few other aspects.
You cannot understand the principled position of the European states. There are no countries in Europe that refuse to allow Middle Eastern refugees to stay, but they are nation-states with their own history, traditions and laws. Where refugees are required to integrate into European society.
Alas, but in France, Middle Eastern and African Muslim refugees do not just do not want to integrate into the French society, observing tolerance and respect for others, they create strongholds of the Muslim world, a quasi-state of compact residence of Muslims with Sharia law and ignoring French law.
Alas, the French have every right to deny the Muslmans such separatism.
Actually, they do this and are not going to ask permission from the Americans for domestic politics.
 
Christians generally do well in terms of killing, but then a few other aspects.
You cannot understand the principled position of the European states. There are no countries in Europe that refuse to allow Middle Eastern refugees to stay, but they are nation-states with their own history, traditions and laws. Where refugees are required to integrate into European society.
Alas, but in France, Middle Eastern and African Muslim refugees do not just do not want to integrate into the French society, observing tolerance and respect for others, they create strongholds of the Muslim world, a quasi-state of compact residence of Muslims with Sharia law and ignoring French law.
Alas, the French have every right to deny the Muslmans such separatism.
Actually, they do this and are not going to ask permission from the Americans for domestic politics.

Oh look, unhinged hysteria about imaginary “separatism”.
 
Oh look, unhinged hysteria about imaginary “separatism”.
You can call my opinion whatever you want, hysteria, imaginary separatism... but there are facts.
Large groups of compactly living radical Muslmans are not satisfied with the French and measures are being taken against them.
I repeat, the French are not going to ask permission from anyone for repercussions against radical Muslemans.
In the United States, you are free to do whatever you want, allow the Muslims to introduce Sharia law, cut off the girls ' clit, legalize polygamy...
 
They’re basically saying “If you treat Muslims like human beings, then France will fall apart!”

It’s Islamophobia and xenophobia of the highest degree.
Muslims must first learn to treat others, especially women, as human beings. There is an ongoing trial going on in Paris now with Muslim women being charged. and convicted, of trying to destroy Notre Dame cathedral. I'll bet this is news to MSM followers.
 
A group of 20 former military generals from the armed forces of France have written an open letter warning that France could descend into civil war if certain dangerous forces and trends were not kept in check.

More on Macron and French Muslims. https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2021/04/macrons-folly-bruce-bawer/
 
You can call my opinion whatever you want, hysteria, imaginary separatism... but there are facts.
Large groups of compactly living radical Muslmans are not satisfied with the French and measures are being taken against them.
I repeat, the French are not going to ask permission from anyone for repercussions against radical Muslemans.
In the United States, you are free to do whatever you want, allow the Muslims to introduce Sharia law, cut off the girls ' clit, legalize polygamy...

There are indeed facts(not that you know any). Vichy Le Pen and her followers are frothing at the mouth in eagerness to go after the “Muslemans”, we already know. It takes a special kind of ignorance to think that the US is “legalizing polygamy” or “introducing sharia law”.
 
Well, a coup d'etat is a French word after all.
 
There are indeed facts(not that you know any). Vichy Le Pen and her followers are frothing at the mouth in eagerness to go after the “Muslemans”, we already know. It takes a special kind of ignorance to think that the US is “legalizing polygamy” or “introducing sharia law”.
))) Neither my opinion nor your opinion in this matter is absolutely unimportant. The French will sort it out... well, or they won't figure it out.
It's up to them how to deal with the Muslmans.
 
Christians murder people in America by bombing abortion clinics. Should Christians be banned from living in America?
Really? That's what Christians are doing? Hasn't been in the news much at all. Do you have a link?
 
A group of 20 former military generals from the armed forces of France have written an open letter warning that France could descend into civil war if certain dangerous forces and trends were not kept in check.


A good example of how you can find stupidity in all countries, and every military.

I think those three values should be abolished and the Bourbons put back on the throne.

Of course you do. But that idea is ****ing dumb, and would never happen. The most powerful countries in the world are those that overthrew monarchs or removed their influence.

Muslims must first learn to treat others, especially women, as human beings.

Women have been treated as second-class citizens in the Middle East since long before Gabriel spoke to Muhammad.
 
Women have been treated as second-class citizens in the Middle East since long before Gabriel spoke to Muhammad.
Right. It's about time they entered a more enlightened era. Same with their attitudes towards Gays, Jews and people of other religions. It's been too backward for too long.
 
Right. It's about time they entered a more enlightened era. Same with their attitudes towards Gays, Jews and people of other religions. It's been too backward for too long.

Okay, how?
 
Back
Top Bottom