• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

The geometry teacher is a recording. The chemistry students often teach themselves.

j brown's body

"A Soros-backed animal"
DP Veteran
Joined
Jun 18, 2018
Messages
54,482
Reaction score
51,155
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Progressive

Teacher shortages are getting renewed attention this year. But in Mississippi and other Southern states, this crisis dates back more than a decade.​


"The nature and the severity of the teacher crisis differ radically from state to state, district to district and even school to school. Some districts have only recently started experiencing teacher shortages, but in many Southern states, the problem has been long-standing and only gotten worse. It doesn’t help either that the state has shortchanged districts like West Bolivar Consolidated by millions of dollars, failing to fund a program that would send more money to poor districts.

Researchers have found that schools that serve high percentages of minority students and students in poverty have more difficulty finding and retaining qualified educators than Whiter, more affluent schools. The West Bolivar Consolidated School District is 98 percent Black, and 100 percent of children qualify for free or reduced-price meals.

...When public schools were compelled to integrate here, White students moved to private schools that came to be known as segregation academies — institutions that still stand today and serve a largely White student body. The desegregation fight in the county is hardly history: In 2016, a federal judge ordered two high schools in Cleveland, the county’s largest city, to consolidate into one to better integrate the student body. But at the schools that make up the West Bolivar district, there is nothing to integrate. White students left in the 1970s after courts told schools to open their doors to children of any race."

Link

Hmmm...

"Critical race theory is an academic concept that is more than 40 years old. The core idea is that race is a social construct, and that racism is not merely the product of individual bias or prejudice, but also something embedded in legal systems and policies."

Link

Ya think?
 
Ya know its funny all the pro cop people never seem to apply their reasoning to the GOP’s decades long war on teachers and professors.
 
Problem 1 with Mississippi might be that they pay their teachers the lowest in the nation.


Across the board: the way we find public education is fundamentally flawed and needs to be addressed.

It should NOT be based on property taxes. That puts poorer neighborhoods in a bad spot that they are fighting against before even a single student or teacher sets foot in a classroom.
 
This is why New York has cracked down on bigoted certification exams. More teachers of color are needed for schools of color.

The shortage is teachers in general. The way the right treats teachers, it's no wonder people don't want to become teachers. Mostly underpaid, have to pay out of pocket for many supplies and they get the "honor" of getting treated like shit from the right. My daughter wanted to become a teacher until she found out all these things and said she didn't want to deal with that so she's working company training instead.
 
I always find it shocking how teachers in the States are held in such low regard. The right is constantly badmouthng them and in many States their salaries are pathetic. In most western countries teachers are held in high regard and paid very well.

Who the hell in their right mind wants to be constantly put upon, spoken poorly about, paid dirt and work their asses off to educate the kids ...luckily teachers! Hats off to them all!
 
Who would ever want to teach in Mississippi. Practically a 3rd world country, over there.
 

Teacher shortages are getting renewed attention this year. But in Mississippi and other Southern states, this crisis dates back more than a decade.​


"The nature and the severity of the teacher crisis differ radically from state to state, district to district and even school to school. Some districts have only recently started experiencing teacher shortages, but in many Southern states, the problem has been long-standing and only gotten worse. It doesn’t help either that the state has shortchanged districts like West Bolivar Consolidated by millions of dollars, failing to fund a program that would send more money to poor districts.

Researchers have found that schools that serve high percentages of minority students and students in poverty have more difficulty finding and retaining qualified educators than Whiter, more affluent schools. The West Bolivar Consolidated School District is 98 percent Black, and 100 percent of children qualify for free or reduced-price meals.


...When public schools were compelled to integrate here, White students moved to private schools that came to be known as segregation academies — institutions that still stand today and serve a largely White student body. The desegregation fight in the county is hardly history: In 2016, a federal judge ordered two high schools in Cleveland, the county’s largest city, to consolidate into one to better integrate the student body. But at the schools that make up the West Bolivar district, there is nothing to integrate. White students left in the 1970s after courts told schools to open their doors to children of any race."

Link

Hmmm...

"Critical race theory is an academic concept that is more than 40 years old. The core idea is that race is a social construct, and that racism is not merely the product of individual bias or prejudice, but also something embedded in legal systems and policies."

Link

Ya think?
Did the report say why teachers do not want to work in those schools with high minority student bodies? It is the right of a parent to send their kids to the schools of their choice. There are many reasons parents send kids to private schools: religious affiliation, better academic scores, less violence in the school. better facilities are just a few. If our political and educational leaders were honest and were truly concerned with improving our schools they would fix these problems. As for teachers, pay is often a factor but not surprisingly the pay at private schools is less than public. The trade off is free tuition for their kids, less discipline issues to deal with, religious affiliations, less stress. Many private schools have racially mixed student bodies so racial segregation is not a strong factor.
Discipline issues often rank as a major reason for students leaving public schools and schools with large minority populations seem to see a lot of that. Discipline works and clear expectations and clear consequences for discipline infractions need to be maintained. Part of this is clear and consistent contact with both students and parents.
CRT ignores the data of minority crime rates and instead chooses to blame someone else for the bad behavior of some. Society should be held accountable when they do wrong and we have fixed many of our problems and continue to work on them. However, being responsible for your actions and knowing there are strict consequences for those actions is a must regardless of race, social position, or income.
 
Did the report say why teachers do not want to work in those schools with high minority student bodies? It is the right of a parent to send their kids to the schools of their choice. There are many reasons parents send kids to private schools: religious affiliation, better academic scores, less violence in the school. better facilities are just a few. If our political and educational leaders were honest and were truly concerned with improving our schools they would fix these problems. As for teachers, pay is often a factor but not surprisingly the pay at private schools is less than public. The trade off is free tuition for their kids, less discipline issues to deal with, religious affiliations, less stress. Many private schools have racially mixed student bodies so racial segregation is not a strong factor.
Discipline issues often rank as a major reason for students leaving public schools and schools with large minority populations seem to see a lot of that. Discipline works and clear expectations and clear consequences for discipline infractions need to be maintained. Part of this is clear and consistent contact with both students and parents.
CRT ignores the data of minority crime rates and instead chooses to blame someone else for the bad behavior of some. Society should be held accountable when they do wrong and we have fixed many of our problems and continue to work on them. However, being responsible for your actions and knowing there are strict consequences for those actions is a must regardless of race, social position, or income.


The Trump base is already among the most poorly educated demographics and voting blocs in the country, and not very well off financially. It is only a very small minority of them which could afford private education. If you cut the little public education they are even getting now, you are looking at illiteracy rates in this country worse than Bangladesh.

MAGA, LOL.
 
Did the report say why teachers do not want to work in those schools with high minority student bodies? It is the right of a parent to send their kids to the schools of their choice. There are many reasons parents send kids to private schools: religious affiliation, better academic scores, less violence in the school. better facilities are just a few. If our political and educational leaders were honest and were truly concerned with improving our schools they would fix these problems. As for teachers, pay is often a factor but not surprisingly the pay at private schools is less than public. The trade off is free tuition for their kids, less discipline issues to deal with, religious affiliations, less stress. Many private schools have racially mixed student bodies so racial segregation is not a strong factor.
Discipline issues often rank as a major reason for students leaving public schools and schools with large minority populations seem to see a lot of that. Discipline works and clear expectations and clear consequences for discipline infractions need to be maintained. Part of this is clear and consistent contact with both students and parents.
CRT ignores the data of minority crime rates and instead chooses to blame someone else for the bad behavior of some. Society should be held accountable when they do wrong and we have fixed many of our problems and continue to work on them. However, being responsible for your actions and knowing there are strict consequences for those actions is a must regardless of race, social position, or income.

Apparently the main reason:

"White students moved to private schools that came to be known as segregation academies..."
 
I always find it shocking how teachers in the States are held in such low regard. The right is constantly badmouthng them and in many States their salaries are pathetic. In most western countries teachers are held in high regard and paid very well.

Who the hell in their right mind wants to be constantly put upon, spoken poorly about, paid dirt and work their asses off to educate the kids ...luckily teachers! Hats off to them all!

Teacher quits $43K to work at Wal Mart for $55K.

It's like a headline out of The Onion. But this is real life.
 
Problem 1 with Mississippi might be that they pay their teachers the lowest in the nation.


Across the board: the way we find public education is fundamentally flawed and needs to be addressed.

It should NOT be based on property taxes. That puts poorer neighborhoods in a bad spot that they are fighting against before even a single student or teacher sets foot in a classroom.
Imo, the strongest reason proposed to explain pay weakness in the teaching profession is that when it started...it was considered to be a job for women. Therefore, they could be paid less.

The idea that our schools provide equal opportunity to our students is wrong, and funding through property taxes is a primary reason.
 
I always find it shocking how teachers in the States are held in such low regard. The right is constantly badmouthng them and in many States their salaries are pathetic. In most western countries teachers are held in high regard and paid very well.

Who the hell in their right mind wants to be constantly put upon, spoken poorly about, paid dirt and work their asses off to educate the kids ...luckily teachers! Hats off to them all!
Thank you.
 
And when that worker walks out of WalMart, her work for the day is done. Teachers go about another 2 hours per day...for free.

Yup. And I've been there. The school bell rings at 3:30 PM and your day is just getting started. There's coaching, clubs, grading, lesson prep, meetings, calling parents, etc etc.
 
Imo, the strongest reason proposed to explain pay weakness in the teaching profession is that when it started...it was considered to be a job for women. Therefore, they could be paid less.

The idea that our schools provide equal opportunity to our students is wrong, and funding through property taxes is a primary reason.
We fund our public schools through property taxes too but the Provincial government collects the money, adds to it, and then disburses the money back to the school boards on a per student basis. This model ensures that all children have the same level of funding regardless of the affluence or poverty of their neighbourhoods.
 

It should NOT be based on property taxes. That puts poorer neighborhoods in a bad spot that they are fighting against before even a single student or teacher sets foot in a classroom.
If not property taxes, how do you suggest public education be funded?
 
I always find it shocking how teachers in the States are held in such low regard. The right is constantly badmouthng them and in many States their salaries are pathetic. In most western countries teachers are held in high regard and paid very well.

Who the hell in their right mind wants to be constantly put upon, spoken poorly about, paid dirt and work their asses off to educate the kids ...luckily teachers! Hats off to them all!
Private school barons certainly got their fill.
 
There's a very ugly dog whistle about communities of color in this post.

:rolleyes:

The communities of color are the ones being oppressed by the largely white politicians of Mississippi. So don't accost me with your virtue signaling bullshit when I've been speaking out for those oppressed communities for a decade now on this forum.
 
Back
Top Bottom