- Joined
- Jun 22, 2013
- Messages
- 20,271
- Reaction score
- 28,076
- Location
- Mid-West USA
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Other
Do you agree with the idea that the bigger the Government, the smaller each citizen becomes?
I am not the originator of this point, although I have recognized it most of my life. But I am curious as to how my peers might think. The following is the argument:
The premise is that everything gets smaller as the government gets bigger. Including:
We can all recognize that Government does have a certain value when it:
Protects us from foreign attacks, and criminals in our own country; addresses natural and man-made disasters; and when all else fails, acts as a safety net of last resort.
BUT, it must always be of LAST resort; because when government is looked to as the FIRST resort, then individual responsibility tends to diminish.
First to go is Goodness. As people look more and more to government for help, individuals ask themselves "why help others when the government can do it for you?"
Next to go is Human Character. Relying on others to take care of you when you are capable of taking care of yourself is both selfish and the definition of irresponsible. Moreover, in relying on other’s in the form of State largess paid for via taxation creates a sense of ENTITLEMENT. This is soon followed by feelings of ingratitude and resentment at any attempts to modify or limit such largesse.
Then goes Liberty. The more government, the more rules. The more rules, the less liberty. U.S. example: the Federal Register which started out with 2,620 pages of rules in 1936 now has well over 87,000 pages currently. Microsoft Word - fed-reg-pages (llsdc.org)
Finally, when goodness, human character, and liberty dissipate, sacrificed to the power of government and the Collective, we ultimately lose our Individuality…becoming mere cogs in the machine of all pervasive government control.
In my opinion, the old saying "The best government is that which governs least" is how we should all look at centralized power and any desire to expand such power.
So, to the poll question: Do you agree that the bigger the Government, the smaller the individual citizen becomes in every way?
Yes
No
Other.
I am not the originator of this point, although I have recognized it most of my life. But I am curious as to how my peers might think. The following is the argument:
The premise is that everything gets smaller as the government gets bigger. Including:
- Liberty
- Individuality
- Goodness
- Human Character
We can all recognize that Government does have a certain value when it:
Protects us from foreign attacks, and criminals in our own country; addresses natural and man-made disasters; and when all else fails, acts as a safety net of last resort.
BUT, it must always be of LAST resort; because when government is looked to as the FIRST resort, then individual responsibility tends to diminish.
First to go is Goodness. As people look more and more to government for help, individuals ask themselves "why help others when the government can do it for you?"
Next to go is Human Character. Relying on others to take care of you when you are capable of taking care of yourself is both selfish and the definition of irresponsible. Moreover, in relying on other’s in the form of State largess paid for via taxation creates a sense of ENTITLEMENT. This is soon followed by feelings of ingratitude and resentment at any attempts to modify or limit such largesse.
Then goes Liberty. The more government, the more rules. The more rules, the less liberty. U.S. example: the Federal Register which started out with 2,620 pages of rules in 1936 now has well over 87,000 pages currently. Microsoft Word - fed-reg-pages (llsdc.org)
Finally, when goodness, human character, and liberty dissipate, sacrificed to the power of government and the Collective, we ultimately lose our Individuality…becoming mere cogs in the machine of all pervasive government control.
In my opinion, the old saying "The best government is that which governs least" is how we should all look at centralized power and any desire to expand such power.
So, to the poll question: Do you agree that the bigger the Government, the smaller the individual citizen becomes in every way?
Yes
No
Other.
Last edited: