• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Pro-Life High School Group Says Principal Banned Them From Using Life-Sized Fetus

No, you don't have to be respectful.

APDST - we are talking about students in a school.

Usually being respectful is mandatory. Violating that and the student gets in trouble.
 

clownboy: skip the forum sliding and engage me in a discussion about proof?
 
Please, you are making a spectacle of yourself and your fake indignation is pure tripe. No one gives a **** what any student believes, but spreading that belief is not allowed in school, it is that simple.
 
APDST - we are talking about students in a school.

Usually being respectful is mandatory. Violating that and the student gets in trouble.

Where does it say that in The Constitution?
 
Please, you are making a spectacle of yourself and your fake indignation is pure tripe. No one gives a **** what any student believes, but spreading that belief is not allowed in school, it is that simple.

Not allowed in school? :lamo
 
Where does it say that in The Constitution?

Sweet ****ing jesus.

Okay - whatever. Suddenly kids can say whatever they want AT SCHOOL. :roll:
 
And we sure wouldn't want any other views to be expressed that aren't in lock-step with the "wildly inaccurate" ones espoused by the teaching unions that run education and curriculum these days.

You have the choice to home shool your child and teach them all your knowledge of the Universe.
 
Where does it say that in The Constitution?

Freedom of speech, especialy in a student's case, does not mean that the school can not set rules, regulations, and restrictions.

If a student wished to go out to the flag pole and read the constitution durring math class...does the school have to allow her the right to do so?

Freedom of speech within reason.
 

Wow. Wrong forum section but that is just...wow. While I agree 100% each person should examine their choices fully before making a decision, that is quite the major implication in that post. There are indeed moral implications outside of religion...but they apply to all/both parties in any decision.

Maybe I am assuming what that post applied to. If not abortion, my bad. I think it is a fascinating comment...but after looking at it (from mostly the abortion focus)....it's incorrect....even when applied elsewhere. I would like to explore it further.
 
You have the choice to home shool your child and teach them all your knowledge of the Universe.

Or you have the choice to demand that the taxes you pay to fund public education are used in an unbiased, unpolitical, unideological way.
 
I have seen tons of fetus pics and abortion pics, but I have never really seen a birth.


 
Let me see. A pro-life group brings the display in, and it's not political? OK. Anything you say.

Well the political focus of the group is no secret to begin with, is it? if the group is allowed at the school, then why not allow accurate portrayals? Arent people there either to support each other or learn more?
 
Or you have the choice to demand that the taxes you pay to fund public education are used in an unbiased, unpolitical, unideological way.

You have the right to demand anything you wish...You also have the choice not to accept it.
 
No - I'm pretty certain that if someone tried to start a pro-choice group and showed aborted fetuses it would cause an uproar and be deemed offensive.

Maybe I'm missing something (if so, I apologize) but it's the pro-life groups that use those pics for emotional blackmail....not pro-choice groups.

And that was not even close to the case here.
 
If they were a biology student group, that would be completely different. But these kids have a political motive. If they hand out pro life literature or discuss why you shouldn't abort, that isn't just a science display.



 
You have the right to demand anything you wish...You also have the choice not to accept it.

Actually, no, you don't have a particular "right" to do so - you have an obligation as a voting member of a democratic society to ensure you do all you can to enforce it.
 
What do you find so shocking about a child in the womb?

The shocking aspect would be to refer to the fetus a "child" or "baby".

That is why science is left to the science classroom. Many of these students will going on to medical careers. To fill their heads with nonsence is a disservice.
 

They're not out rambling about the school proseletyzing...they're in a room somewhere, in a group, separate from the rest of the students unless they choose to join.
 
Actually, no, you don't have a particular "right" to do so - you have an obligation as a voting member of a democratic society to ensure you do all you can to enforce it.

vote your conscience, but accept the outcome.
 
Usually that is taught in "health' class. Should we hand over teaching on gestation to school groups? Should the information be reviewed by health instructors and sanctioned or denied based on "correct" information?

Nobody is forcing kids to join this group...they join because of common interests.
 
The shocking aspect would be to refer to the fetus a "child" or "baby".

That is why science is left to the science classroom. Many of these students will going on to medical careers. To fill their heads with nonsence is a disservice.

"Shocking" is a relative term, some people are more easily startled than others. You are apparently easily shocked, whereas nothing much shocks me.

That said, science exists outside the science classroom. One would hope that students take that which they learn in the classroom and apply it to the real world they are confronted with.

I for one don't want to perpetuate a culture of kids who are all stars in the classroom and completely useless in the real world, do you?
 




Think whatever you want to think.

The USA is a free country.





Just don't expect everyone to support your ideas.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…