• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Mexico in danger of collapse, says US army

Divine Wind

Banned
Joined
Jul 7, 2010
Messages
132
Reaction score
59
Location
Ft. Worth, TX
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Moderate
Oops. This could get nasty real quick. No billion dollar wall would stop the onslaught of refugees headed north if Mexico collapsed into anarchy.

Mexico in danger of collapse, says US army - Telegraph
America may be forced to intervene in Mexico to prevent the country's "rapid and sudden collapse" at the hands of organised crime and drug cartels, according to the US army.
 
You know this is not true.
 
Mexico won't collapse for one reason: The US won't allow it because if Mexico were to collapse, we'd have to deal with all their BS and we're way too busy to do that right now
 
Mexico won't collapse for one reason: The US won't allow it because if Mexico were to collapse, we'd have to deal with all their BS and we're way too busy to do that right now

We deal with their BS all the time. And throughout history we have always had to deal with Mexican insecurities. Nothing would change if its government collapse. Instead it would be great if Mexico did collapse so our armed forces can get better experiences dealing with unconventional warfare. Afghanis are cowards compare to Mexicans.
 
Gee, how do we stop this threat of anarchy? By weakening the cartels, of course! How do we do that? By ending the drug war, obviously. But wait! It's the United States, so I guess thats not gonna happen. Instead let's just keep sitting back and give the cartels power by keeping drugs illegal so that they can run around kidnapping and killing people and keep their strong political influence.
 
That's a interesting thought. But how would making drugs legal here take power away from cartels based in countries where the drugs would probably remain illegal? People would still be forced to business with cartels right?
 
Carpet bomb em all and let God sort it out.
 
Gee, how do we stop this threat of anarchy? By weakening the cartels, of course! How do we do that? By ending the drug war, obviously. But wait! It's the United States, so I guess thats not gonna happen. Instead let's just keep sitting back and give the cartels power by keeping drugs illegal so that they can run around kidnapping and killing people and keep their strong political influence.

Yeah - instead of drugs to be in the green they'll peddle something else. . . and instead of fighting off import of drugs we'll be fighting off laced hecks who dose up and hit the town fo ra night of mayhem and pillaging.

Wow - yes - a future of peace, security and safety.

You know . . . from how things have GONE with Mexico I've already written them off. I don't see *what* they've done - they're already done for and washed up. We're already past that point.
 
Carpet bomb em all and let God sort it out.

do you often call for the murder of innocent civillians and mention God in the same sentence?
 
The only reason Mexico hasn't collapsed already is that USA has acted as a safety valve on a pressure cooker. People coming here for jobs and money to send home has diffused the situation. Now with a bad US economy and no jobs for them to escape to the pot could explode. Then theres the Mexican gangs that basically run Mexico now It's a powder keg waiting for a match
 
do you often call for the murder of innocent civillians and mention God in the same sentence?

In a single word.... YES.

The more extensive explaination wouldn't do any good so I won't waste either of our time on it.
 
In a single word.... YES.

The more extensive explaination wouldn't do any good so I won't waste either of our time on it.

I suppose it's what Jesus would do?
 
I suppose it's what Jesus would do?

Jesus doesn't factor into the Gods that I pay attention to, Dezaad. I'm more a fan of Thor, Tyr, and Odin personally.
 
Jesus doesn't factor into the Gods that I pay attention to, Dezaad. I'm more a fan of Thor, Tyr, and Odin personally.

Ah so you're just a very conservative, tigger loving pagan, genocidal maniac then?
 
Even with horrific levels of violence, Mexico isn't in any real danger of collapse. However, this is no reason to not end the Drug War, a significant contributor to the violence.

That's a interesting thought. But how would making drugs legal here take power away from cartels based in countries where the drugs would probably remain illegal? People would still be forced to business with cartels right?

When you ban something that is in as high demand as drugs, you create a black market. In these markets there are no property rights, courts to settle disputes, or open advertisement. The most effective way of solving disputes is often violence. Just as ending Alcohol Prohibition reduced the power of organized crime, ending the drug war would reduce the power of drug cartels.

Yeah - instead of drugs to be in the green they'll peddle something else. . .

What other illicit goods and services could they sell that are anywhere near as profitable as the drug trade? No one says that ending the Drug War would eliminate organized crime. The goal is a serious reduction of it.

and instead of fighting off import of drugs we'll be fighting off laced hecks who dose up and hit the town fo ra night of mayhem and pillaging.


Wow - yes - a future of peace, security and safety.

There is very little evidence that the drug war has reduced hard drug use.

You know . . . from how things have GONE with Mexico I've already written them off. I don't see *what* they've done - they're already done for and washed up. We're already past that point.

The country has survived worse. They will find a way eventually.
 
Even with horrific levels of violence, Mexico isn't in any real danger of collapse. However, this is no reason to not end the Drug War, a significant contributor to the violence.



When you ban something that is in as high demand as drugs, you create a black market. In these markets there are no property rights, courts to settle disputes, or open advertisement. The most effective way of solving disputes is often violence. Just as ending Alcohol Prohibition reduced the power of organized crime, ending the drug war would reduce the power of drug cartels.



What other illicit goods and services could they sell that are anywhere near as profitable as the drug trade? No one says that ending the Drug War would eliminate organized crime. The goal is a serious reduction of it.



There is very little evidence that the drug war has reduced hard drug use.



The country has survived worse. They will find a way eventually.

All we need to do is look to Needles Park to see a fine example of what will happen to our entire COUNTRY if we legalized any illicit drugs.

I support legalization of marijuana - maybea few other soft drugs - but coke, crack, heroin, meth, lsd . . . all this? **** no. What benefit will that bring to *our* society? What will it *fix* and *improve* - If we legalized all these things then we'd become a magnet for the dreggs of the whole world - NOT just the US citizens alone. . .Good God, the possibilities are revolting and vile and you can't deny this is how things will unravel. We all know how dire addicts are - from occasional use to more use, shared needles, the spreading of disease - a plague on society. Crime rates will skyrocket - on and on. Geesh. Do I have to even paint this picture?

Sorry - but the plights of another country and how they do or don't deal with their problems is NOT my issue. I don't live there, I don't vote for their leaders - I live HERE. I vote HERE. What I want with my country is what matters. What I want with my town is what directly affects me and my children's safety.

The reason why the cartels GREW in strength is because they were given free-run, a blind eye, and even support from twisted politicians and law enforcement individuals. They created hteir own problems south of the border. We shouldn't have to flush our society even more on this baseless notion that if we do it - they'll be better off.

Haha - they never have been 'better' - they have so many more issues to deal with that have come from their own decisions and choices - trying to peg it all on us is offensive.
 
Last edited:
It could be true that they are collapsing. Just look at how they avoid major crises. They're very nonaligned.
 
They need someone with power, knowledge and charisma to come in and take **** over - for the better - and improve the plight of their people.

This hob-nobbed country they've had going on has been broken for so long it's pathetic. After all these years - after what their country DOES have to offer and what they CAN make use of for their success and they have yet to get a handle on anything.

Why not? Why have they become (rather: stayed) so broken?
 
Mexico has always been on the verge of collapsing, and always will. The question should really be, "Has Mexico ever NOT been in ruins?", awkward grammar notwithstanding.
 
All we need to do is look to Needles Park to see a fine example of what will happen to our entire COUNTRY if we legalized any illicit drugs.

That's because they decriminalized the drug and concentrated all of the addicts in one area. The problem was not legalization, but poor management.

I support legalization of marijuana - maybea few other soft drugs - but coke, crack, heroin, meth, lsd . . . all this? **** no. What benefit will that bring to *our* society? What will it *fix* and *improve* - If we legalized all these things then we'd become a magnet for the dreggs of the whole world - NOT just the US citizens alone. . .Good God, the possibilities are revolting and vile and you can't deny this is how things will unravel. We all know how dire addicts are - from occasional use to more use, shared needles, the spreading of disease - a plague on society. Crime rates will skyrocket - on and on. Geesh. Do I have to even paint this picture?

Most people don't avoid hard drugs due to legality, but because they don't want the negative health effects. The beauty of drug legalization is that it allows addicts to get help. Portugal has done something similar to what you describe. They have decriminalized all drugs. I know legalization and decriminalization are different; I'm getting to that. Critics warned of an explosion of drug addicts. Guess what happened. Hard drug use declined. Addicts could get help without fear of legal repercussions, and non-addicts had little interest in starting these hard drugs.

Now critics of legalization may say, "That's all fine and good, but what about increased use due to the price drop of legalized drugs." The evidence for this too, is weak. Firstly, the real price of heroin and cocaine are about half of what they were in 1980. Cartels can satisfy demand just fine right now. Secondly, the quantity demanded of hard drugs is pretty inelastic. Individual doses don't cost that much, the addict will probably not delay their purchase, and they will probably not substitute it. A change of price is unlikely to change chronic use


Sorry - but the plights of another country and how they do or don't deal with their problems is NOT my issue. I don't live there, I don't vote for their leaders - I live HERE. I vote HERE. What I want with my country is what matters. What I want with my town is what directly affects me and my children's safety.

The violence is already spilling over into this country. There's a reason why Phoenix is the kidnapping capital of the US.

The reason why the cartels GREW in strength is because they were given free-run, a blind eye, and even support from twisted politicians and law enforcement individuals. They created hteir own problems south of the border. We shouldn't have to flush our society even more on this baseless notion that if we do it - they'll be better off.

They only grew very violent after the Mexican government cracked down on them in 2006, but this misses the point. Do you see Google or GE running around with private armies, leaving the heads of rivals and journalists on street corners?

Haha - they never have been 'better' - they have so many more issues to deal with that have come from their own decisions and choices - trying to peg it all on us is offensive.

Most Mexicans have never enjoyed a higher standard of living. Since reform in the 1980's and 90's their economy has grown dramatically.
 
Last edited:
Interesting NPR interview detailing some of the reasons to be concerned.

Report: Mexico On Verge Of Collapse | WBUR & NPR
MADELEINE BRAND, host:

From NPR News, it's Day to Day. Mexico could collapse if it doesn't get control of the drug war there. That's the conclusion of two reports, one from the Defense Department, the other from former drug czar Barry McCaffrey, who says Mexico is, quote, "on the edge of the abyss."

NPR's Mexico City correspondent Jason Beaubien is in Tijuana. And Jason, that sounds pretty dire, "on the edge of the abyss." What are these reports saying?

JASON BEAUBIEN: Both of these reports are basically saying that the drug war in Mexico at the moment is escalating, and it's out of control in some parts of the country, and that the U.S. should be considering that these confrontations that the Mexican state is having with drug cartels almost all across the country could push the state into a failed state.

BRAND: A failed state. So what actually could trigger that? What could push Mexico over the edge?

BEAUBIEN: At the moment, you've got an escalation of this drug war. And when Felipe Calderon came in as president in 2006, he went after the drug gangs. And over the course of last year, that war escalated dramatically. You had a doubling of the killings. You've got parts of the country, particularly Juarez, to a lesser extent here in Tijuana, where the killings have just gone up astronomically. You have killings. Drug-related killings in Juarez increased five times last year.

Basically, police in Juarez have thrown up their hands and said, we cannot contain this. And they're not attempting to contain it. The state is no longer able to do what it needs to do in Juarez. And these reports are saying that that could spread quite dramatically to other parts of the country.

BRAND: So basically, the Mexican army and the police officers, they can't do anything? They can't outfight these drug gangs?

BEAUBIEN: Actually, I have a really interesting example in Juarez that just happened this week. You had a student from the university abducted by people in army uniforms. And the army yesterday released a press release saying, don't just take them for being army just because they're in army uniforms, and we aren't really responsible for his abduction and torture and killing.

The military went on to say that, you know, our people only move in groups of 15. So this clearly wasn't us that was doing it. It's that kind of lawlessness that is occurring and that's really a threat. These gangs are incredibly well armed. They've got billions of dollars worth of resources from the drugs that they're smuggling into the U.S. They're getting tons of weapons. There were a half a million rounds of ammunition seized in Mexicali earlier this week. They were coming in from the U.S. This is a war. This is being fought with military-style weapons. And these reports are pointing out that it's a real threat to U.S. security.

BRAND: So if they are out-financing, out-arming, and out-organizing the Mexican army, what can be done? What can the U.S. do?

BEAUBIEN: Well, the U.S. has put up $1.6 billion in the Merida Initiative. Only a fraction of that has actually gotten released. It's going to be for equipment and training. The Mexicans, on their side, are saying that they would like the U.S. to do more to curb demand for these drugs, which is fueling the drug cartels, and also clamp down on the weapons that are flowing from the U.S. back into Mexico. That's what the Mexicans would like to do.

Basically, these reports are saying the U.S. just really needs to be paying attention to this and giving more thought to what is going on and the seriousness of the problem that's occurring south of its border.

BRAND: Jason, thank you.

BEAUBIEN: You're welcome.

BRAND: That's NPR's Jason Beaubien reporting from Tijuana. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.
 
Back
Top Bottom