• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Judge orders Indiana DoC to give a baby killer his taxpayer-funded gender surgery

A boob job is not in any way, shape, or form, "necessary medical care" akin to cancer treatment.
It isn't necessary for transgender care. Many people never need it because of how the hormones affect them. This person likely got bottom surgery.


arrange a sex reassignment surgery for a transgender inmate convicted
 
If the murdering prick wants to turn himself in a woman, he better pony up the mullah for it. And the ACLU deserves nothing but ridicule for defending this idiot.



A federal district judge in Indiana has once again ordered the state Department of Correction (IDOC) to arrange a sex reassignment surgery for a transgender inmate convicted of reckless homicide of a baby, marking the latest development in the ongoing legal saga challenging an Indiana law banning the procedure.

The case, now in its second year, involves inmate Autumn Cordellioné's request for sex reassignment surgery. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) first filed the lawsuit against the Indiana Department of Corrections in 2023 on behalf of Cordellioné, challenging an Indiana law that prohibits the Department of Corrections from using taxpayer funds to cover sex reassignment surgeries for inmates. The ACLU argues the law is a violation of the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition of "cruel and unusual punishment."


Well, if the baby killer believes he's a woman and MUST receive gender affirming care then I figure a few crack heads in the jail are also capable of believing that they are surgeons and MUST be allowed to perform the surgery. Problem solved.
 
Well, if the baby killer believes he's a woman and MUST receive gender affirming care then I figure a few crack heads in the jail are also capable of believing that they are surgeons and MUST be allowed to perform the surgery. Problem solved.
Are they board certified surgeons? That might be kind of important.
 
Are they board certified surgeons? That might be kind of important.
Surgeons are always happy to cut people open. That's how they make their living.
 
Surgeons are always happy to cut people open. That's how they make their living.
Inmate crackheads are not board certified surgeons. Gender surgery is a very complex procedure, often requiring as decade of experience.
 
Inmate crackheads are not board certified surgeons. Gender surgery is a very complex procedure, often requiring as decade of experience.
Right. But if you sincerely believe you have those qualities then, by science, you DO have those qualifications.
 
Right. But if you sincerely believe you have those qualities then, by science, you DO have those qualifications.
Science isn't driven by beliefs. That would be religion, which is the opposite of science.
 
That would suggest that you dont understand the scientific method.
In recent years we have seen science, in a great many circumstances, manipulated (to use the most moderate term I can think of) for political purposes. It's like one of Kamala's Venn diagrams. You've got a "science" circle and a "political" circle and little by little they are bleeding together.
 
In recent years we have seen science, in a great many circumstances, manipulated (to use the most moderate term I can think of) for political purposes. It's like one of Kamala's Venn diagrams. You've got a "science" circle and a "political" circle and little by little they are bleeding together.
Do you have an example of this?
 
Do you have an example of this?
The transgender crap, the Covid vaccine crap, the mask crap and the lockdown crap are all the most recent examples. Add in the environmental propaganda and we’ve got a pretty good picture of how all this works
 
Just appeal, there is no way this gets past the current Supreme Court.

But that said, Federal law requires prisoners receive "necessary medical care" but that does not always mean "gender-affirming surgery" is always defined as "medically necessary" no matter the demands of a prisoner and/or the ACLU.

I do not have all the facts in this case, the article is not entirely clear on that, but until there is adequate explanation of why this is medically necessary for this specific prisoner then the government has a case.
 
The ACLU isn’t my favorite organization, but they have historically taken the side of civil rights even when it isn’t necessarily popular.

Has that changed?
Yeah child murderer saying gimme free boob job has absolutely nothing to do with civil rights.
 
The transgender crap, the Covid vaccine crap, the mask crap and the lockdown crap are all the most recent examples. Add in the environmental propaganda and we’ve got a pretty good picture of how all this works
Obviously you lack an understanding of medical and environmental science.
 
So the civil Right of murdering a child to get a free sex change?

If that's what they're arguing for their vile and need to be disbanded.
Even prisoner have innate rights to medical care while they are incarcerated. I'm a 30+ year member of the evil ACLU, so be careful about your claims of disbanding the Anthony Romero fan club. You might need their assistance some day being that you are a married gay man in Texas.
 
Last edited:
Even prisoner have innate rights to medical care while they are incarcerated.
This isn't medical care it's cosmetic surgery. He doesn't need a triple heart bypass he doesn't need a tumor removed. He'll live just fine without a boob job.
I'm a 30+ year member of the evil ACLU, so be careful about your claims of disbanding the Anthony Romero fan club.

You might need their assistance some day being that you are a married gay man in Texas.
They shouldn't be trying to reward murder with free boob job.

If The prisoner can afford it himself he can go for it it's elective it's not life-saving.
 
This isn't medical care it's cosmetic surgery. He doesn't need a triple heart bypass he doesn't need a tumor removed. He'll live just fine without a boob job.



They shouldn't be trying to reward murder with free boob job.

If The prisoner can afford it himself he can go for it it's elective it's not life-saving.
Who told you that she is seeking breast augmentation? She has been granted bottom surgery(orchi and vaginoplasty) because of severe gender dysphoria.

Cordellioné has been serving a 55-year murder sentence since 2002, after she was convicted of lethally strangling her infant stepdaughter. She is currently being held at the all-male Branchville Correctional Facility.

She was diagnosed with gender dysphoria in 2020, and was prescribed a female hormone and a testosterone blocker. Court documents have chronicled Cordellioné’s history of self-harm and suicide attempts, including attempts to remove her genitals.


Now, she seeks an orchiectomy to remove the testes and a vaginoplasty to construct a vagina.

Not providing such “necessary medical care to address a serious medical need” could be a violation of Cordellioné’s Eighth Amendment right protecting her from cruel or unusual punishment.
 
Who told you that she is seeking breast augmentation? She has been granted bottom surgery(orchi and vaginoplasty) because of severe gender dysphoria.
"Murder a child to get a free vagina" is not a good incentive structure.

"I am unhappy with my body" is not a good enough reason for taxpayers to pay for this for a child-muderer. I don't really care if he's unhappy with his body. He's in prison. Unless there's something actually medically unwell with his nether regions, he doesn't deserve anything. *At best* maybe he can pay for this extreme body mod out of his own pocket if he wants to.
 
"Murder a child to get a free vagina" is not a good incentive structure.

"I am unhappy with my body" is not a good enough reason for taxpayers to pay for this for a child-muderer. I don't really care if he's unhappy with his body. He's in prison. Unless there's something actually medically unwell with his nether regions, he doesn't deserve anything. *At best* maybe he can pay for this extreme body mod out of his own pocket if he wants to.
The 8th Amendment says otherwise.
 
The 8th Amendment says otherwise.
If a female inmate were unhappy with the shape of her nose or the size of her boobs, would she have an 8th Amendment right to get a free nose job or boob job? How about if inmates want taxpayer-funded collagen injections because they are unhappy with their skin?

Is there any limiting principle for what frivolous cosmetic procedures the taxpayers should fund for child murderers?
 
Back
Top Bottom