• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by law

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

SANFORD, Fla. – The fatal shooting of Trayvon Martin is bringing heated calls for the resignation of the local police chief, and the city's commissioners voted "no confidence" in the chief Wednesday night.

The commission voted 3-2 against Sanford Police Chief Bill Lee but can't fire him because the police chief reports to the city manager. City Manager Norton Bonaparte told the commissioners he would take their vote under advisement.

Earlier in the day, calls for firing Lee were met with standing ovations at an NAACP meeting here aimed at addressing outrage over the killing of 17-year-old Trayvon. The unarmed youth was shot Feb. 26 as he was returning to a gated community after buying candy at a convenience store.

Calls mount for police chief's firing in Trayvon Martin case
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Zimmerman was not instructed to stay inside of his car by the police or anybody else.

He was instructed by the procedures in place for neighborhood watchmen to avoid contact with a suspect.

I have not seen proof he did, though violating a neighborhood watch rule doesn't mean much. What evidence do you have that Zimmerman initiated the contact?

Neighborhood Watch Manual

[TABLE="class:data1"][tr][td]REMEMBER:

Community members only serve as the extra “eyes and ears” of law enforcement. They should report their observations of suspicious activities to law enforcement; however, citizens should never try to take action on those observations. Trained law enforcement should be the only ones ever to take action based on observations of suspicious activities.[/td][/tr][/table]
- page 22
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

I am part of the criminal justice system. I am a supervisor, state, but Fish and Wildlife. Same authority as troopers generally, but different task areas. I train cops with many departments, specifically in firearms and other confrontational situations. There are many reasons I should not and would not make a good patrol officer or what people call "a cop." At my residence is a country/state prosecutor - area is domestic violence, sex crimes, and child abuse. Another resident also is an officer in my field. I oft do things differently than other officers, but that isn't uncommon in us backwaters and backwoods types. I could probably quickly list 50 to 100 terrible flaws in the Criminal Justice System in addition to lists of false myths about it.

The original construction of arrest and trials as in the Constitution for the most part no longer exists and mostly contradicted. The general goal was to not hold people in prison or jail until found not-guilty. The presumption of innocence used to have more reality to it.

LOL a trout detective.

OMG hilarious

smokey the bear
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Neighborhood Watch Manual

[TABLE="class:data1"][tr][td]REMEMBER:

Community members only serve as the extra “eyes and ears” of law enforcement. They should report their observations of suspicious activities to law enforcement; however, citizens should never try to take action on those observations. Trained law enforcement should be the only ones ever to take action based on observations of suspicious activities.[/td][/tr][/table]
- page 22
That's pretty much what I understood they are supposed to do, which is why I couldn't figure out why this guy went to an elevated response in this case.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

That's pretty much what I understood they are supposed to do, which is why I couldn't figure out why this guy went to an elevated response in this case.
If he saw some dude walking down the street lighting up a molotov cocktail maybe that would justify immediate interdiction.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

LOL a trout detective.

OMG hilarious

smokey the bear

Got to correct you on one thing TD
it is "smokey bear" not smokey the bear. Smokey gets upset when people add "the"
Think you are confused with Da Bears:lol:
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Got to correct you on one thing TD
it is "smokey bear" not smokey the bear. Smokey gets upset when people add "the"
Think you are confused with Da Bears:lol:

just going by what we used to call them back when I was a kid-mainly state troopers who wore the bear hat too
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

I am part of the criminal justice system. I am a supervisor, state, but Fish and Wildlife. Same authority as troopers generally, but different task areas. I train cops with many departments, specifically in firearms and other confrontational situations. There are many reasons I should not and would not make a good patrol officer or what people call "a cop." At my residence is a country/state prosecutor - area is domestic violence, sex crimes, and child abuse. Another resident also is an officer in my field. I oft do things differently than other officers, but that isn't uncommon in us backwaters and backwoods types. I could probably quickly list 50 to 100 terrible flaws in the Criminal Justice System in addition to lists of false myths about it.
Is that where you learned to make up your own set of "facts" when the real events don't fit in neatly with your wishful thinking? You know, your own "facts" like Trayvon was kicking Zimmerman in the head and how Zimmerman was wearing a red shirt?
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

If he saw some dude walking down the street lighting up a molotov cocktail maybe that would justify immediate interdiction.
Absolutely in that case. At least yell "Stop now!" before but a kid walking down the street on a cell phone isn't exactly DEFCON 5.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Is that where you learned to make up your own set of "facts" when the real events don't fit in neatly with your wishful thinking? You know, your own "facts" like Trayvon was kicking Zimmerman in the head and how Zimmerman was wearing a red shirt?

I gotta give Joko credit. not in a million years would I have thought I'd be "liking" a bunch of your posts :mrgreen:

night all
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

just going by what we used to call them back when I was a kid-mainly state troopers who wore the bear hat too
Yep! Wasn't until later that State troopers got the "Super Trooper" moniker.

Absolutely in that case. At least yell "Stop now!" before but a kid walking down the street on a cell phone isn't exactly DEFCON 5.
Not to be too picky but isn't DEFCON 5 the lowest state of readiness. Did you mean DEFCON 1? ;)
 
Last edited:
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

I gotta give Joko credit. not in a million years would I have thought I'd be "liking" a bunch of your posts :mrgreen:

The feeling's mutual.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Yep! Wasn't until later that State troopers got the "Super Trooper" moniker.

Not to be too picky but isn't DEFCON 5 the lowest state of readiness. Did you mean DEFCON 1? ;)
Could be. I was more pushing a point through than anything but whichever is the right answer works for me.

EDIT - You're right, 1 is the most severe. DOH!
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

um...why would a guy with a gun, be yelling for help?
A guy who was being attacked was yelling for help, when it appeared that no help was forthcoming he then used his firearm in self defense, once there stopped being a threat, he stopped yelling for help.

Yeah, so just why would he be yelling for help?
Ahh - how about he didn't want to resort to using his firearm first.
You all have your minds so set that Zimmerman is at the wrong that you are overlooking the simplest explanations that fit the evidence.



He may not be white but he's not black either and most certainly sounds racist. Did you hear him on the 911 call saying "****ing coons"?
:thinking:
I heard the recording.
The first time I listened with no expectation I heard "punk".
After being told what to listen for I heard "coon".
Just recently when reviewing the 911 call and not specifically listening for that section I heard "punk" again.

It appears that many others have the same experience.

It needs much more analysis from qualified individuals before it has any purposeful meaning.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

If the case is considered legitimately, it exactly fact question it most turns on is who was shouting for help as that appears to be the first moment a gun came into the picture. The girl on the phone with Martin instantly prior to that moment has no recount of Martin mentioning a gun. Accordingly to the 13 year old eye witness, the only one, Zimmerman was on the ground. The nature of the shot to the chest putting Martin over him.

Did Zimmerman pull out a gun that Martin grabbed trying to hold it off of him - maybe that even pulling it towards himself - as Martin shouted for help? Or Did the gun come into the picture possibly falling out as Zimmerman went down and a struggle over the gun with Zimmerman shouting for help?

The spontaneous comment of Zimmerman to the police specifically quoted was he yelled for help but no one would help him. This was at the scene. But Martin's mother said she is certain the very muffled sound in the background of the phone call was her son calling for help. Those very few seconds are what matters.

Everything prior to that is just circumstances drawing a picture of what lead to that moment. From those, negatives can be painted about both of them. Whether forensics and pick out that voice and positively identify it is the most relevant fact of the case and very possibly the decisive one.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Even assuming what we're hearing is "air rushing by the mic" are you saying the wind speed never changes? Or that one is always facing the correct direction for the mic to pick up the wind? That assertion is full of wind ...
Actually it isn't full of wind.
Martin was running away.
Zimmerman then began to follow.
The mic noise cued the operator's question, and then suggested that they didn't need him to do that.
Zimmerman replied with an "ok", and the mic noise went away.
I alleged at that point Zimmerman stopped following him as the operator suggested.
We then later learn that Zimmerman had lost the individual.
The mic noise going away and losing his observation of Martin is consistent with his following the operators advice at that point in time, is it not?

We then later learn, that as Zimmerman was on his way back to his truck, Martin attacked him from behind.

All of this happened in a short period of time and I would like to see a timeline of those events.
As it is, it is all consistent with the evidence of his statements and that of the girlfriends.



Ok. Lets try another tack.

Nobody here knows what happened. Afaik, the only person who knows for sure is Zimmerman. And he's sticking to his story, so far.

I'm a pattern recognizer. I'm pretty good at "people". From what we have heard, Zimmerman is EXACTLY the kind of jackass who gets in peoples faces and throws his authority around (real or imagined). The kind who acts like such an ass that he gets his ass kicked. Which is PROBABLY what happened.

Now it is possible that Martin had a history of violence or a confrontational demeanor or some other factor that will cause me to alter my assessment.

But I don't think its gonna happen, and here's why:

This is a high profile firearm self defense case.

A Public Relations NIGHTMARE.

I promise you that as soon as this case drew national attention, an intensive investigation of Martin was launched. A standard crisis management response in PR. And the gun lobby has great PR people. If he was a "bad-egg" it would be all over the internet, but its not.

People who don't fight normally don't pick fights with much larger opponents in unfamiliar territory. I just can't get a model to run where an up-to-this-point good kid picked THAT time and place to go all "gangsta" on an innocent neighborhood watch guy. Just jump on him and start kicking this guys ass, when he's never jumped on anybody and kicked their ass before.

All it takes is a lucky punch in the face followed by falling back across the sidewalk to account for Zimmermans reported injuries. Hell, you could catch a guy with an elbow shrugging a hand off your shoulder. Heck, you might even start yellin like a little girl if some great big sucker grabbed ahold of you. Even a sissy fight could result a broken nose and an overweight person simply falling backwards.

Only Zimmerman knows, and if the truth will make him look like a jackass, he will never tell.

But it is FAR more likely that he is the responsible party. That had he not acted, nothing would have happened.

That Martin would have walked home and enjoyed his Skittles and iced tea while watching the game with his dad.

The course of his life was fatally altered by the actions of Zimmerman. There is NO evidence to the contrary. None. Martin was COMPLETELY innocent until Zimmerman acted as far as anyone knows.

He was just walking home from the store.
I don't think you realize it, but you just admitted that you have a preconceived way of looking at things.
Sometimes that can be good, at others times - not so much.

Look, I am not trying to be an ass towards you, but I know this is going to come across that way.
What skills you think you have, even if you do, even if you are a professional profiler, so what?
And so far I haven't seen you read the evidence correctly. So what does that say about your supposed skills?

Other people with those skills have an opposite opinion of yours. So What!

This isn't about you or them.

This is about the evidence, and so far I have seen things said that are not true, and speculation that is based on that untrue information, all coming from those who want to see Zimmerman found guilty no matter what.

The majority of these people are looking at this case through biased glasses.

I have watched as joko104 has tried over and over again to set the record straight with accurate information, but no one bothered to listen and they kept on giving the false information over and over again. All because they got it in their head that Zimmerman was wrong from the get.

Stick with the evidence, and what the evidence says. Everything else will fall into place.
Even the behavior of the two involved.




Zimmermann had NO right and NO authority, to confront and question ANYONE!!!!!
Says who?

Besides, your narrative is off.
Martin confronted Zimmerman first, as evidenced by the girlfriends statement.
It was only after this did he question martin.
says who???

says the law.

only LEOs have the right to stop & question a suspect.

anyone else doing it is illegally preventing a citizen form going on his way. its called unlawful imprisonment.
Please cite the law that says so.
If you can't, then please stop making statements about things you don't know.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Neighborhood Watch Manual

[TABLE="class:data1"][tr][td]REMEMBER:

Community members only serve as the extra “eyes and ears” of law enforcement. They should report their observations of suspicious activities to law enforcement; however, citizens should never try to take action on those observations. Trained law enforcement should be the only ones ever to take action based on observations of suspicious activities.[/td][/tr][/table]
- page 22

Most on this thread claim merely watching Martin was made Zimmerman the aggressor and all neighorhood watch people according are aggressors.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Dennis Baxley, a Republican state representative and co-author of the 2005 self-defense law, said Zimmerman negated his ability to claim immunity under the law by chasing Martin.
...
Zimmerman had no right to follow and confront Martin in the first place, Caranna noted.
...
Maybe the FBI investigation will conclude the same things that the authors of the bill in question have. I hope so.

This one is a case for a jury to decide. He should be arrested.
You do realize that it doesn't matter what he thinks, right? And apparently he doesn't even have the correct information about what happened to even form an opinion on the matter.
All that should matter is if Zimmerman's actions are within the letter of the law.
If they are, he will be cleared.
If not, he will be found guilty of a crime.



It was most likely the kid yelling for help.

[video]http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/us/2012/03/21/tsr-zarrella-trayvon-martin.cnn[/video]
Here it is on YouTube.

It does not establish that "it was most likely the kid yelling for help."

What it does establish is one of Zimmerman's statements to the police.
"Zimmerman's statement was that he had lost sight of Trayvon and was returning to his truck to meet the police officer when he says he was attacked by Trevon"
Note: It doesn't say he was attacked from behind as others have reported.



I'm pretty sure Zimmerman (as other neighborhood watch captains) are aware of a list of easy guidelines (local PD) that...***If you see someone in your neighborhood (possible gated community) that you don't recognize, call us. There is no harm in us (cops) talking to them and ascertaining their identity and purpose in the area*** Its plain and simple to follow

Anything further than calling, giving description and location is NOT advisable

Cops take over...talk and de-escalate the situation before it gets to the point of acting out

Zimmerman must have known this
There is nothing that says he couldn't maintain observance until the police arrived.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

The last thing we heard from Zimmerman was that Martin was running away.
That was basically the last thing he told the 911 operator, but definitely not the last thing we heard from him.



What makes more sense? 28 year old pudgy Zimmerman, self appointed community watch captain, shoots a 17 year old resident of his community
More biased disinformation.
He was not a resident of the community.



He was in his car. Trayvon was running away from him. The only way there was contact, which occurred away from Zimmerman's car, is if Zimmerman got out of his car and went after him.
You might want to check the evidence again.
From what I have heard, he was out of his truck when he reported Trayvon running.


I chase no one. Zimmerman chased Trayvon. There is no other way there could have been a confrontation between them unless Zimmerman, against neighborhood watch procedures, went after him. Even according to Zimmerman, Tray was running away.
There is no evidence that he "chased" him.
Evidence that he tried to keep him under observation ? Yes. But not chase him.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Is that where you learned to make up your own set of "facts" when the real events don't fit in neatly with your wishful thinking? You know, your own "facts" like Trayvon was kicking Zimmerman in the head and how Zimmerman was wearing a red shirt?

The 13 year old only eye witness to the fight said that it was Zimmerman on the ground during the fight. Two women said after Martin was dead, Zimmerman was over him maybe trying to help Martin and told them to call the police.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Is that where you learned to make up your own set of "facts" when the real events don't fit in neatly with your wishful thinking? You know, your own "facts" like Trayvon was kicking Zimmerman in the head and how Zimmerman was wearing a red shirt?

It's late and I know it can be difficult for some people to follow a thread for even 2 pages. I was responding to someone who said I have a "hard on" against the Criminal Justice System because of my opinion that most defendants should be imprisoned upon conviction, not as pre-trial punishment and pressure to plea guilty to get out.
As opposed to what your experience and knowledge is about the Criminal Justice System, which I suspect you get from watching detective and cop fictions on TV.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

You do realize that it doesn't matter what he thinks, right? And apparently he doesn't even have the correct information about what happened to even form an opinion on the matter.
All that should matter is if Zimmerman's actions are within the letter of the law.
If they are, he will be cleared.
If not, he will be found guilty of a crime.

(the video)
It does not establish that "it was most likely the kid yelling for help."

What it does establish is one of Zimmerman's statements to the police.

Note: It doesn't say he was attacked from behind as others have reported.




There is nothing that says he couldn't maintain observance until the police arrived.


Most on this forum are claiming that neighborhood watch actions are illegal aggression. And we are in the world of the anti-gun-rights crowd on this forum, though some will deny it.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

If he saw some dude walking down the street lighting up a molotov cocktail maybe that would justify immediate interdiction.

Yes, you have made your apathy about others and your community quite clear.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

A guy who was being attacked was yelling for help, when it appeared that no help was forthcoming he then used his firearm in self defense, once there stopped being a threat, he stopped yelling for help.

Yeah, so just why would he be yelling for help?
Ahh - how about he didn't want to resort to using his firearm first.
You all have your minds so set that Zimmerman is at the wrong that you are overlooking the simplest explanations that fit the evidence.




I heard the recording.
The first time I listened with no expectation I heard "punk".
After being told what to listen for I heard "coon".
Just recently when reviewing the 911 call and not specifically listening for that section I heard "punk" again.

It appears that many others have the same experience.

It needs much more analysis from qualified individuals before it has any purposeful meaning.

On the 911 call, Zimmerman didn't even mention the race of the "guy" until asked specifically by the police and even then wasn't certain - until when following him he said Martin had turned about and was approaching Zimmerman. The race-profiling popular mantra doesn't work.
 
Re: Family of Florida teen killed by neighborhood watch volunteer feel 'betrayed' by

Most on this forum are claiming that neighborhood watch actions are illegal aggression. And we are in the world of the anti-gun-rights crowd on this forum, though some will deny it.

I've been on this thread most of the day -- I haven't seen people claiming that neighborhood watch avtions are illegal aggression. I've seen people claim that Zimmerman going out of his way to accost this individual is inappropriate. Someone earlier posted up the internet site for neighborhood watch organizations -- says quite clearly that those involoved should be calling the police -- NOT intervening on their own.

Many of the posters who are up in arms about Zimmerman's actions are gun enthusiasts and vigorously defend gun ownership and right-to-carry. Just shows gun supporters aren't as partisan as Dems and Reps.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom