• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

El Salvador’s President Says He Won’t Return Man Who Was Mistakenly Deported

Why are you circling a bush? Is this a Don Jr. kink? If so... well... you do you, dude.

You do you.
*sigh* Just more posted idiocy from phoenix2020.
 
You seem to be the most upset over this alleged wrongful Garcia incarceration. Do you know why you're upset Garcia can't get back to America? He's just one person who got swept up along with other tattooed thugs in the wrong place at the wrong time. Why is he so important to you?
Is he the latest Cause célèbre that the anti-Trumpers can use this week to hammer Trump and his Administration?

As is typical of a MAGA conservative, you fail the empathy test. You lot only care when its you or a family member directly affected.
 
You seem to be the most upset over this alleged wrongful Garcia incarceration. Do you know why you're upset Garcia can't get back to America? He's just one person who got swept up along with other tattooed thugs in the wrong place at the wrong time. Why is he so important to you?
Is he the latest Cause célèbre that the anti-Trumpers can use this week to hammer Trump and his Administration?
Indeed as the dangerous dude is a member of MS-13 who has been officially recognized as a terrorist organization. Plus he was here illegally. Those facts alone justify deportation.

Why the left has chose this a hill to die on is quite perplexing..
 
Do the right thing and get him home.

Anyone who thinks the treatment of Mr Garcia is ok, is an asshole and they disgust me.
This is as much about defying the Supreme Court as it is about Garcia. Trump doesn't care about people's lives. He's on his way to absolute power. We're slowly becoming an autocracy. Four years. This is far beyond being an asshole.
 
Indeed as the dangerous dude is a member of MS-13 who has been officially recognized as a terrorist organization. Plus he was here illegally. Those facts alone justify deportation.
He wasn't deported. Deportees are shipped across the border and dropped off. Garcia was sent to the gulag.

Why the left has chose this a hill to die on is quite perplexing..
The left? Is the National Review the left?


The left and conservatives know a Nazi when they see one.
 
Indeed as the dangerous dude is a member of MS-13 who has been officially recognized as a terrorist organization. Plus he was here illegally. Those facts alone justify deportation.

Why the left has chose this a hill to die on is quite perplexing..
I think reasonable people can see this case and see that there are troubling elements.

1. He is here illegally, deportation is justified, I've seen nothing to justify imprisonment in El Salvador.
2. An order preventing his deportation is in place, whether it should be or not, is a separate issue. The gang that this person is fearful of no longer exists.
3. As a Salvadoran citizen, he is imprisoned in El Salvador and I'm not clear what law he violated other than being in the US illegally. If US due process isn't fully being follwed, then certainly El Salvador should apply their laws.
4. The President has talked about deporting US citizens. Absolutely F'in, not.
 
Indeed as the dangerous dude is a member of MS-13 who has been officially recognized as a terrorist organization. Plus he was here illegally. Those facts alone justify deportation.

Why the left has chose this a hill to die on is quite perplexing..

Trump is disobeying the Supreme Court.

Why do Trump supporters hate the Constitution?
 
You seem to be the most upset over this alleged wrongful Garcia incarceration. Do you know why you're upset Garcia can't get back to America? He's just one person who got swept up along with other tattooed thugs in the wrong place at the wrong time. Why is he so important to you?
Is he the latest Cause célèbre that the anti-Trumpers can use this week to hammer Trump and his Administration?

1. If some people dont have due process, no one has due process.

2. Trump is disobeying the Supreme Court.

Why do Trump supporters hate the Constitution?

3. Trump is now saying he wants to do this to U.S. citizens. Do you agree?
 
Add to this the idea that Trump is open to sending our own US citizens to foreign prisons, and we are in a very, very dark place as a country.



The door is open to US citizens being “disappeared”.

We are a third world junta.
 
You seem to be the most upset over this alleged wrongful Garcia incarceration. Do you know why you're upset Garcia can't get back to America? He's just one person who got swept up along with other tattooed thugs in the wrong place at the wrong time. Why is he so important to you?
Is he the latest Cause célèbre that the anti-Trumpers can use this week to hammer Trump and his Administration?

Because he represents a 180 degree paradigm shift from a Democratic Constitutional Republic to a third world junta.

The true question is why wouldn’t he be to ANYONE that fancies themselves an actual patriot?
 
1. He is here illegally, deportation is justified, I've seen nothing to justify imprisonment in El Salvador.
Did it not dawn on you he is a terrorist?
An order preventing his deportation is in place, whether it should be or not, is a separate issue. The gang that this person is fearful of no longer exists.
The AG disagrees
 
Why? The Trump Administration already admitted that this man was apprehended by mistake. He shouldn't be sent anywhere, except home to his family.

He was unlawfully in the country and is entirely deportable.
 
Abducting people inside the country is a domestic issue. It doesn't become foreign policy by shipping them to the gulag in El Salvador.

Nobody was 'abducted.' Mr. Garcia was unlawfully in the country and thus subject to deportation.
 
Look, this isn't difficult. I respond the way I chose.
Indeed.

Your questions to me were irrelevant.
So you chose to reply to with something totally irrelevant? Weird, but ok.

What I think the Court intended is irrelevant, as such is speculation, not factual.
Hmm. I’ve seen a few if your posts. “Factual” does not seem to be your strong point.

Good luck to you,
 
He was unlawfully in the country and is entirely deportable.
I can always count on you to attempt to defend the indefensible. When someone is in the country unlawfully, they get put on a plane back to their native country, not sent to a prison compound. In any case, Abrego Garcia, was granted protections by an U.S. immigration judge to stay in the United States. That means he could not be deported. Nevertheless, he was rounded up and sent to a gulag in El Salvador with the U.S. government saying it as an “administrative error.”

Team Trump has been blatantly contradicting each other, some maintaining for weeks that his expulsion was an “administrative error.” Other Trump advisers suddenly and falsely declared, Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia, had been lawfully sent to a prison in El Salvador.

The White House also sought to portray a recent Supreme Court ruling in Mr. Abrego Garcia’s case as a victory when in fact the decision was a nuanced one. It partly found in favor of Mr. Abrego Garcia while also leaving open a loophole for the administration to avoid bringing him back from El Salvador.

The efforts by the Trump administration to misrepresent the case came as President Nayib Bukele of El Salvador announced after a meeting with Trump that his government would not return Mr. Abrego Garcia to U.S. soil, in spite of the Supreme Court unanimously saying he's due, due process and should be returned.
 
Trump spoke with Bukele, obviously, and that's about all he can do. That's also pretty much the limit of what ANY court can instruct him to do.
Trump and his fellow criminal morons are openly mocking our laws with their "oops" and discussing expanding their terror campaign to include U.S. citizens.
 
Back
Top Bottom