- Joined
- Jan 7, 2013
- Messages
- 8,762
- Reaction score
- 5,360
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- Political Leaning
- Independent
Re: What Are The Roots of The Modern Left's Obsession with Promoting Sex and Hedonism
Part of the confusion is that you're conflating social terms with political ones. They are not necessarily interchangeable. If you want to talk social politics then we should stick with that -- just a suggestion.
Okay, ideologically... I can concede to that. In the general diaspora of social leftism, Hedonism is included, and thus can be found there, BUT there are so many exceptions to this that it undermines what you're saying. Behaviorally, there is no real distinction between leftists and rightists. Both are engaged in the same behaviors. One pretends they aren't while the other openly admits it.
The right often calls out the left for being obvious, but the right is not aware of its own cognitive dissonance. Again, I am speaking to social platforms, not individuals.
But see, here's the thing... Hedonism is incredibly specific, which is why I object to your broad use of it. I would argue that practicing Hedonists are on the far left of the spectrum, and rare; though, if you talk to most Hedonists, they don't associate with left or right, they associate with whatever lets them get what they want. Thus you find Hedonists among both right and left camps.
During the Spanish Inquisition, many of the far-right Inquisitors were also Hedonists. They reveled in causing pain because it brought them pleasure. During the Edwardian period, many of the right-wing aristocratic nobles were Hedonists... they shaped social mores in order to support their lordships, while living extremely lavish and self-indulgent lifestyles.
It's not black and white.
It's not. You are using the term "Hedonism" too flippantly. Please research Hedonism as a stand-alone topic and you'll understand your misattribution.
Nope. You can't say that sexual liberals are all Hedonists. Hedonism is its own camp. Again, please research.
Huh?
Can you please identify parts of my argument you find unconvincing, rather than use an ad hom?
I agree... but there are no legal institutions impeding the co-existence of these values. There are, on paper, equal. Most people live in the moderate zone. Hyperpartisanism makes it seem otherwise.
You can't just claim that Hedonism is part of a leftist movement and not have that questioned. Sorry, it doesn't work that way. Looking into the origins of "said ideology" assumes that your premise is correct to start with, and it isn't.
In order to address the origins of Hedonism, we need to detangle your misuse of various terminologies. Foremost, we need to question your underlying assertion that sexual liberation and instant gratification culture = leftism = Hedonism. I can't just delve into your premise without pointing out the flaws and cognitive dissonance in your opinions because what you're saying is patently inaccurate, even academically.
That's not true. I am questioning how you identify said ideologies, their roots, and their manifestations in human behavior.
For example... it's common for people on the right to call out sexual liberation as Hedonism and therefore leftist, but they reject critical analysis of their use of these terms. Why? I don't think you fully understand what Hedonism is, and how Hedonists are a distinct sub-group.
Regardless if it's a right or left thing, you haven't explained why Hedonism is corrosive to society. You claim there is a culture war yet you aren't accurately identifying its components and aggravating factors. Basically I just don't know what you're talking about other than the usual "blame the left" non-sense.
Part of the confusion is that you're conflating social terms with political ones. They are not necessarily interchangeable. If you want to talk social politics then we should stick with that -- just a suggestion.
Reference to "the Left," as a generalized whole, is appropriate.
Okay, ideologically... I can concede to that. In the general diaspora of social leftism, Hedonism is included, and thus can be found there, BUT there are so many exceptions to this that it undermines what you're saying. Behaviorally, there is no real distinction between leftists and rightists. Both are engaged in the same behaviors. One pretends they aren't while the other openly admits it.
The right often calls out the left for being obvious, but the right is not aware of its own cognitive dissonance. Again, I am speaking to social platforms, not individuals.
"Hedonism" is a far more broad term. It applies to many aspects of one's life, not just sex.
But see, here's the thing... Hedonism is incredibly specific, which is why I object to your broad use of it. I would argue that practicing Hedonists are on the far left of the spectrum, and rare; though, if you talk to most Hedonists, they don't associate with left or right, they associate with whatever lets them get what they want. Thus you find Hedonists among both right and left camps.
During the Spanish Inquisition, many of the far-right Inquisitors were also Hedonists. They reveled in causing pain because it brought them pleasure. During the Edwardian period, many of the right-wing aristocratic nobles were Hedonists... they shaped social mores in order to support their lordships, while living extremely lavish and self-indulgent lifestyles.
It's not black and white.
I would, actually, view that as being a form of "sexual hedonism."
It's not. You are using the term "Hedonism" too flippantly. Please research Hedonism as a stand-alone topic and you'll understand your misattribution.
They are close enough, overlap enough, and all enjoy more than enough support from the generalized "Cultural Left," to merit grouping them together for the purposes of this discussion.
Nope. You can't say that sexual liberals are all Hedonists. Hedonism is its own camp. Again, please research.
Are you completely unfamiliar with the cultural upheaval of the 1960s and the rise of the "New Left?"
Again... Have you just not been paying attention, or what?
Huh?
Can you please identify parts of my argument you find unconvincing, rather than use an ad hom?
Our culture is the literally the most "polarized" it has ever been right now.
I agree... but there are no legal institutions impeding the co-existence of these values. There are, on paper, equal. Most people live in the moderate zone. Hyperpartisanism makes it seem otherwise.
Besides which, I might remind you again that the point of this thread isn't to discuss the merits of the Left's ideology (I've beaten that horse beyond death already). It's to discuss the origins of that ideology.
You can't just claim that Hedonism is part of a leftist movement and not have that questioned. Sorry, it doesn't work that way. Looking into the origins of "said ideology" assumes that your premise is correct to start with, and it isn't.
In order to address the origins of Hedonism, we need to detangle your misuse of various terminologies. Foremost, we need to question your underlying assertion that sexual liberation and instant gratification culture = leftism = Hedonism. I can't just delve into your premise without pointing out the flaws and cognitive dissonance in your opinions because what you're saying is patently inaccurate, even academically.
You basically seem to want to just flat out deny that ideology exists at all as an entity separate and distinct from anything else. That frankly strikes me as being more than a bit dishonest and nonsensical.
That's not true. I am questioning how you identify said ideologies, their roots, and their manifestations in human behavior.
For example... it's common for people on the right to call out sexual liberation as Hedonism and therefore leftist, but they reject critical analysis of their use of these terms. Why? I don't think you fully understand what Hedonism is, and how Hedonists are a distinct sub-group.
Regardless if it's a right or left thing, you haven't explained why Hedonism is corrosive to society. You claim there is a culture war yet you aren't accurately identifying its components and aggravating factors. Basically I just don't know what you're talking about other than the usual "blame the left" non-sense.