• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

US shuts down major San Diego port of entry as migrants rush border

5k is close to what various local groups have been estimating. That said I don't think the entire crowd rushed the border. There is reportedly a core of agitators and radicals that have been trying to create confrontation.
Thanks.

Yeah, it's starting to look the way you've described it. 5K held-up in some athletic field of some sort, being provided some form of basic humanitarian aid. 500 of which decided to rush the border.

Forcing the closure of that crossing is not going endear the caravaners to the local population who use that to go back and forth to jobs on the US side then go home to Tijuana.
That's an interesting point, thanks for making it. I was thinking Trump might get some heat for the lost trade and employment, if he can't figure-out a way to get the crossing open by Monday A.M.
 
The only place those exist is in your imagination.

Not true; Bernie Sanders gets a hard-on just thinking about the Scandinavian Socialist Republics. And at HIS AGE that's quite an accomplishment.


<begin usual Tanngrisnir "you lie" insult fest>
 
So you're saying this is because of Tequila.

I am saying that you are making justifications for illegally entering a country...
 
I'm not blaming the US. I'm keeping perspective. A crowd of 500 gets unruly every day in the Western world and we don't mow them down.

No one is getting shot. This isn't Iraq.

Let's keep perspective.

I didn't mean to imply you were blaming the US. I know you better than that. I was speaking for myself in relation to the overall tenor of this thread, not you.

I do, respectfully, maintain that your view here - concert goers vs aliens crossing a border illegally - is overly simplistic.
 
Last edited:
Given even the U.S.'s failure to maintain a border, I'm not sure Mexico has the ability to do so either. I'm all for secure borders, but I'm not sure Mexico has that capability.
Me, neither. It's a dangerous and volatile situation.
 

I've never heard of the saying "that which is common, not that which bites". :shrug: And "news of shoplifting at Walmart is man bites dog" sounds awfully silly to me. Incongruous.
 

Well, if you like, we could lean the other way... "invaders are over-running the fortifications, mow them down and fix bayonets!"

Because that's the tone of the thread I have a problem with. People are always gonna blame the US. But pretending a gaggle of people in line - who are trying to do things the right way - becoming unruly because the procedures are changing are some kind of threat is hateful.
 
And, I forgot to mention that there are several malls and outlet centers close to the crossing that cater to cross-border shoppers. AND this is one of the busiest shopping days of the weekend. The fecal matter is definitely about to hit the rotating ventilation device. :hitsfan:
 

No one, at least not me or the US government at this point, are advocating for "mow them down and fix bayonets." However, there are many in this thread and in the US government on the left that are, and have advocated, for "let them all in and then let them all loose" which is tantamount (IMHO) to open borders. Closing the border is not comparable to killing people, or even arresting people for rioting. It's simply not dealing with a problem that at this point is not our problem; it's the problem of the Mexican Government. If we allow them to cross over the border, then it's the problem of the US tax payer. With that, I have a problem. The US was allowing any and all that wanted to claim asylum to do so in a manner that was controlled, measured, and methodical.

Bum rushing the border to circumvent US law is not a way to make the average US citizen feel empathy for you (you being the aliens, not you).
 
Bum rushing the border to circumvent US law is not a way to make the average US citizen feel empathy for you (you being the aliens, not you).

And it's not a threat. So let's not suffer any violence fantasies.
 

Seems you and others on DP didn't know this was going to happen. Probably because the anti-Trump multimedia echo chamber has deliberately ignored the ongoing developments.

The fact is, this action by the migrants was preplanned by the organizers of the caravans.


Here's another article: https://www.theepochtimes.com/honduran-migrant-20000-plan-to-march-across-border_2723034.html

So...it's a safe bet that the Mexican and US LE were aware this was going to happen ahead of time, too. They certainly seemed to be prepared.
 
Tear gas has been fired from the US side........

Tell me those tear gas shells did not fly across the border.

Because if they did, this just became an international incident far, far more serious than a few hundred people clamoring to get into the US.
 
And it's not a threat. So let's not suffer any violence fantasies.

Although it is a threat, it is not at this time a violent threat, so in essence, I agree with your basic position. As for not suffering fantasies, the reality of the situation will dictate with time, what is fantasy and what is not, and until then I don't think we should suffer fantasies of Utopian origin nor of violent origin, yet in place we should strive for a cautious but peaceful shepherding of our border. In the mean time, as I said, I agree with your basic position.
 
Tell me those tear gas shells did not fly across the border.

Because if they did, this just became an international incident far, far more serious than a few hundred people clamoring to get into the US.

Nah. Cops teargas college students at campus events. We have agreements with Mexico about cross-border enforcement.

It's still just an unruly crowd, complaining about changes, going nowhere.
 

So this includes US citizens. Guess Trump really did close the border without congressional approval. Did he really sign the secret E.O. He was talking about earlier??? This is nuts.
 
Although it is a threat, it is not at this time a violent threat, so in essence, I agree with your basic position.

My position is we don't fantasize about violence against basically innocent crowds. We keep perspective and understand this happens every day and no one gets shot.


Fantasies of tomorrow don't matter. I'm concerned with what is in essence a line of concert goers rushing the gates being framed as threats worthy of killing. Why?



As long as we're not suffering that, you can have at the US-haters. I'm in no mood for them.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…