• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

THE PANIC OVER TRANS SPORTS INCLUSION

Apparently you subscribe to the belief that women are inherently inferior.

How does that compare to the best time by a transwoman?

No. I subscribe to the fact females are physically slower/weaker in sports compared to the equivalent male level.

Male puberty confers a hell of an advantage.
 
Just watched the1500m heats in the men's under 20 world athletics championships (so teenagers).

The winning times were 5 seconds quicker than the adult women's world record... In the opening heats for teenage boys.

The boys under 18 world record for the 1500m is 16 seconds quicker than the adult women's world record.
Uh, the winning cisgender boys were not on HRT with female hormone levels, were they? Those drugs have a very obvious difference with muscle loss and additional body fat.
 
Apparently you subscribe to the belief that women are inherently inferior.
In feats of strength yes they are. That biological reality. So telling me that I subscribe to reality is a compliment
How does that compare to the best time by a transwoman?
You mean a man?
 
Uh, the winning cisgender boys were not on HRT with female hormone levels, were they?
Who cares. Poisoning a child with incorrect hormones for their biology makes them weaker.
Those drugs have a very obvious difference with muscle loss and additional body fat.
Muscle and body fat aren't near his relevant as male puberty.

Did you remember what a freshman museum of high school boys not only won a game with easy utmost easily female soccer players but totally destroyed them? It's because they're going through male puberty.

Now if you castrate a child with castration drugs false related to puberty blockers that they're not going to develop into adults at all. Maybe just be forever creepy blessings and will probably compete on the same level as an 8 year old child.

It's not a fundamental new idea that poisoning and crippling a child will make them perform poorly.
 
Who cares. Poisoning a child with incorrect hormones for their biology makes them weaker.

Nobody is poisoning anyone. That is another MAGA lie. Someone who is trans has a gender identity that is different from their biology. Those hormones are given to transition their body, as much as current medical science permits, to align with their gender identity. They are not being poisoned.
Muscle and body fat aren't near his relevant as male puberty.

The effects of puberty are irrelevant if they don't have the muscle mass/strength to move their arms and legs. An atrophied male in a wheelchair or who is aged has the same bones from puberty but if they lack the muscle mass to move those bones they can't even stand upright without assistance.
Did you remember what a freshman museum of high school boys not only won a game with easy utmost easily female soccer players but totally destroyed them? It's because they're going through male puberty.
They also had male muscle mass, unlike someone who is transfem, who is both weaker and has a higher body fat.
Now if you castrate a child with castration drugs false related to puberty blockers that they're not going to develop into adults at all. Maybe just be forever creepy blessings and will probably compete on the same level as an 8 year old child.

Your sentences are illogical. Do you offer MAGA to English subtitles, or you could learn how to write so your ideas could be understood by others.
It's not a fundamental new idea that poisoning and crippling a child will make them perform poorly.
Now you are denying that gender identity exists, despite a century of medical evidence otherwise. Your denials don't change facts.
 
Nobody is poisoning anyone.
Giving someone something that is outside of their natural body in the effort to stunt their growth is absolutely poisoning
That is another MAGA lie.
So that means it's truth.
Someone who is trans has a gender identity that is different from their biology.
That's a mental disorder and all doctors should be restrained from treating children who appear to have this mental disorder until they reach the age of 18.
Those hormones are given to transition their body, as much as current medical science permits, to align with their gender identity. They are not being poisoned.
There is this zero medical credit to this. You cannot transition your body it can't happen. It is given to people to stunt and cripple their body to obtain a certain look.

A gender identity again you seem to have trouble understanding of this is just words you say about yourself it's nothing more.
The effects of puberty are irrelevant if they don't have the muscle mass/strength to move their arms and legs.
If they're irrelevant then why are there puberty blockers? Why is there transition at all what would you need it for? Every other thing you're saying suggests that the effects of puberty are extremely relevant.
An atrophied male in a wheelchair or who is aged has the same bones from puberty but if they lack the muscle mass to move those bones they can't even stand upright without assistance.
I don't know what point do you think they're trying to make here but you're not really making one.
They also had male muscle mass, unlike someone who is transfem, who is both weaker and has a higher body fat.
Amen who identifies as a woman is the same as a man who identifies as a leprechaun or a dinosaur or a stove.

We are still talking about men.
Your sentences are illogical.
Your entire thought process is illogical.
Do you offer MAGA to English subtitles, or you could learn how to write so your ideas could be understood by others.
Now we're pretending we don't understand because your argument sucks. Every time you do this it's just absolutely pathetic.

You might as well just throw yourself on the floor and kick your heels and scream that's the equivalent of this
Now you are denying that gender identity exists,
As anything more than words you say about yourself absolutely. It was a dreamed up to help people with a mental disorder cope with their mental disorder. It doesn't apply to anyone outside of this mental disorder.
despite a century of medical evidence otherwise. Your denials don't change facts.
There is absolutely no medical evidence that gender identity is anything more than words you say about yourself.

In fact that's all identity is as a whole I can identify as a leprechaun or a dinosaur or a table and people do. And it's every bit as legitimate as if I identified as a woman or a non-binary magical space unicorn.
 
Giving someone something that is outside of their natural body in the effort to stunt their growth is absolutely poisoning

It is not about stunting their growth.
So that means it's truth.

That's a mental disorder and all doctors should be restrained from treating children who appear to have this mental disorder until they reach the age of 18.

Not treating gender until the age of 18 would be a criminal act, the same as not treating depression anxiety or childhood cancer.
There is this zero medical credit to this. You cannot transition your body it can't happen. It is given to people to stunt and cripple their body to obtain a certain look.

More nonsense.
A gender identity again you seem to have trouble understanding of this is just words you say about yourself it's nothing more.

Such as being gay? Gay rights by your ideas are wrong because they are just words you say about yourself.
If they're irrelevant then why are there puberty blockers? Why is there transition at all what would you need it for? Every other thing you're saying suggests that the effects of puberty are extremely relevant.

I don't know what point do you think they're trying to make here but you're not really making one.

Amen who identifies as a woman is the same as a man who identifies as a leprechaun or a dinosaur or a stove.

Gender identity isn't claiming to be non-human.
We are still talking about men.

Only if you deny gender identity exists.
Your entire thought process is illogical.

Now we're pretending we don't understand because your argument sucks. Every time you do this it's just absolutely pathetic.

You might as well just throw yourself on the floor and kick your heels and scream that's the equivalent of this

As anything more than words you say about yourself absolutely. It was a dreamed up to help people with a mental disorder cope with their mental disorder. It doesn't apply to anyone outside of this mental disorder.

There is absolutely no medical evidence that gender identity is anything more than words you say about yourself.

In fact that's all identity is as a whole I can identify as a leprechaun or a dinosaur or a table and people do. And it's every bit as legitimate as if I identified as a woman or a non-binary magical space unicorn.
Mindless nonsense.
 
It is not about stunting their growth.
That's exactly what it's about. It's about stopping them from developing the way they naturally would that's growth.
Not treating gender until the age of 18 would be a criminal act, the same as not treating depression anxiety or childhood cancer.
You can't treat it there's no treatment for it. Wish you were born male I thought seniors after your death of people that dig up your bones will know you were male.

You're stuck in the body you have that's it that's all you get you can alter it surgically but it doesn't change what it is
More nonsense.
More pathetic running away.
Such as being gay? Gay rights by your ideas are wrong because they are just words you say about yourself.
That's only us being gay and lying about your sex is the same thing it's not.
Gender identity isn't claiming to be non-human.
Yes it is if you will claim to have changed your sex humans can't do that so yeah it's not human.

If you can change your sex why can't you change your species what if someone has a species identity you have a species identity.

And that's 100% to every bit as credible as gender identity.
Only if you deny gender identity exists.
I don't deny it exists I denied it at some sort of magical ingrained inherent thing that nobody can measure unless they hear words you say.
Mindless nonsense.
More pathetic running away.
 
That's exactly what it's about. It's about stopping them from developing the way they naturally would that's growth.

That is how gender dysphoria is treated in teens.
You can't treat it there's no treatment for it. Wish you were born male I thought seniors after your death of people that dig up your bones will know you were male.

Incoherent nonsense.
You're stuck in the body you have that's it that's all you get you can alter it surgically but it doesn't change what it is

This are the limits of current medical science. The Drs do what is possible. Not treating it is criminal and will lead to the death of the patient.
More pathetic running away.

That's only us being gay and lying about your sex is the same thing it's not.

Yes it is if you will claim to have changed your sex humans can't do that so yeah it's not human.

Rambling nonsense.
If you can change your sex why can't you change your species what if someone has a species identity you have a species identity.

Its not possible tio change your species.
And that's 100% to every bit as credible as gender identity.

I don't deny it exists I denied it at some sort of magical ingrained inherent thing that nobody can measure unless they hear words you say.

More pathetic running away.
Until someone thought about and discussed sexual orientation with a Dr or psychologist there was also no evidence of it existing. This is how research begins.
 
That is how gender dysphoria is treated in teens.
I think this problem with the way we treat it in children we don't look for whether or not it's a symptom everybody's just so gung-ho to show how woke they are and they don't bother to take the time to ask themselves if they should.
Incoherent nonsense.
Pathetic running away
This are the limits of current medical science. The Drs do what is possible. Not treating it is criminal and will lead to the death of the patient.
They do what's possible which is absolutely nothing. There is no treatment you can't change your sex. If you were born male when you die you'll be male if you pop your penis inside out it doesn't mean that it's not a penis.

It just means that it's a disfigured that's all.
Rambling nonsense.
Pathetic running away.
Its not possible tio change your species.
It's not possible to change your sex.
Until someone thought about and discussed sexual orientation with a Dr or psychologist there was also no evidence of it existing. This is how research begins.
Except for when women prefer to be with women. Gay or homosexuality is a description of a behavior not an identity.
 
I think this problem with the way we treat it in children we don't look for whether or not it's a symptom everybody's just so gung-ho to show how woke they are and they don't bother to take the time to ask themselves if they should.

Pathetic running away

They do what's possible which is absolutely nothing. There is no treatment you can't change your sex. If you were born male when you die you'll be male if you pop your penis inside out it doesn't mean that it's not a penis.

Rambling nonsense at a 6th grade understanding of science.
It just means that it's a disfigured that's all.

Im open to your ideas, if you have better ideas, (Dr) Clax. When and where did you go to medical school?
Pathetic running away.

It's not possible to change your sex.

Except for when women prefer to be with women. Gay or homosexuality is a description of a behavior not an identity.
Sexual identity refers to one's self-perception in terms of romantic or sexual attraction towards others, though not mutually exclusive, and can be different from romantic identity. Sexual identity may also refer to sexual orientation identity, which is when people identify or dis-identify with a sexual orientation or choose not to identify with a sexual orientation. Sexual identity and sexual behavior are closely related to sexual orientation, but they are distinguished, with identity referring to an individual's conception of themselves, behavior referring to actual sexual acts performed by the individual, and sexual orientation referring to romantic or sexual attractions toward persons of the opposite sex or gender, the same sex or gender, to both sexes or more than one gender, or to no one.
 
Thanks for conceding.

I didn't concede anything.
Don't need a medical degree to understand humans can't change sex
The current level of medical science is far from perfect. That doesn't mean that what is done to change sex so as it more closely aligns with their gender idneity is being done when requested. Medicine is in a constant state of change as new techniques are developed for all treatments.

Your binary understanding of the situation doesn't change the fact.
It's just words you say about yourself.
You didn't read what I posted because you are agreeing with me.
 
I didn't concede anything.
When you dismiss an argument rather than addressing it yes you are and that's just how it's going to be from now on.
The current level of medical science is far from perfect.
And completely absent again we're just talking about words you say about yourself.

Identity is just words you say about yourself.
That doesn't mean that what is done to change sex so as it more closely aligns with their gender idneity is being done when requested. Medicine is in a constant state of change as new techniques are developed for all treatments.
Nothing can be done touching sex that's not possible that's like changing your species not possible.

Someone who's born male can turn into a female the same way someone is born human can turn into a house cat.
Your binary understanding of the situation doesn't change the fact.
Write the fact is that it's binary and delusions that it's not doesn't change the fact that it is.
You didn't read what I posted because you are agreeing with me.
No I don't read Wikipedia opinions it's an ideologically captured nonsense website. If you try to change it even if you have all the credentials you need some social justice warrior stops you. This is how I know what's wrong you don't need to get keepers for truth. You need gatekeepers for lies.
 
When you dismiss an argument rather than addressing it yes you are and that's just how it's going to be from now on.

It was dismissed because you didn't make any valid point that could be addressed, Your outrage is irrelevant.
And completely absent again we're just talking about words you say about yourself.

Identity is just words you say about yourself.

Nothing can be done touching sex that's not possible that's like changing your species not possible.

Someone who's born male can turn into a female the same way someone is born human can turn into a house cat.

Write the fact is that it's binary and delusions that it's not doesn't change the fact that it is.

Rambling nonsense.
No I don't read Wikipedia opinions it's an ideologically captured nonsense website. If you try to change it even if you have all the credentials you need some social justice warrior stops you. This is how I know what's wrong you don't need to get keepers for truth. You need gatekeepers for lies.
Is Wikipedia now part of the deep state? :LOL:
 
It was dismissed because you didn't make any valid point that could be addressed, Your outrage is irrelevant.


Rambling nonsense.

Is Wikipedia now part of the deep state? :LOL:
This is getting away from the point I noticed you doing that when you don't have an argument to make.

Identity whether it's with a social construct like gender is just words you say about yourself.

If it's not show me in the genome show me in the hormones show me in the biology anywhere. You can't do that. So as a result you resort to this kind of crap which is just conceding you just don't understand that that's what you did.
 
Did anyone sew the Gabi Garcia fight when she fought a man smaller and lighter than her and was thoroughly beaten? Again, biological men have a physical advantage. It has been proven time and time again.
 
Did anyone sew the Gabi Garcia fight when she fought a man smaller and lighter than her and was thoroughly beaten? Again, biological men have a physical advantage. It has been proven time and time again.
Not very good there seems to be this effort to gaslight people.

It's the new end of the activism. So all along people who are trans has been around for quite a number of years we just transition and go about their lives people wear relatively okay with it it might have seemed a little weird but to each their own.

They knew they were women or men they just wanted to present themselves as not that decide which is fine. That wasn't enough a lot of these people think they have the right to your mind. You must think of them as women or men respectively you must affirm them as women or men respectively. It changed from being passive to active.

I wonder if this is not an effort to undermine transsexualism.
 
They knew they were women or men they just wanted to present themselves as not that decide which is fine. That wasn't enough a lot of these people think they have the right to your mind. You must think of them as women or men respectively you must affirm them as women or men respectively. It changed from being passive to active.

I wonder if this is not an effort to undermine transsexualism.
Where do you get this moronic schlock? Matt Walsh or Chaya Raichek?

Who told you there is a difference between transgender and transsexual? 25 years ago, 99% of people who are transgender would have been called transsexual. The only difference is that nonbinary and gender fluid did not exist as an idea in the 1980s/90s.
 
Where do you get this moronic schlock? Matt Walsh or Chaya Raichek?
Buck Angel let me guess he's transphobic?
Who told you there is a difference between transgender and transsexual? 25 years ago, 99% of people who are transgender would have been called transsexual. The only difference is that nonbinary and gender fluid did not exist as an idea in the 1980s/90s.
Even you like my own experience tells me there is a difference men who identified as women weren't trying to lie to themselves about actually being women they weren't saying they were biological women. They understood they were men.

The delusion is a modern-day thing.
 
Buck Angel let me guess he's transphobic?
It does seem to appear that he is stuck in the 1990s and has some internalized transphobia. He is not a happy person.
Even you like my own experience tells me there is a difference men who identified as women weren't trying to lie to themselves about actually being women they weren't saying they were biological women. They understood they were men.
This doesn't make a bit of sense. You need to learn to proofread and use proper punctuation.
The delusion is a modern-day thing.
Transgender people arent delusional. If they were delusional then they would not be trans because that is two separate diagnoses. It appears that you know nothing about the subject that you are trying to discuss.
 
It does seem to appear that he is stuck in the 1990s and has some internalized transphobia. He is not a happy person.
Because he didn't lie about being male?
This doesn't make a bit of sense. You need to learn to proofread and use proper punctuation.
You moan about this sort of thing because you can't address the point
Transgender people arent delusional.
If they are a trans woman that think they are women or trans men that think they are men yes they are.
If they were delusional then they would not be trans because that is two separate diagnoses.
If you try to trick yourself into believing you are a woman when you're a man that identifies as a woman that's delusional.
It appears that you know nothing about the subject that you are trying to discuss.
People can't change their sex, and identity is just words you say about yourself.
 
No. I subscribe to the fact females are physically slower/weaker in sports compared to the equivalent male level.

Male puberty confers a hell of an advantage.
In other words, weaker is inferior.
 
Back
Top Bottom