• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Star Wars - The Great Hunt =Game Thread=

If Helix is scum, why not fake claim an investigation on me?

1. He was more on your side Day 1 (he wasn't giving me a town read.
2. Look at the number of players that had bought in, to some extent, regarding your BS about me: Thor, The Mark, YourStar, X Factor...

It seems to me that, if Helix is scum attempting a fake claim, it makes A LOT more sense for him to go after me.
 
Tucker Case said:
We both can't be insane. It'd be just as crazy as having two doctors.
Click to expand...

A body guard and a doc that dies if he targets scum is not out of the realm of sanity.
 
Tucker Case said:
Makes more sense that you are the target of the vig kill because that erases the "hated" problem altogether.
Click to expand...

Why would scum want to erase the Hated problem?
 
Tucker Case said:
Because scum wants you around. Known hated benefits scum the most.

Stop half assing your analyses.
Click to expand...

You claimed that Helix would rather vig me because that eliminates the problem. We were under the scenario that Helix is scum.
 
Hint: all of the other roles that appear as the Jack of all trades powers were represented in this game, it only makes sense that the vig would be as well. A smart vig holds their fire until they are fairly sure they don't hurt town.
 
ecofarm said:
You claimed that Helix would rather vig me because that eliminates the problem. We were under the scenario that Helix is scum.
Click to expand...

As I have said, stop half-assing your analyses. We have a tracker. We have doc protection for that tracker. Now think about what can be done with that.
 
Tucker Case said:
Hint: all of the other roles that appear as the Jack of all trades powers were represented in this game, it only makes sense that the vig would be as well. A smart vig holds their fire until they are fairly sure they don't hurt town.
Click to expand...

Ok, you've had your 15 minutes.

I think The Mark is the 3rd scum, but I doubt we're going to establish that Today (and thus I don't see a reason to stall). I think Helix should shoot Thor.

##vote: Tucker



Can we get a vote count? I think Tucker is L-2.

Look at it this way, Tucker, if you're Town at least you'll find out if you're sane... If you're town, I assure you that you're sane and thanks for making me known Town.
 
Actually, I assure that you're insane. I'd lost track of your claims.
 
I forgot Tucker claimed I was guilty in the slew of his other crap.

If you are town, Tucker, I assure you that you are insane. We're about to find out for sure whether you're town.
 
Before we lynch someone, I think I should tell everyone who I plan on protecting. That way, if I die, town will have another scum identified. Of course, if I am the only one to die, then it means that I was targeted by scum.

Right?

ecofarm said:
Ok, you've had your 15 minutes.

I think The Mark is the 3rd scum, but I doubt we're going to establish that Today (and thus I don't see a reason to stall). I think Helix should shoot Thor.

##vote: Tucker



Can we get a vote count? I think Tucker is L-2.

Look at it this way, Tucker, if you're Town at least you'll find out if you're sane... If you're town, I assure you that you're sane and thanks for making me known Town.
Click to expand...
 
I think we should Track The Mark.
 
Chaddelamancha said:
Before we lynch someone, I think I should tell everyone who I plan on protecting. That way, if I die, town will have another scum identified. Of course, if I am the only one to die, then it means that I was targeted by scum.

Right?
Click to expand...

If you and someone else dies, then we know your target caused your death. But shouldn't you protect Helix? I dunno.
 
ecofarm said:
If you and someone else dies, then we know your target caused your death. But shouldn't you protect Helix? I dunno.
Click to expand...

not unless it is determined that i'm sane. if i'm broken / malfunctioning R2D2, then who knows what my other powers will do. if that's the case, i doubt that i'll use them.

that being said, i want to hear some other opinions before i consider voting Tucker.
 
I think The Mark's alternate claim is C3PO.
 
Helix said:
not unless it is determined that i'm sane. if i'm broken / malfunctioning R2D2, then who knows what my other powers will do. if that's the case, i doubt that i'll use them.

that being said, i want to hear some other opinions before i consider voting Tucker.
Click to expand...

Ok, so if Tucker flips Town, then who does Chad protect?
 
ecofarm said:
Ok, so if Tucker flips Town, then who does Chad protect?
Click to expand...

i don't have an opinion at this point, because i'm not entirely sure which doc is telling the truth.
 
I think Chad should protect Helix if Tucker flips scum and Vance if Tucker flips town.
 
It will be determined that you are sane only after Tucker is lynched. I doubt that you are insane.

The only two ways that I think I can help tonight is either target someone for protection and if I (and another player) die, then we have found scum. But I can only assume that if I pick a scum person to protect, then scum will just kill me anyways. If I choose a town to protect, then scum is free to kill whomever. The problem with this is, what if they kill VM? Then we won't know the results of his tracking. So that brings me to the second way I can help, protecting VM so he can do his tracking.

In the case of Helix, I believe his Vig should still go through, even if targeted for a night kill right? If not, then perhaps I am better off protecting him.
Helix said:
not unless it is determined that i'm sane. if i'm broken / malfunctioning R2D2, then who knows what my other powers will do. if that's the case, i doubt that i'll use them.

that being said, i want to hear some other opinions before i consider voting Tucker.
Click to expand...
 
Helix said:
i don't have an opinion at this point, because i'm not entirely sure which doc is telling the truth.
Click to expand...

Whichever is telling the truth will do what town recommends.
 
ecofarm said:
(quoted you for attention)

Game technicality question:

If vig kills the scum attempting to night kill, does the scum's night kill go through?
Click to expand...

All night actions occur simultaneously unless otherwise noted. The only exception would an ability that directly counters or prevents another, like a doc or a jailkeeper. Those obviously resolve before the actions they are countering or preventing. If two killers take aim at each other during the night, both will die.

Also, I'll post a vote count later today.
 
Chaddelamancha said:
It will be determined that you are sane only after Tucker is lynched. I doubt that you are insane.

The only two ways that I think I can help tonight is either target someone for protection and if I (and another player) die, then we have found scum. But I can only assume that if I pick a scum person to protect, then scum will just kill me anyways. If I choose a town to protect, then scum is free to kill whomever. The problem with this is, what if they kill VM? Then we won't know the results of his tracking. So that brings me to the second way I can help, protecting VM so he can do his tracking.

In the case of Helix, I believe his Vig should still go through, even if targeted for a night kill right? If not, then perhaps I am better off protecting him.
Click to expand...

I'm pretty sure that Helix's vig will go through even if he gets killed.

You protecting Vance works for me, as I remain a bit queasy about the who Thor thing. Since you know if you're town, you could have less doubt about that whole situation. If you're town then Helix is town but I don't see an absolute guarantee on Vance yet (via my perspective). So, if he's scum maybe we find out. If you don't die, we know he is town. If he's town, we're protecting our Tracker anyway.

Leaving it open, Helix or Vance, based upon a scum flip by Tucker, could also work to our advantage. With you targeting one of those two, scum might have to avoid both.

Now, a town flip by Tucker. If you know Helix is town, this means he is insane and will probably not use his Vig. In this case, you should target Vance (who's Thor scenario is not directly linked to Tucker) and perhaps YourStar.

I think we can protect two players by you having 2 possible targets. We protect Helix/Vance if Tucker scum and Vance/YourStar if Tucker is town. You can choose a different second target for the 'Tucker = town' scenario, that's just off the top of my head.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom