• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Second Shutdown?

so, you would die for Wall St?

I would be willing to die for Wall Street, Main Street and Church Street, as well as Constitutional Avenue, but not for Dummass Democrat People's Republic of Communist Coup Street.
 
As he should have. Why do you have a problem with a Governor doing his job?

He's not the moron. That's Cuomo. Compare the death toll

Compare the populations, good grief
 
I have to agree that handwashing, masks, and social distancing are the best we can do for now and that shutdowns have run their gambit.

We never really shut down. it was a 20% shutdown 80% business goes on. We should have done 3 weeks anybody seen outside gets executed on the spot. No exceptions. It would be over by now.
 
We never really shut down. it was a 20% shutdown 80% business goes on. We should have done 3 weeks anybody seen outside gets executed on the spot. No exceptions. It would be over by now.

I keep hearing this BS that we didn't have a shutdown. I bet 40 million unemployed wouldn't agree or the 100,000 businesses that closed.
 
I keep hearing this BS that we didn't have a shutdown. I bet 40 million unemployed wouldn't agree or the 100,000 businesses that closed.

The same study that came up with the 100K small business number also said that represented an overwhelming TWO PERCENT of small businesses :lamo
 
The same study that came up with the 100K small business number also said that represented an overwhelming TWO PERCENT of small businesses :lamo

Do you think 100K businesses closing permanently is funny? What about the unemployment numbers? You're right the economy is strong and everyone else is crazy, there was no shutdown. :roll:
 
Compare the populations, good grief
Florida has more people, more elderly, but one tenth of the deaths per capita. Did you think Florida was a small state?
 
I will die for Jesus, and I will give my life to protect tens of millions of young and middle aged Americans from economic ruin brought on by democrats .

How will you do that? How do you even imagine you can do that?
 
100% false.

DeSantis has a sterling track record so far. Perhaps you should have paid some attention to the results in Florida vs those in New York and New Jersey.

LMAO - yeah ... those millions of Florida commuters on subways and busses sure did a better job, didn't they?
 
Why do we need a second if the first one was useless?

Assumes facts not in evidence. The first one was incalculably useful. It flattened the curve. It kept the hospitals from being completely overrun with patients. That not only saved countless virus victims, but all the other victims that wouldn't have even had a bed in a hospital available after getting hit by a truck.
 
As he should have. Why do you have a problem with a Governor doing his job?

He's not the moron. That's Cuomo. Compare the death toll

Seriously? How ignorant can you be? Name one other governor, of ANY states, that had 5.6 MILLION PEOPLE riding their subways EVERY WORKING DAY!
Don't bother - because you can't even come close.
 
A 2nd shutdown would be absolutely preposterous and uncalled for, mainly because the 1st shutdowns solved nothing. The vast majority of people are not going to stand for it - again.

How about a more reasonable and balanced approach? Leave it up to individual states or local governments to enforce social distancing, mask-wearing and sanitation guidelines, but forcing everything to close is an extremist move that devastated the economy much harder than the Corona virus.
 
Florida has more people, more elderly, but one tenth of the deaths per capita. Did you think Florida was a small state?

By a small margin, but NY is packed in less size and mainly in large cities.
 
Seriously? How ignorant can you be? Name one other governor, of ANY states, that had 5.6 MILLION PEOPLE riding their subways EVERY WORKING DAY! Don't bother - because you can't even come close.
You said it yourself. Your Governor encouraged people to use public transit, without masks. It's a factor, but only one of them. The big hit came in the care facilities, which did not use the trains. Compare NYC to other major metro cities around the world.

By a small margin, but NY is packed in less size and mainly in large cities.
More is not less. NYC is not as densely packed as several other cities, also with major dependence on mass transit. It stands as, by far, the worst case.

Again, Florida has more seniors, but one tenth the deaths. You cannot shrug that off.
 
You said it yourself. Your Governor encouraged people to use public transit, without masks. It's a factor, but only one of them. The big hit came in the care facilities, which did not use the trains. Compare NYC to other major metro cities around the world.


More is not less. NYC is not as densely packed as several other cities, also with major dependence on mass transit. It stands as, by far, the worst case.

Again, Florida has more seniors, but one tenth the deaths. You cannot shrug that off.

You seem to be ignoring how it is growing daily in Florida, and other Open States. This would not be happening if we had waited until we actually met the WH/CDC guidelines and we Required SD and PPE's. Now here in Texas the Governor is back peddling and saying local officials can require businesses to require the wearing if masks. Better late than never, too bad many will die because those in charge wanted to ignore the virus and wish it away.
 
So, DeSantis says they are not shutting down again, full stop. Denies that the fast reopening has anything to do with FL's current crazy numbers. But, some bars and restaurants in Jacksonville are again shutting down after reopening.

Florida bars and restaurants close just a week after reopening | The Independent



How do y'all see this playing out? It seems like a Republican leader is determined to not eat crow on a reckless reopening. But, how long can you continue to exacerbate the problem?

People understand things shouldn't have been shut down in the first place. Most people understand now this was just a leftwing ploy to shut down the economy, damage capitalism and hurt Trump. People WANT to work and make money, and they KNOW the leftwing bastards don't have their interests at heart.
 
I think the shutdowns are effective. They took my state from 2,000 cases a day to 200 in about 3 months.

EVerybody KNEW the leftwing media would say the re-openings failed and would cite deep-state CDC phony numbers to back them up. I predicted this long ago. I further predict media coverage of this virus sham will DISAPPEAR after election day, especially if they are able to steal it for the senile Biden.
 
You said it yourself. Your Governor encouraged people to use public transit, without masks. It's a factor, but only one of them. The big hit came in the care facilities, which did not use the trains. Compare NYC to other major metro cities around the world.


More is not less. NYC is not as densely packed as several other cities, also with major dependence on mass transit. It stands as, by far, the worst case.

Again, Florida has more seniors, but one tenth the deaths. You cannot shrug that off.

Despite your false equivalencies, there is simply no comparison with any other city. The Number 6 Train ALONE carries more passengers than ALL OTHER SUBWAYS in the country combined !!

And please provide a link where Cuomo "encouraged people to use public transit without masks". Or better yet, don't even waste your time looking.
 
Despite your false equivalencies, there is simply no comparison with any other city. The Number 6 Train ALONE carries more passengers than ALL OTHER SUBWAYS in the country combined !! And please provide a link where Cuomo "encouraged people to use public transit without masks". Or better yet, don't even waste your time looking.
You are a fine one to talk of false equivalents. Try comparing NYC to Seoul, Hong Kong, London, Paris, Istanbul, Moscow, Mexico City, Sao Paulo, Lima, Bogota, Rio. Seoul is a good one. It's about the same size and has more people in public transport.
 
EVerybody KNEW the leftwing media would say the re-openings failed and would cite deep-state CDC phony numbers to back them up. I predicted this long ago. I further predict media coverage of this virus sham will DISAPPEAR after election day, especially if they are able to steal it for the senile Biden.

Everybody knows the right wing is full of fallacy and don't care about True Witness bearing simply for the sake of morals, unless they allege to be bakers.
 
EVerybody KNEW the leftwing media would say the re-openings failed and would cite deep-state CDC phony numbers to back them up. I predicted this long ago. I further predict media coverage of this virus sham will DISAPPEAR after election day, especially if they are able to steal it for the senile Biden.

1. the re-openings can be a reaso2n/has shown to be part of the reason why the virus is still going way too strong. Which is why the Orange Overlord Trump doesn't want to talk about it anymore, you know, as the pathetic fake leader that he is.

2. left wing media? In your case that is an illogical statement, you are so conservative that almost all media seems left wing. That is not the fault of the media but more your extreme conservative points of view.

3. the virus will only disappear after a vaccine is introduced. And you do know this is a world wide virus? That poor leadership in the US has caused it to keep festering is not the fault of the media but more of the politicians. But as it is a world wide illness, it is rather illogical/total nonsense to claim it will disappear after the beginning of November because of the US election. That is conspiracy nonsense, not anything factual.

4. Biden really has to do very little, Trump, the republican party and Bolden are doing all of Biden's work. He will fairly win this election.

PS. it was Trump who "stole" the election last time around so it is rather illogical to talk about stolen elections.
 
You are a fine one to talk of false equivalents. Try comparing NYC to Seoul, Hong Kong, London, Paris, Istanbul, Moscow, Mexico City, Sao Paulo, Lima, Bogota, Rio. Seoul is a good one. It's about the same size and has more people in public transport.

I see. So now, unable to counter my point about no state in the country having anything even remotely approaching the mass transit density of New York, you want to make comparisons with Seoul? SEOUL !!??!! Do you really want to go there? All you’re doing is highlighting the total catastrophic FAILURE of the Trump administration! If that’s what you meant to do, you’ll get no argument from me.

Here’s a list of some of the States that ALL have HIGHER Covid 19 death rates than the entire country of South Korea!

Indiana
Iowa
Tennessee
South Carolina
Alabama
Missouri
Mississippi
Ohio

. . . . Shall I go on? And these States don’t have a significant fraction of the population of South Korea. In fact, their total combined population doesn’t even equal South Korea. And by the way - those are all States with Republican governors!

So whatever point you’re trying to make about New York seems even less feeble than trying to compare apples to a water color painting of beach volleyball.

Like I said, if your intention was to lay the blame for the Covid 19 fatalities on Trump’s total FAILURE as a president, you’ll get no argument from me.
 
I see. So now, unable to counter my point about no state in the country having anything even remotely approaching the mass transit density of New York, you want to make comparisons with Seoul? SEOUL !!??!! Do you really want to go there? All you’re doing is highlighting the total catastrophic FAILURE of the Trump administration! If that’s what you meant to do, you’ll get no argument from me. Here’s a list of some of the States that ALL have HIGHER Covid 19 death rates than the entire country of South Korea!
Indiana
Iowa
Tennessee
South Carolina
Alabama
Missouri
Mississippi
Ohio
. . . . Shall I go on? And these States don’t have a significant fraction of the population of South Korea. In fact, their total combined population doesn’t even equal South Korea. And by the way - those are all States with Republican governors! So whatever point you’re trying to make about New York seems even less feeble than trying to compare apples to a water color painting of beach volleyball. Like I said, if your intention was to lay the blame for the Covid 19 fatalities on Trump’s total FAILURE as a president, you’ll get no argument from me.
Seoul has a larger transit system than NYC. So, you acknowledge that the transit system is not the issue. Thanks for that.
 
Seoul has a larger transit system than NYC. So, you acknowledge that the transit system is not the issue. Thanks for that.

No - as I said, and is not in dispute, NYC has the largest transit system IN THE COUNTRY! You have yet to disprove that. Feel free to try again.
So, you must acknowledge that it has been the catastrophic FAILURE of the Trump administration, because you've come up with no defense, and not even any response, to the fact that 8 States with a cumulative population LESS than the country of South Korea ALL have higher individual Covid casualties. Thanks for that.

And please try to spare us all anymore feeble false equivalencies.
 
Back
Top Bottom