davidtaylorjr
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 30, 2013
- Messages
- 6,775
- Reaction score
- 1,123
- Location
- South Carolina
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Very Conservative
The question is Was Roberts bribed or blackmailed?
Let me ask you this, then. What argument do you have that the supreme court's decision is wrong or improper? You might disagree with their reasoning, but they are empowered to make that decision, not you. Or are we actually debating Marbury v Madison?
you are suggesting that John roberts was bribed or blackmailed?
what if he made his decision out of his own volition.
Then he's an idiot or politically motivated. Neither of which is proper for the job.
I'm saying the Supreme Court decision isn't even relevant to the discussion.
And neither is bad mouthing something that hasn't even taken effect yet. It's like you know it will work and that's why you can't let it happen.
Why do liberals keep shouting that Obama Care is Constitutional the Supreme Court said so? How is that relevant to the argument that while it may be Constitutional it isn't good for the American people? What is the logic there? I guess the liberals realize they don't have a good argument for the ACA so they keep running to the Supreme Court decision on the mandate.
many liberals consider judges alito and scalia to have the same problems, but the only way anyone can leave the supreme court is if they choose to step down.
Because republicans challenged the constitutionality of the law and the supreme court said it was constitutional. Since they didn't win that argument, they started with their 42 repeal votes. Be that as it may, people had their chance to say no to the ACA and not re-elect Pres Obama but they did. The ACA is here to stay.
Because republicans challenged the constitutionality of the law and the supreme court said it was constitutional. Since they didn't win that argument, they started with their 42 repeal votes. Be that as it may, people had their chance to say no to the ACA and not re-elect Pres Obama but they did. The ACA is here to stay.
You show your case against them and I might just very well agree. In the mean time, someone needs to tell me how Roberts can use the taxing and spending clause that can only be used towards the enumerated powers when nothing about forced commerce falls under any the powers given to congress. Don't even try the commerce clause unless you can show an on going trade dispute between the 'listed' members. Of course, I have no idea how you are going to show that people not having insurance is a trade dispute between anyone.
I don't know what Roberts argued in his ruling.
but roberts can use the taxing and spending clause with relation to the affordable care act because the mandate was ruled as a tax, and i presume that by using the Neccessary and proper clause as justification, the congress can use the powers of the taxing and spending clause to enforce the insurance mandate.
Because republicans challenged the constitutionality of the law and the supreme court said it was constitutional. Since they didn't win that argument, they started with their 42 repeal votes. Be that as it may, people had their chance to say no to the ACA and not re-elect Pres Obama but they did. The ACA is here to stay.
Because republicans challenged the constitutionality of the law and the supreme court said it was constitutional. Since they didn't win that argument, they started with their 42 repeal votes. Be that as it may, people had their chance to say no to the ACA and not re-elect Pres Obama but they did. The ACA is here to stay.
Many common citizens are opposed to ObamaCare but support the Affordable Care Act. LOLOL
Who cares?
We're now up to 72% of Americans against the Republican shutdown, and Republicans around for Newt's tantrum know it. This is what the party of Speaker Cruz and Speaker Limbaugh and hidden Speaker DeMint get.
Republicans didn't shut down the Government, the Democrats did because they are unwilling to compromise. Get the facts straight. And it isn't a true shutdown either.
Why do liberals keep shouting that Obama Care is Constitutional the Supreme Court said so? How is that relevant to the argument that while it may be Constitutional it isn't good for the American people? What is the logic there? I guess the liberals realize they don't have a good argument for the ACA so they keep running to the Supreme Court decision on the mandate.
72% of Americans who blame your team. Which means the Republican Lie machine is at it again but will be set straight.
Republicans didn't shut down the Government, the Democrats did because they are unwilling to compromise. Get the facts straight. And it isn't a true shutdown either.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?