- Joined
- Dec 18, 2019
- Messages
- 4,292
- Reaction score
- 634
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Communist
Let the ruling classes tremble at a communist revolution. The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win. Workingmen of all countries, unite!
Let the ruling classes tremble at a communist revolution. The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win. Workingmen of all countries, unite!
Let the ruling classes tremble at a communist revolution. The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win. Workingmen of all countries, unite!
It was a nice idea but then a..h.les like Stalin came along.
If we consider that since the beginning, the USSR was surrounded, not just a..h.les, but bloody ghouls, seeking to destroy it, then comrade Stalin, who managed to fight back against these ghouls and create a superpower in the most difficult conditions and the shortest historical time, is the savior of mankind and the leader of a new, truly progressive society. Everything else is fascist propaganda.
People like to own stuff.
People like to own stuff.
These conversations always end up messy.
Purely planned based economic systems are just as prone to consequences and eventual failure as purely market based economic systems. Mostly for the same reason, on a long enough timeline they both tend to lead to centralize power and influence, aristocracy some form, and marginalization of everyone else.
We can talk all day about economic, social, and governmental theory but in practice we end up with people that have their own motivations, ideologies, faults, what have you that tend to lean towards collection of wealth and resources.
Outside of a classroom the notion of power and holding onto that exist across the spectrum of all known government models with an economic systems.
That is the primary reason we lean towards a mixed model and ideally with a system of government that identifies the individual rights. Still plenty of failures and there is still room for governmental practices that marginalize someone, but there is no solid alternative that would work as best we have evolved so far.
In practice Communism is just as much of a disaster for humanity.
Once "workers of the world unite" (i.e. the "Russian Social Democratic Labour Party" as organized) went to the *very next step* we saw anti-elitist calls end up being ploy to remove one form of aristocracy and replace it with unannounced other. What was sold was not what ended up happening. The result was polarizing intentional divisions, appeal to government authority to outright take from those marginalized, forced settlements and redistribution, bouts of famine and resource mismanagement, appeals to a portion of the nation to spy on the rest, eventually revolution with bloodshed for the record books including everything from "reeducation camps" to judicial executions.
What should be noted from a standpoint of learning from history is we are facing people in this nation, today, that are wanting something that started just like this did.
Will we learn? (I am skeptical.)
If we consider that since the beginning, the USSR was surrounded, not just a..h.les, but bloody ghouls, seeking to destroy it, then comrade Stalin, who managed to fight back against these ghouls and create a superpower in the most difficult conditions and the shortest historical time, is the savior of mankind and the leader of a new, truly progressive society. Everything else is fascist propaganda.
The USSR became a superpower because the could enlist millions of conscripts, the Jet Engines developed by the British, the rockets from the Germans and because of nuke technology they stole from the US.
If we consider that since the beginning, the USSR was surrounded, not just a..h.les, but bloody ghouls, seeking to destroy it, then comrade Stalin, who managed to fight back against these ghouls and create a superpower in the most difficult conditions and the shortest historical time, is the savior of mankind and the leader of a new, truly progressive society. Everything else is fascist propaganda.
The USSR became a superpower because the could enlist millions of conscripts, the Jet Engines developed by the British, the rockets from the Germans and because of nuke technology they stole from the US.
Stalin really is the Savior of humanity, whether you like it or not, and "nearly" doesn't count. Stalin is the winner. As for ass kicking, everyone got it from the Germans at the beginning, some didn't even survive it (and some got their asses kicked by the germans even at the end of the war ). Even the Japanese kicked everyone's ass first. This is the advantage of the aggressor for you, to choose when and where to strike, to have an advantage due to this. As for the slain officers of the Red army, listen less to the lies coming from the stinking Solzhenitsyn. Stalin purged the army before the war, but Hitler did not and received a bomb from his officers when things went bad.Stalin was a lot of things, but “savior of mankind” ain’t one of them. Hfote very nearly wrecked his own “truly progressive society” by murdering so many officers that the Red Army got its ass kicked for years by the Wehrmacht.
I 'm actually surprised to hear about the " theft " of ideas and inventions from a representative of a country where a large number of inventions were made by emigrants in the first generation... As for the Nazi 's role in the creation of the US space program, I'd rather modestly omit it...
Stalin really is the Savior of humanity, whether you like it or not, and "nearly" doesn't count. Stalin is the winner. As for ass kicking, everyone got it from the Germans at the beginning, some didn't even survive it (and some got their asses kicked by the germans even at the end of the war ). Even the Japanese kicked everyone's ass first. This is the advantage of the aggressor for you, to choose when and where to strike, to have an advantage due to this. As for the slain officers of the Red army, listen less to the lies coming from the stinking Solzhenitsyn. Stalin purged the army before the war, but Hitler did not and received a bomb from his officers when things went bad.
Stalin really is the Savior of humanity, whether you like it or not, and "nearly" doesn't count. Stalin is the winner. As for ass kicking, everyone got it from the Germans at the beginning, some didn't even survive it (and some got their asses kicked by the germans even at the end of the war ). Even the Japanese kicked everyone's ass first. This is the advantage of the aggressor for you, to choose when and where to strike, to have an advantage due to this. As for the slain officers of the Red army, listen less to the lies coming from the stinking Solzhenitsyn. Stalin purged the army before the war, but Hitler did not and received a bomb from his officers when things went bad.
If we consider that since the beginning, the USSR was surrounded, not just a..h.les, but bloody ghouls, seeking to destroy it, then comrade Stalin, who managed to fight back against these ghouls and create a superpower in the most difficult conditions and the shortest historical time, is the savior of mankind and the leader of a new, truly progressive society. Everything else is fascist propaganda.
If we consider that since the beginning, the USSR was surrounded, not just a..h.les, but bloody ghouls, seeking to destroy it, then comrade Stalin, who managed to fight back against these ghouls and create a superpower in the most difficult conditions and the shortest historical time, is the savior of mankind and the leader of a new, truly progressive society. Everything else is fascist propaganda.
Stalin happily worked with the Nazis for years until they turned on him. His regime of utter paranoia and psychotic brutality came crumbling down within minutes after he kicked the bucket. His own subordinates flat out stated that his system was totally unworkable, which is why they got rid of Stalinism to begin with. They were sick of murdering innocent people to appease the paranoia of a brutal thug.
And millions upon millions of Stalin’s people died because he was a paranoid idiot.
.
If anyone was happy to work with Hitler, it was the famous appeasers in England and France. Without them, Hitler would never have been able to start a war. Your historical ignorance allows you not to know about the Munich betrayal of Czechoslovakia and the "Phoney war", but the bourgeois propagandists of the Cold war are shouting about the non-aggression Pact with Germany, which the USSR was forced to conclude, since all its attempts to attract future allies to action against Hitler failed. Too much these scoundrels dreamed of sending Hitler against the USSR. And in response, they got hit in the teeth by Hitler. You probably don't know that almost all European States had a non-aggression Treaty with Hitler. The USSR was the last in this chain.
And you "millions upon millions" only one thing proves that you are so brainwashed, that you are ready to believe anything, for example, that the marriage of a man and a man is normal... Once you believe in a biologically abnormal thing, they can put any lie in your head and you will swallow it without thinking.
Until 1933, Germany was a completely democratic country (even Hitler came to power democratically).Pre-Hitler Germany and the USSR were both "pariahs" for other capitalist countries. Therefore, the Soviet Union, experiencing hostile pressure, allowed the germans (democratic germans, let me remind you) to open two schools in Russia, where the Germans trained tankmen and pilots. The Soviet military used these schools to train its specialists, as Germany was more advanced in both aircraft and tank construction. After Hitler came to power, these contacts were immediately terminated.Stalin was working with Hitler even before Munich. The USSR helped the Germans test and develop tanks and aircraft during the interwar period as well as working with Hitler to carve up Poland and seize the Baltic States and other chunks of territory.
The USSR was still sending trains full of aid to the Nazis pretty much up to the minute that Barbarossa kicked off.
Are you denying that the USSR lost millions upon millions of men on the Eastern Front?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?