• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Judge orders Indiana DoC to give a baby killer his taxpayer-funded gender surgery

Are you denying that psychological gender identity exists and the importance of it?
Yes, I deny that. "Psychological gender identity" is pseudoscientific mind-body dualism woo-woo.

If your brain is in a male body, it's a male brain. If your brain is in a female body, it's a female brain. That's it. There's no "inner you" that tells you what gender you are (or if there is it's unfalsifiable), there is only the objective physical reality that is either the male or female sex.
 
Yes, I deny that. "Psychological gender identity" is pseudoscientific mind-body dualism woo-woo.

If your brain is in a male body, it's a male brain. If your brain is in a female body, it's a female brain. That's it. There's no "inner you" that tells you what gender you are (or if there is it's unfalsifiable), there is only the objective physical reality that is either the male or female sex.
Did you gleam all this from your pseudo medical license? 😆
 
Sorry, this has "F***ed up written all over it. This is a complete clusterf***. In my world, surgeries like this shouldn't even be available to anyone incarcerated in a penal system. Especially if it's funded by taxpayers. I'm not anti-trans, or anti-gay, but sorry, the only surgeries that should be approved for an inmate paid by taxpayers should be life saving surgeries.
And this is fodder for MAGA to convince people we are being invaded by trans or whatever they decide to make up.
 
And this is fodder for MAGA to convince people we are being invaded by trans or whatever they decide to make up.
There is no need to try to pretend this is anything other than what it is. The OP isnt saying that 'we are being invaded by trans'...the OP is saying the country has been infected by leftists and their mental illness that have pushed a trans agenda onto this country, mainstreamed that mental illness, pushed it onto children, and now is so completely wrecked mentally that they support spending taxpayer dollars to physically alter a baby killer to fit the baby killers preferred gender of choice.

I mean...that's a LOT of lunacy, brought to you by people that cant even define what a woman is.

How about instead we do this. Let every leftist out there that believes this should happen start up a gofundme account and pay for it themselves. I support your decision to do whatever you want as an adult...as long as it doesnt target children.
 
There is no need to try to pretend this is anything other than what it is. The OP isnt saying that 'we are being invaded by trans'...the OP is saying the country has been infected by leftists and their mental illness that have pushed a trans agenda onto this country, mainstreamed that mental illness, pushed it onto children, and now is so completely wrecked mentally that they support spending taxpayer dollars to physically alter a baby killer to fit the baby killers preferred gender of choice.

I mean...that's a LOT of lunacy, brought to you by people that cant even define what a woman is.

Someone with a female gender identity.
How about instead we do this. Let every leftist out there that believes this should happen start up a gofundme account and pay for it themselves. I support your decision to do whatever you want as an adult...as long as it doesnt target children.
What is the transgender agenda because it seems that only conservatives have ever heard of this nonsense.

Tell me about targeting chicken when a persons gender identity is not a choice that they make.
 
There is no need to try to pretend this is anything other than what it is. The OP isnt saying that 'we are being invaded by trans'...the OP is saying the country has been infected by leftists and their mental illness that have pushed a trans agenda onto this country, mainstreamed that mental illness, pushed it onto children, and now is so completely wrecked mentally that they support spending taxpayer dollars to physically alter a baby killer to fit the baby killers preferred gender of choice.

I mean...that's a LOT of lunacy, brought to you by people that cant even define what a woman is.

How about instead we do this. Let every leftist out there that believes this should happen start up a gofundme account and pay for it themselves. I support your decision to do whatever you want as an adult...as long as it doesnt target children.
The person pretending is you with your strawman argument and your belief in your ability to diagnosis mental illness.
 
You giggle while you shit?


.
And occasionally fart when I pee. What other bodily functions are you curious about?
@Gatsby most likely just uses a large dosage of Common Sense.
😆

Why go to someone with medical knowledge and training for your medical issues when you could just ask a ****ing commoner. That's some kind of sense....
 
And occasionally fart when I pee. What other bodily functions are you curious about?

And you think that this sort of behaviour is something that you should proclaim when you are hoping people will listen to you?

😆

Why go to someone with medical knowledge and training for your medical issues when you could just ask a ****ing commoner. That's some kind of sense....

There is no science that proves that a biological male that thinks he is a biological woman or woman in general... is a biological woman or woman in general.


,
 
And you think that this sort of behaviour is something that you should proclaim when you are hoping people will listen to you?
What's makes you think I'm hoping you or anyone else do anything? :LOL:
There is no science that proves that a biological male that thinks he is a biological woman or woman in general... is a biological woman or woman in general.
There's no evidence your argument is anything but a strawman. Provide evidence of these people who are biological males who think they are biological females.
 
I didn't quote anything about a Strawman. Read it again.
I did read it and I'm asking you what you were confused about. For the record, I'm the one who called your argument a strawman and asked you to provide evidence that your claim was real. Do you know what a strawman is? Do you need me to explain it to you?
 
I did read it and I'm asking you what you were confused about. For the record, I'm the one who called your argument a strawman and asked you to provide evidence that your claim was real. Do you know what a strawman is? Do you need me to explain it to you?

You asked:

Master Debator said:
Provide evidence of these people who are biological males who think they are biological females.

That doesn't make any sense. If you are still confused after this second time then it might be time for me to move on...


.
 
You asked:



That doesn't make any sense. If you are still confused after this second time then it might be time for me to move on...


.
It makes perfect sense. I'm asking you for evidence of your claim. What are you confused about? It's a fairly simple request.
 
It makes perfect sense. I'm asking you for evidence of your claim. What are you confused about? It's a fairly simple request.

Yes. Perfect sense. You asked me to prove a negative... well done.

Bodi said:
There is no science that proves that a biological male that thinks he is a biological woman or woman in general... is a biological woman or woman in general.
 
Yes. Perfect sense. You asked me to prove a negative... well done.
No.... I asked you to prove your positive claim, that the issue is about biological males who are wrong in thinking they are biological females. I'm suggesting this is a strawman until you provide evidence of this fitting an actual description of anyone.
 
No.... I asked you to prove your positive claim, that the issue is about biological males who are wrong in thinking they are biological females. I'm suggesting this is a strawman until you provide evidence of this fitting an actual description of anyone.

I didn't say "that the issue is about biological males who are wrong in thinking they are biological females"... I said that "There is no science that proves that a biological male that thinks he is a biological woman or woman in general... is a biological woman or woman in general." The mistake is in your reading comprehension, in all honesty.
 
I didn't say "that the issue is about biological males who are wrong in thinking they are biological females"... I said that "There is no science that proves that a biological male that thinks he is a biological woman or woman in general... is a biological woman or woman in general." The mistake is in your reading comprehension, in all honesty.
And that's a strawman. No one is claiming that's science. That's what makes it a strawman. You invented that talking point out of thin air.
 
Back
Top Bottom