• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Iran test-fires missiles amid nuclear tension

Redress

Liberal Fascist For Life!
DP Veteran
Joined
Mar 5, 2008
Messages
112,990
Reaction score
60,557
Location
Sarasota Fla
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
Iran test-fires missiles amid nuclear tension - Yahoo! News


This is worrying news. Iran seems to be betting that no one will go to war with them to stop them from gaining nukes. The question is whether they are right in that, as we are not in a good situation to go to another war. I don't think just a bombing campaign would be effective.
 

Yes and No the real question is how long can Western Power keep Israel from going in an destroying these site along with some of the other Military Sites.

We already know that Saudia Arabia and Jordon will not stop them from flying thru there Airspace.

I personally see a three to four prong attack by Israel not only taking out these plants but hitting their(Iran) Air Defence and Naval Base's.
 

I have my doubts that Israel would risk this action without first consulting with the United States. I have serious doubts that the US would go along with this.

So, for Israel, is the prospect of upsetting your best ally worth the risk of possibly (and possibly not) causing any delay in the Iranian nuclear program. On top of it all, this is not as easy a mission to simply go in and take out sites as we are making it out to be. Iran has been under this threat for awhile now and unless they are complete idiots have defended their sites. This all assumes that Israel (and the United States) know where the bulk of these sites are to begin with.
 

The problem is not taking out sites. That can be done no matter how well defended. The problem will be Iran's reaction. They could start firing off missiles, play around on their borders launching strikes, and so on, basically daring some one to actually invade.
 

True, they could be destroyed, but it would not be the cakewalk that it seems a lot of people are thinking it would be.

I agree with you on the reaction however, Iran is set up to cause some serious problems across the Middle East for the United States.
 
What effect do you think this show of strength will have on the talks?
 
If everyone can give me an hour I will draw out what allot of my friends at the Pentagaon think the Israel will do. Please be in mind this is just what alot of us have thought they would do over the past few year and not what they will really do nor is it the actaul belief of any official belief of the DoD nor this White House.
 
What effect do you think this show of strength will have on the talks?

Actual effect, probably very little to none, though of course that is part of why this is being done.
 
Actual effect, probably very little to none, though of course that is part of why this is being done.

You don't think it'll add another layer of seriousness to them?
 
You don't think it'll add another layer of seriousness to them?

Sure, but I don't think it will effect the outcome much if at all. We cannot really let Iran intimidate us, and this was really serious before the missile firings.
 

IMO, they are likely to keep thumbing their noses at everybody, and will get away with it for a long time. At some point, I can see them pushing the envelope too far, but I am not sure who is going to respond Israel, US, or a coalition of sorts.
 
What effect do you think this show of strength will have on the talks?

Nothing really. Most likely Iran has done this for its domestic audience. Also, from a practical standpoint, I have seen rumors that these missiles were modified to make them more mobile and easier to use in short range engagements. So, if they are fearing some kind of strike, making their missiles more mobile gives them some advantage.
 

I do not believe that Israel has the resources to complete a destruction of all Iranian nuclear plants, "Air Defence and Naval Base's". The most that Israel can do is take out a good portion of the nuclear plants but only with extreme cooperation from us, Saudi Arabia, Jordan and with refueling from us.

Israel can perform a quick limited sneak attack but to take out all trhee of those types of installation let's be serious.
 

I think that even those misguided fools who run Iran realize that there is either no one country or group of countries that want to or have the current resources to invade their country. Let's be serious here folks we (US) and some NATA countries are involved in Afghanistan and we (US) still in Iraq. Does anyone really think that any country actually has the stomach to invade Iran?

Talk of invading Iran is the stuff that gives adolescent chicken hawks orgasms and makes anyone who knows which side is up to say “you gotta be kidding me”.
 
Last edited:

No it wouldn't be a sneak attackit would be a major attack not only taking out the Nuke site but taking out some of there larger Military Base's along with some of their Duel-Use Factorys.
 
No it wouldn't be a sneak attackit would be a major attack not only taking out the Nuke site but taking out some of there larger Military Base's along with some of their Duel-Use Factorys.

We can agree to disagree but it is my estimation that Isreal does have the capacity to take out a significant number of Iranian nuclear sites unless they used tactical nukes. Israel may have the will but not the means to do that with comventional only weapons.
 
No one's going to a damn thing to stop Iran from going nuclear. The only thing that will provke action will be an attack, by Iran. Even then, maybe.
 
Iran has been saying it for years: "The Great Satan and the Little Satan are going to be destroyed." They've been showing us their missles. They've played hide and seek with the IAEA for years, many people said oh there's nothing to worry about, now we've heard about a hidden underground site the IAEA never knew about.

If Israel doesn't act, it looks like we're just going to keep dorking around and whining...then when a mushroom cloud appears over some city in Israel, Europe or maybe even the USA people will look shocked and say "whoodathunkit??"

I am disgusted.
 
No one's going to a damn thing to stop Iran from going nuclear. The only thing that will provke action will be an attack, by Iran. Even then, maybe.

I don't think that even the Mullah Hulllahs of Iraniya are stupid enough to actually attack anyone themselves. What scares me is that they would give or sell nuclear devices to the whackiest of the whacks aka Al Queda !!

We very well may have to perform some surgical strikes oursleves. We have that capability. That would not stop the Mullah Hulllahs and their puppy pig Archimedijan or however he spells his names but that would delay the monsters for a long time. The backlash is that the moderates of Iran would move back under the Mullah Hulllahs when we attack them.
 
Last edited:

I'm reminded of all those numbskulls who were shocked upon discovering the extensiveness of Holocaust in the mid 40s. Heck, all Hitler had been doing was talking about his plans for the previous 20 years.

Of course, guaging by the attitudes of way too many of the things that infest internet discussion forums, a nuclear strike on Israel would just be met with claims they had it coming these days.
 
I don't think that even the Mullah Hulllahs of Iraniya are stupid enough to actually attack anyone themselves. What scares me is that they would give or sell nuclear devices to the whackiest of the whacks aka Al Queda !!

people said that about Hitler, too. Look how that turned out. When it comes to psycho, ass hat dictatorships, nothing surprises me.

Even if they're not that stupid, prudence dictates that we should assume that they are.



Either we fight a total war, or we don't bother with it. I'm tired of all this policeing BS. Either we declare war and roll in killing every living thing, or we leave them alone.
 

They will not do it themselves they know that would be suicide. They do not have the capability to strike us directly.
 

Do not understand that we do not have the capability at this to "roll in killing every living thing". Yes that would get their attention but it is not feasible at this time.
 
They will not do it themselves they know that would be suicide. They do not have the capability to strike us directly.

Beg to differ sir. There has been talk in the intel community about Iranian cargo vessels with hidden missle launchers, firing same from near the coast of CONUS. And if we dork around long enough, they'll have ICBM's and nukes small enough to fit on them.

As for how they would not dare, it would be suicide...well some of them don't seem to care about that:


'Divine mission' driving Iran's new leader - Telegraph



Ahmadinejad says Israel doomed - USATODAY.com


Some people need to realize that the leadership of Iran is not composed of rational Western materialists, who contemplate profit/loss before every move, but to a large degree is peopled by religious fanatics, some of whom have stated that it wouldn't matter if every man woman and child in Iran died in some global nuclear holocaust, if that brought on the return of the 12th Imam.

MAD (mutually assured destruction) counted on the rationality of both sides in the conflict...

G
 
Last edited:
Those of us aware of such matters realize that there is currently a Middle East state in possession of a concealed nuclear arsenal not subject to international inspection that deliberately hid the nature of its nuclear program from U.S. inspectors at the time of the development of its arsenal. The president of that country has threatened that another Middle East state could be "wiped off the map." Perhaps Iranian development of a weapons program could prevent the political regime of that state from launching one of their typically invasive campaigns of aggression.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…