• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

If Alien Contact Is Received: what then?

tac138777

Banned
Joined
Aug 10, 2018
Messages
401
Reaction score
83
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian - Right
What do you think our government should do if they receive otherworldly contact from an intelligent species not of this Earth? Should other nations be put in the know? Public kept in the dark? Just wondering.
 
Broadcast this message to them and everyone:

All of our history and study indicates technological advancement is accompanied by social advancement. We anticipate and extend benevolence.
 
No alien race would ever contact us since there isnt any intelligent life down in this planet.
 
What do you think our government should do if they receive otherworldly contact from an intelligent species not of this Earth? Should other nations be put in the know? Public kept in the dark? Just wondering.

Go ask your indigenous natives they have first hand experience of how that will evolve.
 
Go ask your indigenous natives they have first hand experience of how that will evolve.

Well that is that theory that there is a 50/50 chance they are hostile. Might as well spin the cylinder on a revolver with 1 bullet. At least the odds are only like 16% there.

But they could be aware of the issues that meeting has for the locals as well. If they are so advanced as to understand that. We could even gain knowledge from them too. Look at Japan with the European interactions. Advancing several hundred years in technology by having the right understanding of it.
 
Broadcast this message to them and everyone:

All of our history and study indicates technological advancement is accompanied by social advancement. We anticipate and extend benevolence.

Goodness, did you forget your sarcasm emoticon?

Anticipate and extend benevolence? We blow up hospitals and wedding parties, and we extend benevolence? Not hardly.
 
What do you think our government should do if they receive otherworldly contact from an intelligent species not of this Earth? Should other nations be put in the know? Public kept in the dark? Just wondering.

Democrats invite them in to be citizens, the Republicans nuke them.
 
What do you think our government should do if they receive otherworldly contact from an intelligent species not of this Earth? Should other nations be put in the know? Public kept in the dark? Just wondering.

Likely everything you ask about has already happened. Recall Project Bluebook.

We already have been contacted, at least as early as Ike's administration. Other governments are also aware. Yes, the public has been kept in the dark, perhaps with good cause. Cognitive dissonance is so strong in some humans that they could never handle the knowledge. It would blow the proverbial 50 amp fuse.
 
Assuming a race of beings, so advanced that they could travel many many light years within a biological lifetime would want to contact us....

Then I say, yes, let everyone know.

But that wouldn't happen, as it would destroy religion, the most useful manipulation and control tool known to man - and the governments of the world wouldn't want to lose such a tool.
 
Goodness, did you forget your sarcasm emoticon?

Anticipate and extend benevolence? We blow up hospitals and wedding parties, and we extend benevolence? Not hardly.

You just couldn't go one thread without your terrorist rhetoric, could ya? What a staunch warrior against the evil US! Go tell your mommy how brave you are.
 
Democrats invite them in to be citizens, the Republicans nuke them.

Lol. Democrats wouldn’t give them citizenship. Just welfare and everything else. They just don’t have to pay taxes lol.
 
Assuming a race of beings, so advanced that they could travel many many light years within a biological lifetime would want to contact us....

Then I say, yes, let everyone know.

But that wouldn't happen, as it would destroy religion, the most useful manipulation and control tool known to man - and the governments of the world wouldn't want to lose such a tool.

You know. You people always say that about religion. But it seems to me that government has been the tool to control man.
 
You know. You people always say that about religion. But it seems to me that government has been the tool to control man.

Have you heard of Constantine, Popes and the Tudors?
 
Let everyone know and then throw one hell of a bbq.
 
Let's just wait until some aliens actually visit Earth.
 
What do you think our government should do if they receive otherworldly contact from an intelligent species not of this Earth? Should other nations be put in the know? Public kept in the dark? Just wondering.

Back in the 1990's, a think tank said if all people accepted intelligent life outside of earth -- said the suicide rate would be 25% of the world population.
 
Back in the 1990's, a think tank said if all people accepted intelligent life outside of earth -- said the suicide rate would be 25% of the world population.

What were they thinking!
 
You just couldn't go one thread without your terrorist rhetoric, could ya? What a staunch warrior against the evil US! Go tell your mommy how brave you are.

You give me so much ammo with such grand rhetoric. It's a target rich environment, no pun intended. Extend benevolence. :lamo Yeah, the gunship crew on Collateral Murder were extending benevolence with their chain gun.
 
Have you heard of Constantine, Popes and the Tudors?

Yea actually. Constantine and the Tudors both used government. You realize that in the past 400 or so years government is the driving force for keeping people in line? Not religion. You certainly don’t pay your taxes because God said to. Neither do I. I pay mine because men paid by the government using government purchased weapons would come and take my money and throw me in a government paid for jail. Pretty much the same globally for the past few hundred years. And even prior to that.
 
What do you think our government should do if they receive otherworldly contact from an intelligent species not of this Earth? Should other nations be put in the know? Public kept in the dark? Just wondering.

First, they cover it up. Then make all efforts to conceal the encounter from all other governments/nations/people. Then they start developing, in coordination with the extra-terrestrials, new technology such as integrated circuitry, stealth capabilities, kevlar, etc.

You know. Like they are doing now. That what they would do. LOL!
 
What do you think our government should do if they receive otherworldly contact from an intelligent species not of this Earth? Should other nations be put in the know? Public kept in the dark? Just wondering.

might as well tell the world
 
What do you think our government should do if they receive otherworldly contact from an intelligent species not of this Earth? Should other nations be put in the know? Public kept in the dark? Just wondering.

Of course everyone should know.

And a worldwide program then put into place to establish contact and (hopefully) two way communication.

An alien species will not be hostile- it makes no sense. If someone has the technology to get to the Earth, there is literally nothing they would want to ‘take’ from us, other than potentially knowledge about our society.
 
Back
Top Bottom