• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Biden on the Barrett Nomination

Greenbeard

DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 10, 2013
Messages
20,231
Reaction score
21,631
Location
Cambridge, MA
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Liberal
Biden's statement (THE U.S. SUPREME COURT – STATEMENT BY VICE PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN) hits the right notes. A quick reminder that voting rights and equal justice and Roe are all at stake before the pivot to the main takeaway: "health care hangs in the balance."


Trump and the GOP are rushing this illegitimate nomination through because they want another friendly face there when they go before the court on November 10 to argue for taking tens of millions of Americans' health care away. And bringing back pre-existing conditions during a pandemic.

Every Dem with a microphone, Twitter account, or tree stump to climb on and speak from should be reminding voters morning, noon, and night what Trump, every GOP candidate and elected official, and Barrett are trying to do to Americans' health care.
 
Now the Speaker of the House gets in on the fun: Pelosi Statement on Nomination of Amy Coney Barrett to Supreme Court

Hopefully this is the tone and message coming out of every Dem's mouth for the next several weeks. Since this is coming from the leadership and the nominee, it looks like it will be. Hallelujah.
 

Care to explain what makes Barrett illegitimate?
 
Care to explain what makes Barrett illegitimate?

The election has already begun. And the current Senate leadership has already set the precedent that even if people weren't already voting (which they are), a nomination even in the same calendar year is too close in proximity to the election. Rushing this through to take away people's health care is an abomination.

Thankfully the Dems understand that pointing out the "what" and the "why" here in simple terms is the way to go. This is all about health care.



 
She has a mixed race family including 2 black children. It is predictable that bigot and racist Biden despises her.
 
If President Trump has his way, complications from COVID-19, like lung scarring and heart damage, could become the next deniable pre-existing condition.
Must be practicing for Halloween.
 
Reactions: PoS

My issue with her is that she seems to be on the religious right of the political spectrum. She stated that she doesn't believe the constitution protects LGBTQ individuals. I hope I am wrong about this. I do not support discrimination and consider this a big factor in my 2020 decision.
 
That does not answer the question asked. Perhaps you do not understand the meaning of something being illegitimate: not authorized by the law; not in accordance with accepted standards or rules.

Ginsberg herself addressed the same in 2016 concerning Obama and his lame duck appointment.


It applied then and it applies the same today with Trump.
 
Classy as usual.
 
Not one thing you said here explains why Barrett’s nomination is illegitimate. Cite a legal explanation.

Sorry Sabre. I was typing while you already responded.
 
Reactions: PoS
The filibuster should have been abolished from the beginning.
 
Not one thing you said here explains why Barrett’s nomination is illegitimate. Cite a legal explanation.

Sorry Sabre. I was typing while you already responded.

Is it legitimate for a nominee to say this in 2016 and then accept a nomination less than 1.5 months before an election?


 
The GOP and Cotton have set up a war room to defend Barrett from attacks. The GOP is miscalculating IMO. They democrats don’t need to attack Barrett personally. They already have the high road. They should resist this appointment for all the reasons Biden has laid out. Also, they can honor RGB’s dying wish.

The GOP knows the Kavanaugh’s fight ignited their base last time. The GOP made it about due process, but this Supreme Court fight isn’t going to look anything like that. There is a lot on the line. there are so many reasons to not vote yes on pushing this nomination through
 

Just keep playing this video over and over.... Does it help the legitimacy of the court to have a justice that is CLEARLY being hypocritical...

 
what crap: why is this illegitimate?
 
She’s Catholic and the GOP is trying to make this an issue of all Catholics, but I think that there’s two sides to this. I’m not sure that all Catholics would want to be associated with her views. There are a lot of Catholics. How many Catholics would want her to represent the faith of all Catholics?

I just don’t think the way the GOP is playing this is very smart. There are already a lot of Catholics on the Supreme Court, and Biden is a Catholic
 
Just keep playing this video over and over.... Does it help the legitimacy of the court to have a justice that is CLEARLY being hypocritical...

That’s sad. She seems partisan and completely lacking principles. Our country doesn’t deserve this
 
Other than religious bigotry?

Sure: Trump has been impeached, and received bipartisan support for removal. He and other Republicans have stated a) it’s inevitable that the election goes to the SC and thus they have to have a 9th picked-by-Trump-judge on there. The SC, like any other institution we have, does not only get it’s authority from the constitution. It needs the belief from Americans that it is an impartial, legitimate body. Even if Barret were those things, Trump has stated repeatedly he wants her there for a court case he is telegraphing he wants her to weigh in on.

The entire thing from the process to the goal is anti-democratic and designed to try to use cover of institution to retain power despite the country telling Trump he is no longer wanted. I don[t know why the GOP keeps insisting the election is pre-rigged and htis justice must be there to decide. I mean...other than electoral bigotry.
 

First off, I am Catholic myself. Roman Catholic to be exact. And I don't believe the government shouldn't be imposing Catholic teachings onto the rest of the country. There's a video of her talking to a group of people before the election, stating that the same-sex marriage case was unconstitutional, even though state courts ruled that barring same-sex marriage violates the equal protection and due process clauses within the 14th amendment and discriminates based on sex.

It's true that most Catholics support Biden, but good Catholics don't want to strip LGBTQ Americans of their civil rights.

To note: I hope I read her incorrectly.
 
Last edited:
Other than religious bigotry?

I have noted my objection. I would like to know her views on LGBTQ Americans for 2020. Hopefully they have shifted. I cannot in good conscience support a religious right figure.
 

Considering your last statement, are you saying that you're not a good Catholic?
 
Other than religious bigotry?
Ironic coming from a Trump supporter. You know he ran on a Muslim ban, right?

The issue is, I don't know many anti religious bigots. I do know a lot of fundamentals have a sense of persecution however. Her religion isn't the main issue. There are many reasons to be concerned with a candidate like her.
 
if Hillary was president now, and had a slim majority in the senate-would she do anything differently? I just love you Trump haters who pretend that the Democrat party is somehow more honest or more virtuous than the GOP
 
if Hillary was president now, and had a slim majority in the senate-would she do anything differently? I just love you Trump haters who pretend that the Democrat party is somehow more honest or more virtuous than the GOP

I don’t know! But we both know the GOP would be running these clips of them saying “It’s only right not to do this in an election year” and the dems would be getting buried for it. You do understand how politics works, right? GOP said what they said *just* 4 years ago. And we are weeks from an election.

Any way you want to cut it, this is politically a nightmare for the GOP. I get why.- you *have* to grab the court if you can. There is no other option. Gotta replace RBG, it’s too big of a get. But the timing makes it miserable and the Dems should be burying the GOP in it.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…