• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

You Really Did Not Build That

Why do so many white people freak out whenever someone points out that Black people made a significant contribution in building America? I've never seen as much poutrage as I have in these threads where I try discussing the subject.

The facts are there. Black slaves were the backbone of colonial America, without them the region probably doesn't get off the ground for another century, at least. If even that.

You're factually wrong here. Slaves didn't build America, they were used to fuel an agrarian lifestyle for rich plantation owners. If anything, slavery considerably held back the industrialization of regions that allowed it.
 
You're factually wrong here. Slaves didn't build America, they were used to fuel an agrarian lifestyle for rich plantation owners. If anything, slavery considerably held back the industrialization of regions that allowed it.

You're forgetting the slaves in the Northeastern colonies. Slaves had a hand in building what is today New York, Rhode Island, Boston...
New York soon had had the largest colonial slave population north of Maryland. From about 2,000 in 1698, the number of the colony's black slaves swelled to more than 9,000 adults by 1746 and 13,000 by 1756. Between 1732 and 1754, black slaves accounted for more than 35 percent of the total immigration through the port of New York. And that doesn't count the many illegal cargoes of Africans unloaded all along the convoluted coast of Long Island to avoid the tariff duties on slaves. In 1756, slaves made up about 25 percent of the populations of Kings, Queens, Richmond, New York, and Westchester counties.

Slaveholding concentrated in New York City, where by 1691 competition from slave labor had driven white porters out of the market houses and where by 1737 free coopers were complaining of "great numbers of Negroes" working in their trade.

The slave trade became a cornerstone of the New York economy. As with Boston and Newport, profits of the great slave traders, or of smaller merchants who specialized in small lots of skilled or seasoned slaves, radiated through a network of port agents, lawyers, clerks, scriveners, dockworkers, sailmakers, and carpenters.

Slavery in New York
 
why do lefties assume that we all get our ideas from talk show hosts that I have never listened to.

Because you parrot their talking points.
 
You're forgetting the slaves in the Northeastern colonies. Slaves had a hand in building what is today New York, Rhode Island, Boston...

Right, because all of America was built in the 18th century right? -.-
You still haven't proved me wrong, slavery didn't build America, it held her back.
 
Because you parrot their talking points.

Maybe they repeat stuff they hear from other people. You parrot socialist psychobabble
 
Right, because all of America was built in the 18th century right? -.-
You still haven't proved me wrong, slavery didn't build America, it held her back.

silly white guilt is hilarious. Its amazing what the left believes in in order to tear america down
 
Right, because all of America was built in the 18th century right? -.-
You still haven't proved me wrong, slavery didn't build America, it held her back.

Without the building that took place here with slave labor in the 17th and 18th century, we'd be like Canada--a sparsely populated country with underused resources and no real military might.
 
silly white guilt is hilarious. Its amazing what the left believes in in order to tear america down
What's hilarious--white denial. Why can't you guys just admit that slaves helped make America great, that without their help she never would have reached this high plateau?
 
What's hilarious--white denial. Why can't you guys just admit that slaves helped make America great, that without their help she never would have reached this high plateau?

there is absolutely no reason for us whites to feel guilty about what other whites did 200 years ago We all know the history-your moronic self flagellation appears to be driven by some personal issues
 
Without the building that took place here with slave labor in the 17th and 18th century, we'd be like Canada--a sparsely populated country with underused resources and no real military might.

You go on believing that. They were involved, but they were not the driving or only reason we are where we are today.
 
You go on believing that. They were involved, but they were not the driving or only reason we are where we are today.
I never said they were. Where did you get the idea that I did?
 
As usual you are wrong. I never heard of that guy. I have been using the term psychobabble for decades

Socialist psychobabble? Yeah. Right. You coined that. :lol:
 
The post I quoted?

Then I suggest you re-read it. Break it down word for word if you must because there is no way you can get from that post me saying "they were the driving or only reason we are where we are today".
 
Then I suggest you re-read it. Break it down word for word if you must because there is no way you can get from that post me saying "they were the driving or only reason we are where we are today".

Without the building that took place here with slave labor in the 17th and 18th century, we'd be like Canada--a sparsely populated country with underused resources and no real military might.

You reread it.... without the building that took place here with slave labor..... as though without slave labor, it wouldn't have taken place, according to this....
 
Socialist psychobabble? Yeah. Right. You coined that. :lol:

I never said I did. I have used it for decades. Your posts make the term so very useful
 
I never said I did. I have used it for decades. Your posts make the term so very useful
Funny. You do realize I am not a socialist. Right?
 
You reread it.... without the building that took place here with slave labor..... as though without slave labor, it wouldn't have taken place, according to this....

Without slave labor, things would indeed have been different--for sure the US would not have so quickly gotten a huge leg up on the Europeans, and the initial toe hold we achieved here would perhaps not have happened for at least another 50 years. But, that is a far cry from saying slaves were a driving force or the only reason we are where we are today.

Come on. You don't see that?
 
you have claimed not to be many things.
I find it amazing that you see giving credit to Blacks for helping build America somehow takes away from the efforts of whites. Hell, the guy above misinterprets giving Blacks credit for helping make America great to mean discounting what whites did completely.

WTF is wrong with you people?
 
I find it amazing that you see giving credit to Blacks for helping build America somehow takes away from the efforts of whites. Hell, the guy above misinterprets giving Blacks credit for helping make America great to mean discounting what whites did completely.

WTF is wrong with you people?

what good comes from people like you whining that say Princeton might have been partially built with slave labor. and how is that response relevant to what I said
 
Without slave labor, things would indeed have been different--for sure the US would not have so quickly gotten a huge leg up on the Europeans, and the initial toe hold we achieved here would perhaps not have happened for at least another 50 years. But, that is a far cry from saying slaves were a driving force or the only reason we are where we are today.

Come on. You don't see that?

Your words... clear as day.

50 years? No way. When entrepreneur's want to get something done, they find a way to make it happen. Slave labor may have been the easiest and most convenient at the time, but there were many people who did that work who were not slaves also.
 
Back
Top Bottom