• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

USA must break up !!! Only way !!!

The extreme hate on both sides has exceeded the Civil War and I am afraid a second one could happen
It’s 100 percent clear to me that the only solution is too dissolve USA into several or dozens of nations !!

I have no idea what the map would look like but this is the only way to avoid war

NE would be one nation
SE another nation
California own nation
2 nations in the Middle states
2-3 nations in the West
Texas

No way a nation where you have 24/7 hate (mostly all from the left) can survive

What is your opinion

No empire, republic, dictatorship, etc is extinction proof. I think we tend to regard nations and states as forever affairs because people live such brief lives compared to them. The European nations seem to be the best example I can think of for your idea. For so long they lived as States devoted to each others destruction. When war got to be the affair it became in the early 20th century their ideas evolved towards mutual economic benefits. Even that can't seem to hold them together in the face of nationalism. All it takes in a few short years of American nationalism in charge and it seems that the European interest may be to ally against us. Middling States Like Syria or Turkey seem to be forced to pick the closest enemy to the gates at the moment. It is all very fluid.

Maybe it is time for a shake up. It feels like we are Thelma and Louising our way to the cliff right now anyways.
 
So far it appears the left has already started the war with racism , nasty rhetoric, violence And extreme hate
 
Because it was part of Pakistan. Like I said. And just like the map, it was divided from the rest of Pakistan by large amounts of territory from another nation.

It was part of Pakistan 50+ years ago, but you didn't say that you turned the clock back 50+ years when you made that post. If you want to discuss the situation between India and Pakistan in the region of Kashmir I'm willing to do so.
 
No empire, republic, dictatorship, etc is extinction proof. I think we tend to regard nations and states as forever affairs because people live such brief lives compared to them. The European nations seem to be the best example I can think of for your idea. For so long they lived as States devoted to each others destruction. When war got to be the affair it became in the early 20th century their ideas evolved towards mutual economic benefits. Even that can't seem to hold them together in the face of nationalism. All it takes in a few short years of American nationalism in charge and it seems that the European interest may be to ally against us. Middling States Like Syria or Turkey seem to be forced to pick the closest enemy to the gates at the moment. It is all very fluid.

Maybe it is time for a shake up. It feels like we are Thelma and Louising our way to the cliff right now anyways.

It’s time !!! You cannot have a nation with this much hate
It’s going to erupt into a Volcano
 
The extreme hate on both sides has exceeded the Civil War and I am afraid a second one could happen
It’s 100 percent clear to me that the only solution is too dissolve USA into several or dozens of nations !!

I have no idea what the map would look like but this is the only way to avoid war

NE would be one nation
SE another nation
California own nation
2 nations in the Middle states
2-3 nations in the West
Texas

No way a nation where you have 24/7 hate (mostly all from the left) can survive

What is your opinion

I say let all of the conservative states finally have their own Repug utopia country. They can all continue with their #plandemic conspiracy bull****, they can continue to deny the deadliness of COVID-19, and they can eventually all kill each other off through their stupidity.

Repugs think all government sucks. By all means, form your own country and continue to wallow in suckiness.
 
It’s time !!! You cannot have a nation with this much hate
It’s going to erupt into a Volcano

Only the cult, a tiny minority, believes that.
 
I say let all of the conservative states finally have their own Repug utopia country. They can all continue with their #plandemic conspiracy bull****, they can continue to deny the deadliness of COVID-19, and they can eventually all kill each other off through their stupidity.

Repugs think all government sucks. By all means, form your own country and continue to wallow in suckiness.

Sometimes I think you're being serious when you make outlandish statements such as these. Is this one of those times?
 
It’s time !!! You cannot have a nation with this much hate
It’s going to erupt into a Volcano

I think good leadership does one of two things in a situation like this. 1) They begin to realize we might have two distinct nations and find a way to bind them so tightly financially that they can be separately run but economically tied. IE EU. Will it work or not who knows? 2)Go full Hitler and Sumter and fire the first shot. Will it work or not who knows? One thing for sure is people should let their leaders know what they are thinking and feeling and be able to be heard. Has American leadership managed to polarize and isolate so well they can't hear? Who knows, but I guarantee you, Citizens United was one of the best arrows the people allowed to fall in their quiver.
 
USA is a 5th World hell hole
A giant sewer pipe
The nation is destroyed
Break it up
Zero future here

You haven't traveled much, have you?
 
Sometimes I think you're being serious when you make outlandish statements such as these. Is this one of those times?

Outlandish...like the Trump loonies who believe in the Deep State? That kind of outlandish?
 
I think good leadership does one of two things in a situation like this. 1) They begin to realize we might have two distinct nations and find a way to bind them so tightly financially that they can be separately run but economically tied. IE EU. Will it work or not who knows? 2)Go full Hitler and Sumter and fire the first shot. Will it work or not who knows? One thing for sure is people should let their leaders know what they are thinking and feeling and be able to be heard. Has American leadership managed to polarize and isolate so well they can't hear? Who knows, but I guarantee you, Citizens United was one of the best arrows the people allowed to fall in their quiver.
The hate cannot be mended !!
We must separate and now
I am being dead serious
This is not any jokes

I will be in Arizona and we can unite with Texas
 
The deep chasm has only become wider and deeper and we are past the “ point of no return “
 
The hate cannot be mended !!
We must separate and now
I am being dead serious
This is not any jokes

I will be in Arizona and we can unite with Texas

Why are you so angry? Can you not speak about this issue without raging?
 
They want a morally vacant Nazi Tea Party utopia, so let them have it.

I am a trump guy and we’re the ones who fought the Nazis while ..people of your ilk hide in the woods
Not saying you would, but the young leftist of 2020 are not the JFK Dems of old
 
I am a trump guy and we’re the ones who fought the Nazis while ..people of your ilk hide in the woods
Not saying you would be the young leftist of 2020 are not the JFK Dems of old

Trump loves leftie communists. He sucks Vladimir Putin's **** every day.
 
Ah, non-responsive. Deflection noted.

Deep state is not even a swamp
It’s an ocean of corrupt bureaucrats and billionaires like Soros and Zuckerface

Trump has done well but he cannot escape it’s rapid currents and gravity waves
 
Obama and Hillary control the deep state but Soros is the real “ puppet master “
 
Deep state is not even a swamp
It’s an ocean of corrupt bureaucrats and billionaires like Soros and Zuckerface

Trump has done well but he cannot escape it’s rapid currents and gravity waves

Me and some other Deep State fellas took a dump on a giant portrait of Trump last night. It was fun.

We're going to trick Steven Miller into lying to the FBI next. Michael Flynn was just the beginning!
 
Virginia isn't a red state, for one. Silly map, even stupider idea.

No...good Idea...and This one is Better:

New America By Me.webp

Counties that are Red stay mostly red. The micro states of socialists and their supporters have several small states to choose, where most of them currently live anyway. Certain blue areas are given to Canada, certain hard to defend border areas are given to Mexico.

Perfect solution.
 
The extreme hate on both sides has exceeded the Civil War and I am afraid a second one could happen
It’s 100 percent clear to me that the only solution is too dissolve USA into several or dozens of nations !!

I have no idea what the map would look like but this is the only way to avoid war

NE would be one nation
SE another nation
California own nation
2 nations in the Middle states
2-3 nations in the West
Texas

No way a nation where you have 24/7 hate (mostly all from the left) can survive

What is your opinion

You correctly identified the problem... the Left. Can't we just ship them all to Mexico, or something? Then the USA will only contain true Americans.
 
Trump loves leftie communists. He sucks Vladimir Putin's **** every day.

Spoken like a true liberal lol
Tiny vocabulary , vulgarity and zero logic
That is the vernacular of a Marxist liberal
Funny ..because T has put major sanctions on Russia while the demon Obama did zero and gave them Crimea

I am placing you on iggy as I won’t say what I really want to about you
 
No...good Idea...and This one is Better:

View attachment 67280552

Counties that are Red stay mostly red. The micro states of socialists and their supporters have several small states to choose, where most of them currently live anyway. Certain blue areas are given to Canada, certain hard to defend border areas are given to Mexico.

Perfect solution.

Yes, please have your conspiracy-addled COVID-19 #plandemic no facts no science Repug utopia.

When everyone dies, the liberals will move back into all of those red areas.
 
Back
Top Bottom