U.K. Supreme Court Rules Trans Women Can’t Be Defined as Women

[Phys251]

Objectively 1000

Objectively wrong.

I know.

Gender is sex.

Man = adult male. Always has. You know that. Everyone knows that. It’s impossible for a man to transition into a woman. Sorry.

AMAB trans females are female, even before transition.

 

[rahl]

Objectively wrong.

Nope. Biology doesn’t care that you don’t like it.

Surrender accepted.

AMAB trans females are female, even before transition.

Nope. A “trans female” is a man. And will forever remain a man. No matter how many body parts he mutilates or artificial hormones he injects. Sorry.

 

[Phys251]

Nope. Biology doesn’t care that you don’t like it.

Keep whiffing.

Surrender accepted.

Keep whiffing.

Nope. A “trans female” is a man. And will forever remain a man. No matter how many body parts he mutilates or artificial hormones he injects. Sorry.

By your own words, you admit that you don't understand what gender confirmation surgery even is.

 

[rahl]

Keep whiffing.

1000

Keep whiffing.

Crushing your position with reality.

By your own words, you admit that you don't understand what gender confirmation surgery even is.

It doesn’t matter how many body parts you mutilate. You are and will forever remain a man. I know this hurts your feelings. But reality doesn’t care.

 

[Phys251]

1000

Crushing your position with reality.

It doesn’t matter how many body parts you mutilate.

Again you don't know what goes on in gender confirmation surgery. Educate yourself.

You are and will forever remain a man. I know this hurts your feelings. But reality doesn’t care.

As a cis man, your bleating means nothing to me. It's amusing, but boring and predictable.

 

[rahl]

Again you don't know what goes on in gender confirmation surgery. Educate yourself.

A man has cosmetic surgery. He remains a man after the surgery.

As a cis man, your bleating means nothing to me.

Nobody cares what it means to you. You remain a man no matter what cosmetic surgeries you have. Nobody cares that this hurts your feelings.

It's amusing, but boring and predictable.

Reality doesn’t care about your feelings. You are a man and will forever remain a man. Because it’s not possible to transition into a woman.

 

[Phys251]

A man has cosmetic surgery. He remains a man after the surgery.

Nobody cares what it means to you. You remain a man no matter what cosmetic surgeries you have. Nobody cares that this hurts your feelings.

Reality doesn’t care about your feelings. You are a man and will forever remain a man. Because it’s not possible to transition into a woman.

Your bubble world means nothing. Neither does your bleating about the gender confirmation surgery which you obviously know nothing about.

 

[rahl]

Your bubble world means nothing.

Reality doesn’t care how you feel.

Neither does your bleating about the gender confirmation surgery which you obviously know nothing about.

A man mutilating his body and taking artificial hormones doesn’t change his dna. You are a man and will die a man. I’m sorry this hurts your feelings, but reality doesn’t care.

 

[Phys251]

Reality doesn’t care how you feel.

Or you.

A man mutilating his body and taking artificial hormones doesn’t change his dna. You are a man and will die a man. I’m sorry this hurts your feelings, but reality doesn’t care.

Your ignorance amuses me, but bores me. Are you one of those who think Caster Semenya is a man?

 

[rahl]

Or you.

I haven’t offered any feelings. I’ve pointed out reality.

Your ignorance amuses me, but bores me. Are you one of those who think Caster Semenya is a man?

It doesn’t matter how many cosmetic surgeries a man has. You are a man and will forever remain one. Your hurt feelings have no effect
On reality.

 

[Phys251]

I haven’t offered any feelings. I’ve pointed out reality.

Only in your imagination.

It doesn’t matter how many cosmetic surgeries a man has. You are a man and will forever remain one. Your hurt feelings have no effect
On reality.

You are doing an amazingly poor job of reading my mind.

 

[rahl]

Only in your imagination.

Nope. In objective reality. Confirmed by biological science.

You are doing an amazingly poor job of reading my mind.

I don’t care what’s in your mind. I’m pointing out it’s impossible for a man to transition to a woman. It matters not how many cosmetic surgeries you have. You will forever remain a man. Your hurt feelings over this fact, has no bearing on reality.

 

[Phys251]

Nope. In objective reality. Confirmed by biological science.

Science never changes?

I don’t care what’s in your mind. I’m pointing out it’s impossible for a man to transition to a woman. It matters not how many cosmetic surgeries you have. You will forever remain a man. Your hurt feelings over this fact, has no bearing on reality.

You are under the delusion that you hurt my feelings. You don't. Your ignorance on the matter is amusing, but boring. Transphobia hasn't the slightest variation in its tactics.

 

[rahl]

Science never changes?

Not biological science. It’s impossible for a man to become a woman.

You are under the delusion that you hurt my feelings.

You seem upset that you can’t become a woman.

You don't. Your ignorance on the matter is amusing, but boring.

Pointing out you can’t become a woman isn’t my ignorance. It’s objective reality.

Transphobia hasn't the slightest variation in its tactics.

Reality isn’t an irrational fear of “trans” people

 

[trouble13]

Thankfully America fought and won a war to escape draconian English rule. Who do they think they are to tell men they are not women. Thankfully us Americans are more enlightened than that. We know that we can be anything or anyone we want to be by simply declaring it to be so.

 

[Phys251]

Not biological science. It’s impossible for a man to become a woman.

Biology never changes? Oh dear lord Sounds like all the thousands of biology research publications every year don't exist!

You seem upset that you can’t become a woman.

I already told you that I'm a cis man. You aren't very good at this.

Pointing out you can’t become a woman isn’t my ignorance. It’s objective reality.

Reality isn’t an irrational fear of “trans” people

Y'all sure do spend an irrational amount of time trying to keep transgender people down.

Here's a helpful hint for you in language that even you can understand:

 

[Taylor]

Next, they'll issue a ruling that Earth is round.

 

[rahl]

Biology never changes?

No

Oh dear lord Sounds like all the thousands of biology research publications every year don't exist!

DNA doesn’t change because you mutilate body parts

I already told you that I'm a cis man. You aren't very good at this.

There’s no such thing as cis man/trans man. There’s just man. And you are a man, and will die a man.

Y'all sure do spend an irrational amount of time trying to keep transgender people down.

Pointing out reality doesn’t keep anyone down.

Here's a helpful hint for you in language that even you can understand:

View attachment 67566246

Pandering to delusions doesn’t help anyone. You are a man. You can’t change that. No matter how many cosmetic surgeries you have. This is reality.

 

[Phys251]

No

DNA doesn’t change because you mutilate body parts

There’s no such thing as cis man/trans man. There’s just man. And you are a man, and will die a man.

Pointing out reality doesn’t keep anyone down.

Pandering to delusions doesn’t help anyone. You are a man. You can’t change that. No matter how many cosmetic surgeries you have. This is reality.

Your ignorance is off the charts. Biology changes all the time. Cis people exist. Trans people exist. No matter how much you stamp your feet and demand otherwise. This is reality.

 

[rahl]

Your ignorance is off the charts. Biology changes all the time.

No it doesn’t.

Cis people exist. Trans people exist.

Trans people are delusional people who think they are something that they provably are not.

No matter how much you stamp your feet and demand otherwise. This is reality.

Nope. There are men, and there are women. You are a man. Calling yourself a woman does not change reality. You are a man and will die a man, no matter how many cosmetic surgeries you have. I’m sorry this hurts your feelings. Reality doesn’t care.

 

[Lisa]

Next, they'll issue a ruling that Earth is round.

Its not round. Technically its an oblate spheroid. Its flattened at the poles and bulges at the equator. Details matter.

Shape of the Earth: The Oblate Spheroid - Earth How

Earth is not a perfect sphere. In fact, it’s in the shape of an oblate spheroid. Earth shape bulges at the equator and flattens at the north and south pole.

earthhow.com

Human sexuality is also not just binary male and females based on genitalia or DNA.

 

[rahl]

Its not round. Technically its an oblate spheroid. Its flattened at the poles and bulges at the equator. Details matter.

Shape of the Earth: The Oblate Spheroid - Earth How

Earth is not a perfect sphere. In fact, it’s in the shape of an oblate spheroid. Earth shape bulges at the equator and flattens at the north and south pole.

earthhow.com

Human sexuality is also not just binary male and females based on genitalia or DNA.

Humans, like all mammals, are binary.

 

[Taylor]

Its not round. Technically its an oblate spheroid. Its flattened at the poles and bulges at the equator. Details matter.

Shape of the Earth: The Oblate Spheroid - Earth How

Earth is not a perfect sphere. In fact, it’s in the shape of an oblate spheroid. Earth shape bulges at the equator and flattens at the north and south pole.

earthhow.com

Human sexuality is also not just binary male and females based on genitalia or DNA.

Oblate spheroids are round.

 

[Lisa]

Oblate spheroids are round.

Technically that is not true.

 

[Taylor]

Technically that is not true.

Sure it is.