• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Trump’s first task is herculean: closing the border. Here are his plans.

Building a wall won’t address the majority of illegal immigration, drug trafficking, or sex trafficking because those already come through legal points of entry.
It won't stop more from coming. We need to address the problem in the other direction, but no one wants to do that.

Walls are easily defeated, especially if they are as long as our southern border. (And what until someone points out to Trump that boats go in water, and they can sail right around the ends of his stupid wall, even if it could actually be made "impenetrable". But it can't.)
This will result in the US blowing a lot of taxpayer money on a big ugly trump ego project, and then playing whackamole for the next 20 years. It will solve nothing, but cause more serious problems.
 
Last edited:
You could be right and then in 2028 the guy saying he will go Singapore death penalty on drug mules will win.

Saying a government can never serve it's people just means even more strident and extreme reform will happen. Keep talking and you'll remember the good ol' days where you remember Trump as more like Mitt Romney compared to his successors.

Or we could do the actual small government thing and end the war on drugs. But conservatives care more about controlling people than freedom.
 
You could be right and that just means that the next person after him will take an ever more strident position since it is a strong priority for the American people that immigration be fixed. You guys can sit there and shrug your shoulders just like how you do for drugs, the homeless, crime and everything else. Maybe he will fail but the point is at some point if a government cannot serve it's people, it will not exist.



Oh you're one of those remaining people who still think he "won" it? I guess the fact that all those votes never materialized for Obama, Clinton or Harris was just a coincidence.



Yet the policies of the Democrat party and their governance was so bad that they will take him with all that failure over another four years with Harris.

That's pretty bad. I mean that's like you gave me a venereal disease but you're still better than crazy eyes over there with the cackle.



You can dogmatically repeat yourself. SOMEONE has to control immigration in some fashion. Trump has talked about bringing the military home from abroad and using it to defend our own borders vs those of Japan, Europe and so on. Something will get done at some point.
I'm not being dogmatic. I'm simply pointing out reality.

We aren't bringing troops home to defend the border even assuming you can get around the Posse Comitatus Act. That's another stupid fever dream.
 
So that's a no then since the objectives and outcomes were in that article. You don't read. Got it.
You want the national guard in Oakland, New Orleans, Port Elizabeth, Baltimore?

You think shipping companies are going to play nice when routes and ports of call are mapped out months in advance, and consumers are already pissed at the down-chain costs of Panama's water loss, or a single ship blocking the Suez?

And when Florida is under next year's six or twelve once-in-a-century hurricanes, you keeping the guard at the NY Port Authority?
 
You want the national guard in Oakland, New Orleans, Port Elizabeth, Baltimore?

You think shipping companies are going to play nice when routes and ports of call are mapped out months in advance, and consumers are already pissed at the down-chain costs of Panama's water loss, or a single ship blocking the Suez?

And when Florida is under next year's six or twelve once-in-a-century hurricanes, you keeping the guard at the NY Port Authority?


I'm concerned we will see troops separating crying families. But more worried people will support it.
 
Yet the policies of the Democrat party and their governance was so bad that they will take him with all that failure over another four years with Harris.

The economy has historically performed more than twice as well under Democrats since 1933.

People voted against their own interests because that is how grifts work. The grifter tricks you into acting against your interests.
 
MAGAs have never been conservatives.

They're fascists.
More Americans love fascist than not according to the epic EC beatdown libs took this week.
 
I'm concerned we will see troops separating crying families. But more worried people will support it.
Same.

But here's an anecdote. My friend O. did logistics for a Boston pharmaceutical company. She ran the entire supply chain. It's a 300k a year starting job, because she had to organize everything from raw goods to glassware, never mind the controlled substance compliances. I am woefully understating the complexity. They ran 3 billion across the end line even during covid and the Suez thing almost sank the entire company, and she had to get the r&d budget cut to make up the overages from getting supplies into the air, which triggered a rasher of additional compliance headaches. Which also hurt the company's future earnings.

But here we are with Trumpers come in with a legion of hammer wielding dumb dumbs, hopped up on ignorance and arrogance, thinking they can hulksmash a whiter tomorrow...
 
Or we could do the actual small government thing and end the war on drugs. But conservatives care more about controlling people than freedom.

There's plenty of small government available once our borders are handled. That is actually one of the core jobs the federal government SHOULD be doing. We can stop funding Ukraine and the Department of Education and actually handle our border.

I'm not being dogmatic. I'm simply pointing out reality.

We aren't bringing troops home to defend the border even assuming you can get around the Posse Comitatus Act. That's another stupid fever dream.

No you're being dogmatic. You've not added anything but repetition that failure will occur.

You want the national guard in Oakland, New Orleans, Port Elizabeth, Baltimore?

You think shipping companies are going to play nice when routes and ports of call are mapped out months in advance, and consumers are already pissed at the down-chain costs of Panama's water loss, or a single ship blocking the Suez?

And when Florida is under next year's six or twelve once-in-a-century hurricanes, you keeping the guard at the NY Port Authority?

Your strawman might scare the crows away.

I'm concerned we will see troops separating crying families. But more worried people will support it.

They don't have to be separated. They can all choose to be deported.

The economy has historically performed more than twice as well under Democrats since 1933.

People voted against their own interests because that is how grifts work. The grifter tricks you into acting against your interests.

Democrat wars must be good for business right? I mean WWI, WWIII, Vietnam, and so on. Democrats are the war party.

Same.

But here's an anecdote. My friend O. did logistics for a Boston pharmaceutical company. She ran the entire supply chain. It's a 300k a year starting job, because she had to organize everything from raw goods to glassware, never mind the controlled substance compliances. I am woefully understating the complexity. They ran 3 billion across the end line even during covid and the Suez thing almost sank the entire company, and she had to get the r&d budget cut to make up the overages from getting supplies into the air, which triggered a rasher of additional compliance headaches. Which also hurt the company's future earnings.

But here we are with Trumpers come in with a legion of hammer wielding dumb dumbs, hopped up on ignorance and arrogance, thinking they can hulksmash a whiter tomorrow...

Hey you've gotten so good at calling Trump supporters uneducated white people that they've conveniently started adding all the black and brown people as well to their voting totals. Keep it up! Majority rule won't work well when the vast majority of people don't want to be told they have no agency just because they have no college degree and you the person with the college degree just need your loans forgiven while you tell them how to run their lives.

In the meantime, this is a good test for the soon to be unified Federal Government under President Donald Trump.
 
You want the national guard in Oakland, New Orleans, Port Elizabeth, Baltimore?
The minute control of the NG shifts to Feds Posse Comitatus applies and they cannot be used for domestic law enforcement.
 
No you're being dogmatic. You've not added anything but repetition that failure will occur.
If wishes were horses.

I didn't say it'll
fail. I said it'll a boat load of money, hurt the economy and never be completely successful.

Sorry you can't stomach reality.
 
The minute control of the NG shifts to Feds Posse Comitatus applies and they cannot be used foe domestic law enforcement.
I was referring to the plan to use them as container inspectors.
 
There's plenty of small government available once our borders are handled. That is actually one of the core jobs the federal government SHOULD be doing. We can stop funding Ukraine and the Department of Education and actually handle our border.



No you're being dogmatic. You've not added anything but repetition that failure will occur.



Your strawman might scare the crows away.



They don't have to be separated. They can all choose to be deported.



Democrat wars must be good for business right? I mean WWI, WWIII, Vietnam, and so on. Democrats are the war party.



Hey you've gotten so good at calling Trump supporters uneducated white people that they've conveniently started adding all the black and brown people as well to their voting totals. Keep it up! Majority rule won't work well when the vast majority of people don't want to be told they have no agency just because they have no college degree and you the person with the college degree just need your loans forgiven while you tell them how to run their lives.

In the meantime, this is a good test for the soon to be unified Federal Government under President Donald Trump.
Look at you, trading in banal nothings and smug self-assurance.
 
Democrat wars must be good for business right? I mean WWI, WWIII, Vietnam, and so on. Democrats are the war party.

What are you even talking about? Ike was a Republican President.
 
There's plenty of small government available once our borders are handled. That is actually one of the core jobs the federal government SHOULD be doing. We can stop funding Ukraine and the Department of Education and actually handle our border.



No you're being dogmatic. You've not added anything but repetition that failure will occur.



Your strawman might scare the crows away.



They don't have to be separated. They can all choose to be deported.



Democrat wars must be good for business right? I mean WWI, WWIII, Vietnam, and so on. Democrats are the war party.



Hey you've gotten so good at calling Trump supporters uneducated white people that they've conveniently started adding all the black and brown people as well to their voting totals. Keep it up! Majority rule won't work well when the vast majority of people don't want to be told they have no agency just because they have no college degree and you the person with the college degree just need your loans forgiven while you tell them how to run their lives.

In the meantime, this is a good test for the soon to be unified Federal Government under President Donald Trump.

Unless your plan is to seal the border and stop all legal traffic, you aren’t going to make a dent against the majority of illegal immigration, drug trafficking, or sex trafficking.
 
Back
Top Bottom