• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Trans Swimmer Crushes Female Opponents, Take Five Medals at Championship Event (5 Viewers)

This is a group of adults who have come together to compete and have set their own rules of amateur competition .
So why would you think it's a erasing somebody for saying no dudes allowed even if they're dudes that say they're not dudes?
Should they be allowed to do that or does the government need to get involved?
Yes. And I should be allowed to criticize them for treating women like garbage.
 
.



Ana Caldas made Trans proud. He is clearly a gift to women sports. Just what women sports needed: a winner. And did he win! Every event he touched turned into Gold. Five Gold Medals in all. And he didn't even break into a sweat.

Women should draw inspiration from the superior performance of "women" like Ana Caldas.



<<<
A man who identifies as a woman has won five gold medals in a women’s swimming championship in an event dubbed a “real-life South Park episode.”
Swimmer Ana Caldas tore through the opposition in the 45-49 age group at the U.S. Masters Swimming Spring National Championship held in San Antonio, Texas, last weekend. Not only did he win all his competitions, but it wasn’t even close, as his times came in far ahead of his opponents.

For instance, in the 50 and 100-yard breaststroke, Caldas posted a time four seconds faster than the second-place winner. And in the 100-yard freestyle event, Caldas beat the next closest swimmer by three seconds.
<<<



I saw what you did there. The swimmer didn't even break a sweat.
 
You're making my point. He never won and never even came close when he was swimming with dudes.

You just contradicted yourself above.

K
Thomas was not a dominate figure in the sport.

She won one race.

Katie Leckey just broke the world record again.

That is a dominate figure in women’s swimming.
 
How so? The entire thing is voluntary.

And as for the rest…

Addressing the idea that a group of adults can put on a competition and include trans people and a certain group of conservative busybodies not have a problem with it.

If it is a problem… what is the solution?

Your repeated insult attempts are week. Why do you hate females?


g
 
Thomas was not a dominate figure in the sport.
You keep saying this and then in the next sentence you will say he's scored at least in the upper five.

He was 400th in the male League.
She won one race.
So he dominated.
Katie Leckey just broke the world record again.

That is a dominate figure in women’s swimming.
Play sing in the upper five after spending your life being in the 400th range sounds to me like dominating.

Try not torpedoing your own argument.
 
You keep saying this and then in the next sentence you will say he's scored at least in the upper five.

He was 400th in the male League.

So he dominated.

Play sing in the upper five after spending your life being in the 400th range sounds to me like dominating.

Try not torpedoing your own argument.
I think that the definition of “dominating” isn’t agreed upon.

Dominating is someone who isn’t being beat… at all.

Thomas was not that person.

Leckey is that person.
 
Your repeated insult attempts are week. Why do you hate females?


g
I haven’t insulted anyone.

The thing is that it really is a conundrum.

Does the government step in and regulate private amateur sports organizations that have no problem with trans people or are adults able to compete as they wish without government interference.

For me the answer is simple… let people play sports as they wish to play sports.
 
I think that the definition of “dominating” isn’t agreed upon.
Yeah. The last place swimmer moving up to the upper five to me seems like domination.
Dominating is someone who isn’t being beat… at all.
And you're using this strict definition because you're wrong you know you're wrong and you're trying to use semantics to weasel out of it.
Thomas was not that person.
He was last place like 400th. So he may not fit your stupid infinitely narrow situational definition for the purposes of this argument but that doesn't matter.
Leckey is that person.
 
The government getting involved in private amateur sports is not small government
Duh. I've agreed with you on this subject now three times why are you trying to shop this idea that I think government should get involved?

I'm criticizing criticizing doesn't equal advocating for government involvement.

Get a clue please this is tiresome.
 
Duh. I've agreed with you on this subject now three times why are you trying to shop this idea that I think government should get involved?

I'm criticizing criticizing doesn't equal advocating for government involvement.

Get a clue please this is tiresome.
I apologize for my misunderstanding of your point.

Then in this issue… not much to do about it but complain.

That’s okay.
 
So why would you think it's a erasing somebody for saying no dudes allowed even if they're dudes that say they're not dudes?

Yes. And I should be allowed to criticize them for treating women like garbage.
It is a sexual fetish with them.

They get off sexually watching men dominate women.
 
For **** sake NO.

Criticism does not equal advocation of government involvement.
I don’t know why there is even criticism here.

It has nothing to do with anyone here.

It’s a competition where trans people have been competing for a while now… no one gave a shit until yeaterday when the right wing media frothed it up.
 
The OP is about a private amateur sports league.


A league open to the public



And looking into this.. it seems like Caldas has been swimming with this league for a few years now without any ire placed upon her or the league that we all suddenly know about.


So if someone has been cheating for years it protects them from uproar because there was silence before?



in 2021 she placed 7th overall in the 40-44 age range.

He. That 7th spot belonged to a woman



It is a wild time when something a picayune as an amateur swimming event put on by a private organization in Texas creates such a fervor in some people.


If it is so picayune maybe muscleman Ada should hand back the medals
 
Yeah that's exactly why you're here to pretend somehow magically that not letting men play on winning the sports erases them.

Remember you complained about it too
My complaints are ingrained in inclusion and letting individuals and groups decide for themselves without a bunch of busybodies telling them that they are doing it wrong.
 
I don’t know why there is even criticism here.
Because people have opinions you did too you mentioned one.

Some nonsense about people being erased without actually being erased.
It has nothing to do with anyone here.
So quit talking about it. You're all up in this too.
It’s a competition where trans people have been competing for a while now… no one gave a shit until yeaterday when the right wing media frothed it up.
Men shouldn't play in women's sports even if they say they are trans.

If you don't think people should have an opinion on this stop doing it. I think you're using it to freak out about the right wing.
 
My complaints are ingrained in inclusion and letting individuals and groups decide for themselves without a bunch of busybodies telling them that they are doing it wrong.
Yeah you think yours is the only opinion that matters that's why you're trying to lecture everyone else that they shouldn't have an opinion on this.

It's very self-centered.

You also think that yours is only opinion that should be voiced.

That's why people are posting.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Back
    Top Bottom