• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

The Former European Commission President commented on the U.S Election.....


New member
Apr 19, 2016
Reaction score
Political Leaning
Good Afternoon. Jose Manuel Barroso, the former European Commission President and the former Prime Minister of Portugal gave a presentation in December 2015 in Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Relations where he mentioned the presidential election:

So xenophobic forces exist in Europe. When you know the history of Europe and old demons, I think we should be attentive to that. How to fight this xenophobia? How to be sure that we keep Europe open, at the same time that we are able to control our borders?

My question to you is the following: Do you think it is only a European problem there? Don't you have that problem here in the United States? When we see a leading candidate in the presidential race making the comments he made about Mexicans or just the position he took now against all Muslims?

So, my dear friends, we are living in a very difficult and complex world, where globalization is, in fact, feeding this kind of nationalistic, nativist, xenophobic, sometimes racist attitudes. This is a problem not only for Europe, for many of us who believe in ethics in international relations. We have to fight together against those negative sentiments that have a very deep history in some of our societies.

Yes, there is a problem in Europe, but it is not a specific problem to Europe. The solution, as we have seen now with the tragic events in San Bernardino, is not to close European borders. The United States is in full control of the borders. But it can happen to you. If you have suicide bombers, fanaticized, they can be anywhere, even if you close your borders.

So we have to see how deep this issue is and try to avoid simplistic, populist answers to very complex and difficult challenges. It is not by closing Schengen. On the contrary. It is by Schengen that we can fight, because terrorists don't respect borders. It is precisely by changing intelligence and information, putting together the national resources against terrorism, that we can succeed in the fight against this kind of violent jihadism that we have today as the major threat not only to Europe, but to the world and to our values.

Firstly, that's a very well-argued, thoughtful and moderate comment on the current security situation worldwide.

Secondly, he's not commenting on the US election, merely referencing comments of someone who is currently in the global spotlight. He referenced the San Bernardino shootings, but he was not commenting on that specifically either.
I dont see anything wrong with what he said... are Europeans not allowed to comment on American issues while in the US and talking to Americans or something like that?
I agree however since he used to represent the European Union and the Republic of Portugal, the latter as head of government, I merely wished that it got more fanfare in the news since President Obama himself commented on the state of the European Union (the United Kingdom's status in that conglomeration). This is all it received, and it was on the Eastern European crisis instead: rtvi.com/video/43694
Top Bottom