It looks to me that several of the parameters for the issues you discuss like "what the people are thinking" are difficult to define. How do we define "what the people are thinking?"
I’ve had this question before. Teachers are persuading students they can’t know what people are thinking, which is balderdash. For a start those very teachers know exactly what nonsense their students are thinking since they’ve just filled their heads with it. Here’s Ms. Dimwit, a teacher, at home with her significant other gender thingy, in bed.
Dimwit: How was your day?
Genthing: Baddish. Yours?
Dimwit: Not baddish. Told the clones they can’t know what peoples are thinking.
Genthing: Why teech ’em that?
Dimwit: I was taught to teech ’em that, in teecher trayning…
Genthing: But it’s stupid.
Dimwit: No it ain’t.
Genthing: Yup. After you teeched them, what were they thinking?
Dimwit: That you can’t knows what peoples are thinking, off course.
Genthing: So you
DO know what peoples are thinking!
Dimwit: I just taught thems that. Of course
I know…
As you can see, Dimwit and Genthing aren’t much good with English. What Dimwit doesn’t know is that if you study a human’s behavior and actions you can deduce what he, she, it or thingy is thinking. Here’s a splendid genderbenderish example:
Genthing goes into a plastic surgeon at 9.00 A.M. and comes out at 11.00 A.M. with bandages on her nose. She is holding the side of her face and moaning in pain. She goes into a pharmacist’s and buys some painkillers. She asks for a cup of water and swallows three of the pills and leaves.
What was she thinking?
It’s clear she was thinking she wanted to have a nose job. It’s clear she was thinking she would get a nose job at the surgery in question. It’s clear she thought to make an appointment for the nose job, and that she thought about being there at 9.00 A.M. for her nose job appointment. It’s clear she thought about the pain she felt, and she thought to go to the drug store to get pain meds. It’s clear she thought to ask for a cup of water to swallow her pills.
How did we know she was thinking all those things?
By studying her actions and behavior.
So when you see Ms Dimwit you can tell her she was wrong. We can indeed define "what the people are thinking."