Star Wars - The Great Hunt =Game Thread=

[Helix]

here's my take.

first,

I dunno, all of the setting could be pointless. I just thought it was very strange when I saw my character name and ~"... a Townie" after it.

I had no idea who it was. I google searched and read a few wookiepedia entries. It's the guy that Darth Vader magic-chokes for not capturing Han Solo. Also, I was congratulated by Yoda during the Battle of Corseca (sp) while defending the Jedis from Grievous and other forces of evil.

this does not compute. in the first quote, Eco recalls being surprised that his character could possibly be town. in the second, he claims that he had to google the character, because he had "no idea who it was." this is just exceptionally suspicious.

next, the town / scum / theme alignment. i have been thinking about this all day, and forgive me for going too meta, but this will be the third Pasch game i've played. in the previous two, town won, and in the last round, won handily. at this point if i were Pasch, i would have some motivation to weight the game more towards scum this time. if Tucker and others are telling the truth, some obviously dark side roles might be town. i know in my own instance that an obviously town role is also town. it's possible that this was designed to limit or to confuse role claims.

the fact that Eco is claiming such an obscure role also gives me pause. scum would likely choose a role that they are sure no one else has in order to prevent a counter claim. also, it's possible that the well known roles were handed out first and that scum were given fake claims from whatever was left.

finally, there has just been something off about Eco's game play. when i played with him last game, i pretty much jumped on his team immediately, because i was was pretty confident he was town. this time does resemble his game play then, but there is just something that isn't the same. it's almost like he's a very good mask of town Eco.

caveat : my analysis depends heavily on meta. that being said, ##vote Ecofarm.

 

[The Mark]

I keep having the idle thought that it'd be epic (in a somewhat twisted way) if the scum team consisted of eco/tucker in this game.

It'd just make day one all that more hilarious.


But.

It seems unlikely.

 

[Chaddelamancha]

I was suspicious of Eco when he said Pasch had given out false roleclaims for scum, when I have not heard/seen anything like that from Pasch. I know it was allowed last game, but I didn't hear anything like that in this game. Maybe I missed it, but I doubt it. I think he was recalling something that he had read in his PM. That, combined with the two quotes from Helix makes me think perhaps Eco got his actual role and his false roleclaim mixed up. With that in mind.

##Vote: Eco

Also, I would hate for The Mark to be right with his "Meh, why not" vote after I went after him.

here's my take.

first,





this does not compute. in the first quote, Eco recalls being surprised that his character could possibly be town. in the second, he claims that he had to google the character, because he had "no idea who it was." this is just exceptionally suspicious.

next, the town / scum / theme alignment. i have been thinking about this all day, and forgive me for going too meta, but this will be the third Pasch game i've played. in the previous two, town won, and in the last round, won handily. at this point if i were Pasch, i would have some motivation to weight the game more towards scum this time. if Tucker and others are telling the truth, some obviously dark side roles might be town. i know in my own instance that an obviously town role is also town. it's possible that this was designed to limit or to confuse role claims.

the fact that Eco is claiming such an obscure role also gives me pause. scum would likely choose a role that they are sure no one else has in order to prevent a counter claim. also, it's possible that the well known roles were handed out first and that scum were given fake claims from whatever was left.

finally, there has just been something off about Eco's game play. when i played with him last game, i pretty much jumped on his team immediately, because i was was pretty confident he was town. this time does resemble his game play then, but there is just something that isn't the same. it's almost like he's a very good mask of town Eco.

caveat : my analysis depends heavily on meta. that being said, ##vote Ecofarm.

 

[cAPSLOCK]

When I was scum and you played, wasn't it the game when I made very few posts Day 1?

Yup that is a major difference. You were much quieter that time.

 

[ecofarm]

You attacked me from the start and started making an argument to get me lynched for nothing.

I interrogated you. Why? Because you are a 'big dog'. I did not attack anyone. I was disturbed by a response of yours during our enhanced interrogation technique.

After my disappointment with your interrogation (I wanted you to be town, given your capacity), I began to prod you further. At every corner, my disappointment was reinforced. The original event as well as that which cascaded has been documented extensively by me quoting myself and re-creating Lists and explanations countless times.

 

[ecofarm]

Look at how much eco hates meta!

He hates it so much he'll use it as a way to railroad someone!

I was proving a point. Meta is useful, but should not be the basis of ones case. You have meta against you; yet, I've built a case without it.

 

[ecofarm]

And this explanation does not provide me a reason why any of what I quoted has to do with this game.

You claimed that I was acting like Tucker, that being: targeting one player with nothing but meta.

I countered that via the fact that I've addressed several players with specific citation of actions I found questionable.

 

[Your Star]

You claimed that I was acting like Tucker, that being: targeting one player with nothing but meta.

I countered that via the fact that I've addressed several players with specific citation of actions I found questionable.

No, you talked about traveling the world.

 

[ecofarm]

And this explanation does not provide me a reason why any of what I quoted has to do with this game.

specific citation of actions I found questionable.

By that, I mean this game.

 

[ecofarm]

By that, I mean this game.

I don't mean actions from other games, which no one (even the target) could be bothered with confirming.

I mean stuff that actually happened here and everyone can see herein.

 

[ecofarm]

No, you talked about traveling the world.

That was a personal flame, I've lived in Europe and Africa for years each, and before that I was a troop; you've no ground to preach reality to me.

 

[ecofarm]

caveat : my analysis depends heavily on meta. that being said, ##vote Ecofarm.

Thank you for being a fkg idiot, and after I supported your protection.

 

[ecofarm]

No, you talked about traveling the world.

Is that how Tucker seduced you?

 

[ecofarm]

I die at L-1, "Hated"

 

[ecofarm]

I have a handicap, "Hated".

If I'm L-1, I'm dead.

Please remove votes..

 

[ecofarm]

The Hated modifier makes it so that a player requires one less vote than normal to lynch. For example, if there are seven players alive, most players will require four votes to be lynched but a Hated player will only require three...

Hated players are easier to lynch. It's a simple way to weaken a role, albeit one that's not necessarily fun for the player. However, Hated Townies can cause problems by causing LyLo to occur earlier. If a seven-player LyLo consists of three Townies, one Hated Townie, and three scum; the scum have already won if they know who the Hated Townie is. (This is not to say that the scum should simply endgame the Town in this case, as they may not be aware of one of the players being Hated...

It is debatable whether it is better to not claim Hated Townie. By not claiming you are opening yourself up to getting run up to L-1 and thus unexpectedly lynched; by claiming you are making yourself a policy lynch on the Day before LyLo.

Hated - MafiaWiki

 

[ecofarm]

I don't mean to appear panicked, but I had not noticed that Chad voted for me and that would be L-2?

 

[ecofarm]

Never mind the fact that his attacks on me were both irrational and based on lies about what I said. He was depending on meta for his railroad of me, but he HATES it now that it is working against him. :lol

Aside Chad's vote (?) I hadn't noticed that either. Spooky.

 

[ecofarm]

I think I have 5 votes. That's L-1 for me.

 

[ecofarm]

If someone hammers me without reasonable consideration, we have a suspect.

I die at 6 votes.

 

[Chaddelamancha]

It states that it weakens a role. Does this imply that you have a role?

I think I have 5 votes. That's L-1 for me.

 

[ecofarm]

It states that it weakens a role. Does this imply that you have a role?

I will not state such at this time.

 

[ecofarm]

Can someone else check the confirmation on me being at 5 votes? I feel like I've been workin' my ass off and someone else can do something. Or fk y'all.

Remove a vote or eat a mislynch at next vote, by my quick calculation.

 

[ecofarm]

I think it's great how, as soon as Tucker votes for me (I'm not claiming a conspiracy) Pasch is here to update. But me at L-1 and he's nowhere to be found.

 

[cAPSLOCK]

If he's hated he likely also has a (probably powerful) PR. Hope he turns scum.