• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Southern Tradition of Women Hyphenating Last Name

VySky

VySky

Supporting Member
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 12, 2019
Messages
49,379
Reaction score
19,599
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Moderate
My roots run deep in the South. Yet I have never understood this Southern tradition.

It is common here for women to carry their maiden names as a middle name.

Then their kids, boys even, have to carry the hyphenated name.

Clearly, its a failure to submit to their husbands.

Thoughts?

=========================================

www.brides.com

Everything to Know About Hyphenating Your Last Name

Options for your married last name include hyphenating. If you’re thinking about joining both names with a hyphen, here are some things to consider.
www.brides.com www.brides.com
 
VySky said:
My roots run deep in the South. Yet I have never understood this Southern tradition.

It is common here for women to carry their maiden names as a middle name.

Then their kids, boys even, have to carry the hyphenated name.

Clearly, its a failure to submit to their husbands.

Thoughts?

=========================================

www.brides.com

Everything to Know About Hyphenating Your Last Name

Options for your married last name include hyphenating. If you’re thinking about joining both names with a hyphen, here are some things to consider.
www.brides.com www.brides.com
Click to expand...

My mother took her maiden name as a middle name and she's from the north.
 
VySky said:
Then their kids, boys even, have to carry the hyphenated name.

Clearly, its a failure to submit to their husbands.

Thoughts?

=========================================
Click to expand...
First....thanks for the giant laugh.
Next, my thoughts are I can't decide which of your two statements is the more ridiculous..... Even boys???? Submit to their husbands????

Do you live on this planet?
 
j brown's body said:
My mother took her maiden name as a middle name and she's from the north.
Click to expand...
My mother did also, and so did I. My step daughter hyphenated her name when she married. She had an established career, and had no wish to give up her name entirely. My niece never changed her last name at all. All from the north.
 
VySky said:
My roots run deep in the South. Yet I have never understood this Southern tradition.
Click to expand...

What makes you think it's a 'Southern' tradition? Because you happen to live in the South?

VySky said:
Clearly, its a failure to submit to their husbands.

Thoughts?
Click to expand...

Do you live in the Republic of Gilead?
 
VySky said:
en.wikipedia.org

John Parker Wilson - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
Click to expand...
Obviously you misunderstood my post, which might have been difficult for you. My intent was to convey astonishment that you thought boys should somehow be shielded from this horror of carrying their mother's name. But thanks for the link to wikipedia and John Parker Wilson.
 
VySky said:
My roots run deep in the South. Yet I have never understood this Southern tradition.

It is common here for women to carry their maiden names as a middle name.

Then their kids, boys even, have to carry the hyphenated name.

Clearly, its a failure to submit to their husbands.

Thoughts?

=========================================

www.brides.com

Everything to Know About Hyphenating Your Last Name

Options for your married last name include hyphenating. If you’re thinking about joining both names with a hyphen, here are some things to consider.
www.brides.com www.brides.com
Click to expand...
Where does "southern tradition" figure in?
 
Airyaman said:
Where does "southern tradition" figure in?
Click to expand...
Reading comprehension issues are not uncommon among the population.

Read slower
 
VySky said:
Reading comprehension issues are not uncommon among the population.

Read slower
Click to expand...
What are you wanting me to read slower? There is nothing about "southern tradition" in the article you posted.

Or are you talking about your assertion that it is a "southern tradition"? I see that, why do you think I asked? It's not a southern thing.
 
Airyaman said:
What are you wanting me to read slower? There is nothing about "southern tradition" in the article you posted.

Or are you talking about your assertion that it is a "southern tradition"? I see that, why do you think I asked? It's not a southern thing.
Click to expand...
You haven’t reviewed the links have you?
 
My mom kept her name and I got the hyphenated name. Also not from the South. Submission lol.
 
VySky said:
Thank me later

www.southernliving.com

How The Double-Name Trend Started And Stayed In The South

When you hear us calling for Sarah Jean or Bobbi Sue, you know you're in the South. Here's how the trend got started and why it remains popular today.
www.southernliving.com www.southernliving.com
Click to expand...
Giving your child a double first name like Bobbie Sue IS NOT the SAME as hyphenating your name when marrying. Please try to honestly defend your opening post and not dance around moving the goal posts constantly.
 
VySky said:
My roots run deep in the South. Yet I have never understood this Southern tradition.

It is common here for women to carry their maiden names as a middle name.

Then their kids, boys even, have to carry the hyphenated name.

Clearly, its a failure to submit to their husbands.

Thoughts?

=========================================

www.brides.com

Everything to Know About Hyphenating Your Last Name

Options for your married last name include hyphenating. If you’re thinking about joining both names with a hyphen, here are some things to consider.
www.brides.com www.brides.com
Click to expand...
Hispanic
 
JMR said:
My mother did also, and so did I. My step daughter hyphenated her name when she married. She had an established career, and had no wish to give up her name entirely. My niece never changed her last name at all. All from the north.
Click to expand...
Why did she alter her name at all?
Christmas, when I got married in 1978 I told my wife not to change her name.
Obviously it is 2024 so that ship has sailed.
The only women taking a man's last name are to make insecure men feel secure, powerful.
 
VySky said:
Thank me later

www.southernliving.com

How The Double-Name Trend Started And Stayed In The South

When you hear us calling for Sarah Jean or Bobbi Sue, you know you're in the South. Here's how the trend got started and why it remains popular today.
www.southernliving.com www.southernliving.com
Click to expand...
Why would I thank you, because Southern Living said it was a southern thing? Another assertion without much backer.

Or rather, the article was not about hyphenating last names, it was the double name: Bobby Sue, Joe Bob, Mary Jane, etc.
 
JMR said:
Giving your child a double first name like Bobbie Sue IS NOT the SAME as hyphenating your name when marrying. Please try to honestly defend your opening post and not dance around moving the goal posts constantly.
Click to expand...
MAGA through and through, can never admit errors.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom