Should Elon Musk be Deported?

[Parker_Chess]

My vote is that he's ungrateful and deserves deportation. And can you imagine an American citizen immigrating to South Africa and being vocal in their local politics? This might be an unpopular opinion but if you are immigrating to a country you should mostly stay low on voicing your criticism against their culture, society, and government. It comes across as disrespectful.

 

[Mycroft]

Should Elon Musk be Deported?​

No

 

[Gatsby]

We should not de-naturalize US citizens except in the most extreme circumstances, of which Elon Musk is not one.

 

[Gatsby]

And can you imagine an American citizen immigrating to South Africa and being vocal in their local politics?

If they became citizens of South Africa they would have every right to be vocal in their local politics just like any other South African.

This might be an unpopular opinion but if you are immigrating to a country you should mostly stay low on voicing your criticism against their culture, society, and government. It comes across as disrespectful.

You're right, that's an unpopular opinion. We don't have second-class citizens. All US citizens can participate in our democracy and freedom of speech, no matter where in the world they were born.

 

[Mr Person]

No. Deport the brownshirts carrying out Trump's orders.

 

[Felis Leo]

My vote is that he's ungrateful and deserves deportation. And can you imagine an American citizen immigrating to South Africa and being vocal in their local politics? This might be an unpopular opinion but if you are immigrating to a country you should mostly stay low on voicing your criticism against their culture, society, and government. It comes across as disrespectful.

No. A criminal case should be opened against him and he should be arrested, tried and, if convicted, rot in prison for the rest of his life for engaging in such flagrant corruption (and often admitting to it publicly).

 

[Helix]

 

[SkyChief]

Should Elon Musk be Deported?

This (absurd) poll question is based on the false premise that he can be deported. Elon Musk is a U.S. citizen - he cannot be deported.

 

[Felis Leo]

The poll question is nonsensical. Elon Musk is a U.S. citizen - he cannot be deported.

Musk can be deported if he is de-naturalized and stripped of his citizenship.

 

[SkyChief]

Musk can be deported if he is de-naturalized and stripped of his citizenship.

That's a myth. A U.S. citizen cannot be "stripped" of citizenship.

There are some exceptions: if they are involved in persecution or genocide, or have been actively involved with a terrorist organization, then they may be denaturalized.

None of these exceptions apply to Musk. He cannot be deported.

 

[Felis Leo]

That's a myth. A U.S. citizen cannot be "stripped" of citizenship.

Born citizens no. Naturalized citizens can be.

 

[Atomic Kid]

My vote is that he's ungrateful and deserves deportation. And can you imagine an American citizen immigrating to South Africa and being vocal in their local politics? This might be an unpopular opinion but if you are immigrating to a country you should mostly stay low on voicing your criticism against their culture, society, and government. It comes across as disrespectful.

Musk has been a US citizen for 23 years. How many years does a naturalized citizen have to wait before they are allowed to criticize governmental policies or anything else? Do their 1rst Amendment rights have an asterisk next to them?

 

[Atomic Kid]

Born citizens no. Naturalized citizens can be.

In that case, let's get Melania packed up and ready to go.

 

[American]

My vote is that he's ungrateful and deserves deportation. And can you imagine an American citizen immigrating to South Africa and being vocal in their local politics? This might be an unpopular opinion but if you are immigrating to a country you should mostly stay low on voicing your criticism against their culture, society, and government. It comes across as disrespectful.

He's an American citizen, good luck.

 

[American]

No. Deport the brownshirts carrying out Trump's orders.

Show me some brownshirts. Make sure they are following the law.

 

[Deuce]

This (absurd) poll question is based on the false premise that he can be deported. Elon Musk is a U.S. citizen - he cannot be deported.

Google "denaturalization."