• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Obama Border Patrol chief to Trump: ‘Stay the course’ on the border wall

This shutdown will destroy Trump in the end. His non-political history is no match for the likes of Nancy Pelosi as she knows how politics work while Trump is a clueless fool.
 
If I was the President of the United States, I bet I could convince people to get behind me and support replacing the American Bald Eagle with a turkey as the U.S. National emblem. The same goes for Trump's wall. He brings the NBPC representatives to Washington to say what he wants them to say, not what the majority of their union believes. As you can see, there is a lot more to this story than just a few Border Patrol agents say "we need a wall" then others say "we need more security and a fence in vulnerable area where it's needed".

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/01/trump-nbpc/580237/
Funny you would quote an article "opining" about why border patrol agents would support a wall(I thought it was very condescending, BTW) instead of just posting the facts.

Here are the facts...

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2018/apr/2/border-patrol-agents-back-trump-wall-survey-finds/

The findings, shared with The Washington Times, appear to undercut the argument of congressional Democrats, who released a report last month concluding that line agents didn’t support Mr. Trump’s plans for a wall. The report was based on an internal tool used by Homeland Security to evaluate security gaps.

The NBPC’s survey, of more than 600 agents in two of the Border Patrol’s busiest sectors, found just the opposite: A stunning 89 percent of line agents say a “wall system in strategic locations is necessary to securing the border.” Just 7 percent disagreed.

89% support.
 
Get over it already. There's never going to be a big beautiful border wall paid for by Mexico. The End.

Probably not but I wouldn't mind seeing large stretches of wall in places where people can just stroll across unimpeded right now.
 
Great job of research?

From the same source...



The source concludes that border agents want a wall. You really should read beyond the headline.


Jeez, the guys who answer to Trump, the sector chiefs...agree with Trump? Well blow me down, would of guessed. It's not like Trump is the kind of person that would fire someone if they disagreed with him...right?

You really shouldn't just read something without taking the time to think about who said what, and why they might have said it.
 
I know this wasn't directed at me, but what a bunch of nonsense. Everyone is discussing the wall, sorry you don't like that others have a different opinion than you, but so what?

She got caught posting Alt Right non sense.....
 
Probably not but I wouldn't mind seeing large stretches of wall in places where people can just stroll across unimpeded right now.

Stroll across????...Where is that?...Much of the border is in the desert far away from any road....Nobody is just strolling across..Total non sense
 
Just like we need to reduce America’s demand for illegal drugs. How’s that working for you? We’ve run out of sound bites and easy solutions. The democrats whan border security that stops working when they quietly defund it, walls are hard to knock down without prople noticing.

There are viable solutions besides eminent domain. The ranchers are not as unreasonable as the media would have you think. When the wall gets there, then they can sue.

Where have Dems defunded border security, the amount give to border security each year has INCREASED. So please show where Dems defunded anything dealing with Border Security.
 
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/22/us/politics/border-patrol-wall-immigration-trump-senate-democrats.html

What Border Agents Say They Want (It’s Not a Wall)


WASHINGTON — President Trump has called for a wall along the border with Mexico to stop undocumented immigrants and drugs from entering the United States. But Border Patrol agents on the front lines say they need more technology and additional personnel to curb the illegal traffic, according to a report released on Thursday by Democrats on the Senate Homeland Security Committee.

The report was based on internal Customs and Border Protection documents from the 2017 fiscal year. It concluded that less than one half of 1 percent of the agents’ suggestions to secure the Southwest border mentioned the need for a wall.


The documents show that the Border Patrol identified what it called 902 “capability gaps,” or vulnerabilities, on the Southwest border. The word “wall” was suggested as a possible solution for just three of those gaps.

Sorry but I'll trust this survey and a statement by the current head of border security, rather than a report released by Democrats on the Senate Homeland Security Committee from your source above.

Border Patrol agents overwhelmingly support Trump's wall in new survey

Border Patrol Chief: 'We Certainly Need a Wall, Any Agent Will Tell You That'
 
Jeez, the guys who answer to Trump, the sector chiefs...agree with Trump? Well blow me down, would of guessed. It's not like Trump is the kind of person that would fire someone if they disagreed with him...right?

You really shouldn't just read something without taking the time to think about who said what, and why they might have said it.

I actually did my homework.

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2018/apr/2/border-patrol-agents-back-trump-wall-survey-finds/

The NBPC’s survey, of more than 600 agents in two of the Border Patrol’s busiest sectors, found just the opposite: A stunning 89 percent of line agents say a “wall system in strategic locations is necessary to securing the border.” Just 7 percent disagreed.

89% support among border agents. Did you REALLY believe that border agents didn't overwhelmingly support this? If you did... why?
 
Sorry but I'll trust this survey and a statement by the current head of border security, rather than a report released by Democrats on the Senate Homeland Security Committee from your source above.

Border Patrol agents overwhelmingly support Trump's wall in new survey

Border Patrol Chief: 'We Certainly Need a Wall, Any Agent Will Tell You That'

Not a problem, it's your right to support whatever you want to support. There might be some money for border security, but it's going to include money for a border fence, not a wall.
 
Stroll across????...Where is that?...Much of the border is in the desert far away from any road....Nobody is just strolling across..Total non sense

Yep, and that's the part that could most use a wall.
 
And we have barriers in strategic places. Trump has been bragging about it ... remember?

Of the remaining problems, new walls are not high on the list of priorities.

Maybe not high on the list of YOUR priorities but there are many, including the vast majority of border agents, who would disagree.
 
Funny to see the trump ass Kissers bringing up Obama....Constantly

You mean like you libs blamed everything on Bush for 8 yrs. But you know Obama failed at everything he did. He's a few examples.

Obama's Stupidly,
*
Putin told Obamafail to stay out of Crimea and he said yes sir. How stupid was that???
*
Putin told Obamafail to NOT sell arms to Ukrainian and he said yes sir. How stupid was that.
*
Putin told Obamafail to NOT put our missile defense shield in NATO, he again says yes sir. How stupid was that.
*
Obamafail asked Putin of all people to certify that all of Syria’s WMD were taking out of Syria and Putin lied to Obamafail. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail told Russia that once he is reelected he can be more flexible to what Putin wants. How stupid was that. Obamafail loved Putin and did whatever Putin wanted. How stupid was that. Watch the video.
*
https://video.search.yahoo.com/sear...ebe22615f3d65bfe65b0b38fafc50134&action=click
*
Obamafail was in office and what did he do to shut down NK’s nuclear program. Absolutely nothing. Obamafail was a stupid coward.
*
Obamafail flies in the middle of the night to Iran to deliver billions in cash so that Iran can fund their terrorists group without the money being traced. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail cuts a deal with Iran to delay the making of nukes for 10 yrs and the agreement does not have inspections anywhere anytime. Not only that, no one can inspect any of Iran’s military bases. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail pulls out of Iraq and leaves ISIS to materialize and when they do he calls them the JV Team. However that JV Team was not JV at all, making Obamafail to go back into Iraq to try to eradicate ISIS by tying the hands of our military. Thus he could not eradicate ISIS. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail yells out his RED LINE to Syria to never use WMD’s on its people again, Yep Syria walked all over Obamafail’s RED LINE. Obamafail does nothing. What a ****ing dumbass coward.
*
Obamafail bombs the crap out of Lybia and walks away. And in doing so the resistance builds and raids our embassy killing four of our own. And Obamafail goes around calling it a protest of some stupid video. How stupid can this dumbass be?
*
Obamafail borrows and spends 10 trillion doubling our national and has the crown of borrowing more than all the president before him combinded. And what did we get, the worst economic recovery in US History. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail gives Solyndra 400 million of tax payer money to make solar panels, the company goes broke. How stupid was that????
*
Obamafail bails out GM with taxpayer money that we lost 11.2 billion on the deal. How stupid was that.
https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/30/gm-bailout-cost_n_5240260.html
*
Obamafail campaigned on closing Clubgetmo and guess what it’s still in use. How stupid was that???
*
Obamafail’s signature so called achievement was Obamacare that he promised you can keep your Dr., you can keep your insurance, and you’ll save $2,500 per yr per family on your health insurance. Guess what Obamacare was a complete failure. How stupid was he????
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpa-5JdCnmo
*
Obamafail’s rollout of Obamacare was the worst in US History, and he had to continue to write executive orders to push out dates of different parts of Obamacare so that it would not crash under his term in office. Not one Republican voted for Obamafails signature failure. How stupid was he????
*
Obamafail locked up Utah’s land for a park but that got overturned by Trump. How stupid was that????
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/dec/28/obama-claims-16m-western-acres-national-monuments/
*
Obamafail, did what to get NATO to get them to pay their fair share which is 2% of their GDP, but none of them were paying up except the US paying our share and subsidizing them.
*
Obamafail buys his allies, how stupid is that?????
*
Obamafail killed the Keystone pipeline, why? Because he thought the pipeline would be safer and less expensive, can’t have that so he killed it. How stupid was that???
*
What did Obamafail do against China for stealing our intellectual capital? And China ripping us off on trade. He did not a ****ing thing, what a stupid coward he was?
*
What did Obamafail do to kill NAFTA that was ripping off our country? And renegotiate NAFTA for a better deal. What a stupid coward he was?
*
Obamafail cuts a deal with Iran so they can have nukes in 10 yrs. and he has no inspections anytime anywhere. BTW Obamafail could not go on an Iran military bass. How stupid is that. Remember Reagan’s famous quote “trust but verify” Obamafail missed that speech.
*
I could go on and on but no use.
*
I would say Harvard didn’t teach him a ****ing thing.
 
Really?...So you think people are walking a 100 miles into the desert ,cross, and walk 100 more to a road?...Absurd
This is where the coyotes come in. You have heard of them, right?
 
You mean like you libs blamed everything on Bush for 8 yrs. But you know Obama failed at everything he did. He's a few examples.

Obama's Stupidly,
*
Putin told Obamafail to stay out of Crimea and he said yes sir. How stupid was that???
*
Putin told Obamafail to NOT sell arms to Ukrainian and he said yes sir. How stupid was that.
*
Putin told Obamafail to NOT put our missile defense shield in NATO, he again says yes sir. How stupid was that.
*
Obamafail asked Putin of all people to certify that all of Syria’s WMD were taking out of Syria and Putin lied to Obamafail. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail told Russia that once he is reelected he can be more flexible to what Putin wants. How stupid was that. Obamafail loved Putin and did whatever Putin wanted. How stupid was that. Watch the video.
*
https://video.search.yahoo.com/sear...ebe22615f3d65bfe65b0b38fafc50134&action=click
*
Obamafail was in office and what did he do to shut down NK’s nuclear program. Absolutely nothing. Obamafail was a stupid coward.
*
Obamafail flies in the middle of the night to Iran to deliver billions in cash so that Iran can fund their terrorists group without the money being traced. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail cuts a deal with Iran to delay the making of nukes for 10 yrs and the agreement does not have inspections anywhere anytime. Not only that, no one can inspect any of Iran’s military bases. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail pulls out of Iraq and leaves ISIS to materialize and when they do he calls them the JV Team. However that JV Team was not JV at all, making Obamafail to go back into Iraq to try to eradicate ISIS by tying the hands of our military. Thus he could not eradicate ISIS. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail yells out his RED LINE to Syria to never use WMD’s on its people again, Yep Syria walked all over Obamafail’s RED LINE. Obamafail does nothing. What a ****ing dumbass coward.
*
Obamafail bombs the crap out of Lybia and walks away. And in doing so the resistance builds and raids our embassy killing four of our own. And Obamafail goes around calling it a protest of some stupid video. How stupid can this dumbass be?
*
Obamafail borrows and spends 10 trillion doubling our national and has the crown of borrowing more than all the president before him combinded. And what did we get, the worst economic recovery in US History. How stupid was that?
*
Obamafail gives Solyndra 400 million of tax payer money to make solar panels, the company goes broke. How stupid was that????
*
Obamafail bails out GM with taxpayer money that we lost 11.2 billion on the deal. How stupid was that.
https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/30/gm-bailout-cost_n_5240260.html
*
Obamafail campaigned on closing Clubgetmo and guess what it’s still in use. How stupid was that???
*
Obamafail’s signature so called achievement was Obamacare that he promised you can keep your Dr., you can keep your insurance, and you’ll save $2,500 per yr per family on your health insurance. Guess what Obamacare was a complete failure. How stupid was he????
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpa-5JdCnmo
*
Obamafail’s rollout of Obamacare was the worst in US History, and he had to continue to write executive orders to push out dates of different parts of Obamacare so that it would not crash under his term in office. Not one Republican voted for Obamafails signature failure. How stupid was he????
*
Obamafail locked up Utah’s land for a park but that got overturned by Trump. How stupid was that????
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/dec/28/obama-claims-16m-western-acres-national-monuments/
*
Obamafail, did what to get NATO to get them to pay their fair share which is 2% of their GDP, but none of them were paying up except the US paying our share and subsidizing them.
*
Obamafail buys his allies, how stupid is that?????
*
Obamafail killed the Keystone pipeline, why? Because he thought the pipeline would be safer and less expensive, can’t have that so he killed it. How stupid was that???
*
What did Obamafail do against China for stealing our intellectual capital? And China ripping us off on trade. He did not a ****ing thing, what a stupid coward he was?
*
What did Obamafail do to kill NAFTA that was ripping off our country? And renegotiate NAFTA for a better deal. What a stupid coward he was?
*
Obamafail cuts a deal with Iran so they can have nukes in 10 yrs. and he has no inspections anytime anywhere. BTW Obamafail could not go on an Iran military bass. How stupid is that. Remember Reagan’s famous quote “trust but verify” Obamafail missed that speech.
*
I could go on and on but no use.
*
I would say Harvard didn’t teach him a ****ing thing.

You got nothin ....What a joke
 
The NBPC position regarding walls and fences is not due to a concern of losing our jobs if fences and walls are built. On the contrary, the NBPC realizes that walls and fences require just as much manpower to protect them. Border Patrol Agents witness what happens to walls and fences when there are not enough Border Patrol agents to protect them.

One of many things that kills me about this whole stupid debacle. A wall will only accomplish its goal with monitoring all along it, which requires a huge expenditure on new infrastructure, personnel, supply chains, etc., all along the length.Otherwise, they'll just cross where there isn't said monitoring. And even then, it'd only stop 25% of illegals from arriving. Most likely, that would only be temporary as alternate routes (ie, by water) are worked out.

The whole thing breathtakingly absurd.




If people really cared about illegal immigration, they'd be demanding we focus on their reason for coming here, not on a wall & deport policy. Ramped up nationwide e-verify, allocation of a whole bunch more resources to enforcing against employers, ramping up penalties on employers such that the risk of being caught with illegals employed cannot be considered a cost of business. I'm sure we could come up with more if people really cared to think about it. If they can't get work here, they'll not be coming here to try to take anyone's job. They'll be genuine asylum seekers.

But no, they need to demand a big stupid wall while not being honest about what it would require to make it work, just so they can manufacture an issue to wield against Democrats who, as they like to point out, have allocated money for border security. If they demand a wall, their wishes are less likely to be granted. Thus, they can always attack "the left" dishonestly about supposedly wanting open borders. Only a few fools truly want that.
 
Last edited:
Yep, and that's the part that could most use a wall.

If the risk of death in an arduous journey across a desert isn't going to deter someone, a mere wall will be the least of their concerns. If the GOP really wants a wall, they need to be honest about what it will cost to adequately monitor/patrol such that it really does work.

Otherwise, you know, things like ladders, tunnels, catapults, ropes, and the like have existed for a very long time.




And remember: only about 25% of them cross at the southern border. The vast majority are visa overstays.
 
Not a problem, it's your right to support whatever you want to support. There might be some money for border security, but it's going to include money for a border fence, not a wall.

Trump has recently said a fence is okay.... 500 hundred miles of replacement fence would be enough for him, and yet, the obstructionist congressional dimwits don't want to fund it.

I support fences because I know they work.
I lived 10 miles from the San Diego border for 10 years.
They work. Are they 100%? Nope... Nothing is certain but death and taxes.
 
Trump has recently said a fence is okay.... 500 hundred miles of replacement fence would be enough for him, and yet, the obstructionist congressional dimwits don't want to fund it.

trump told his base of idiot bigots it was going to be a wall...and Mexico would pay for it...Try to keep up
 
Maybe not high on the list of YOUR priorities but there are many, including the vast majority of border agents, who would disagree.

Your article surveying agents in two busy sectors doesn't rebut list of priorities in the New York Times article. There's a whole lot which needs done. Increased stretches of wall only addresses a small part of it. Trump needs to show he's serious about comprehensive reform ... as opposed to being willing to make Americans homeless and unable to afford food or medication all for a dollar figure that he pulled out of his ass for something he promised we wouldn't have to pay for.
 
You got nothin ....What a joke

Your right, but the joke is on you for voting for an idiot that knew nothing. Obamafail is the worst president ever. And you have to be so proud of all his failures.
 
Trump has recently said a fence is okay.... 500 hundred miles of replacement fence would be enough for him, and yet, the obstructionist congressional dimwits don't want to fund it.

Doesn't matter what he said in December, it's January and he has changed his mind at least twice since he made that statement. He wants a 'wall', not a fence, not a see-through beautiful concrete filled steel beams, he wants a wall, a concrete wall. Democrats passed legislation the day they took control of the House that offered $1.3 billion for border security, including physical barriers and technology along the U.S. southern border. Last year, the Congress voted yes on a bill to give him 1.6 billion for his wall. That money has yet to be spent, it's sitting somewhere, unspent.
 
Back
Top Bottom