• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Momentum Transfer Analysis of the Collapse of the Upper Storeys of WTC 1

creativedreams

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Dec 21, 2008
Messages
2,730
Reaction score
239
Location
Timbuktu
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Conservative
Momentum Transfer Analysis of the Collapse of the Upper Storeys of WTC 1


Here are some facts for the people new to physics and the world of mechanical engineering. The following is and excerpt. You can follow the whole thing at this link.

http://www.journalof911studies.com/articles/Journal_5_PTransferRoss.pdf

Author:
The author of this work, Gordon Ross, was born in Dundee, Scotland. He holds degrees in
both Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering, graduating from Liverpool John
Moores University, in 1984.

Energy Summary:
The energy balance can be summarized as
Energy available;
Kinetic energy 2105MJ
Potential energy Additional downward movement 95MJ
Compression of impacting section 32MJ
Compression of impacted section 24MJ
Total Energy available 2256MJ
Energy required;
Momentum losses 1389MJ
Plastic strain energy in lower impacted story 244MJ
Plastic strain energy in upper impacted story 215MJ
Elastic strain energy in lower stories 64MJ
Elastic strain energy in upper stories 126MJ
Pulverization of concrete on impacting floor 304MJ
Pulverization of concrete on impacted floor 304MJ
Total Energy required 2646MJ
Minimum Energy Deficit -390MJ

Conclusion:
The energy balance of the collapse moves into deficit during the plastic shortening phase of the first impacted columns showing that there would be insufficient energy available from the released potential energy of the upper section to satisfy all of the energy demands of the collision. The analysis shows that despite the assumptions made in favor of collapse continuation, vertical movement of the falling section would be arrested prior to completion of the 3% shortening phase of the impacted columns, and within 0.02 seconds after impact.
A collapse driven only by gravity would not continue to progress beyond that point.

LF: Former German Minister Says Building 7 Used To Run 9/11 Attack Guide the planes in, then destroy the crime scene

Former Helmut Schmidt cabinet member, 25-year German Parliamentarian and global intelligence expert Andreas Von Bülow says that ..."the 9/11 attack was run by the highest levels of the US intelligence apparatus using WTC Building 7 as a command bunker which was later demolished in order to destroy the crime scene."

Former German Minister Says... "Building 7 Used To Run 9/11 Attack Guide the planes in, then destroy the crime scene"

Building #7 held offices of the CIA.......

MARVIN BUSH, BUILDING 7 AND FORBIDDEN QUESTIONS Hidden History

The German Minister says he believes the WTC Buildings were rigged with explosives while Marvin Bush was head of security for the airlines and the World Trade Center Buildings


WTC1 went from the top photo to the bottom photo.

Many Americans much of who are prominent physicists, scientists, architects believe likely after an hour was taken to determine where to start the collapse sequence of explosives.

wtcsmoke.jpg


site1103.jpg
 
Last edited:
Here is an interview with the German Defense Minister

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cGNvmp7w85U"]YouTube- Andreas Von Bülow On 9/11[/ame]
 
Where is he getting this "up to 60" states thing from?
 
Fail ... here too ...

Here is an interview with the German Defense Minister

YouTube- Andreas Von Bülow On 9/11

Wrong creative ... you have deliberatly misconstructed that sentence to make it seem as though this "is" the current Minister !!!

Andreas von Bülow was NEVER the actual Minister in charge ... he was the State-Secretary to the German Federal Ministy of Defence ... until 1980 ... TWENTY-NINE YEARS AGO !!!

The current Verteidigungsminister is Dr. Karl Theodor Freiherr zu Guttenberg ...

BMVg.de: Startseite BMVg.de

Seriously creative ... WHY can you not even get the simple facts right ???

Just like your previous sock-puppetry ... you engage in the dishonest practise of intentional poor grammar to make your statment sound more credible and important than the reality ... :spin:

Or did you just not know, as you gullibly swallow everthing blindly from conspiracy sites ???

In any case ... as you have been told before von Bülow made those statements in either 2003 or 2005 ... and they were PERSONAL opinions ... which had neither the backing nor patronage of ANY part of the actual Bundestag ... therefore, creative ... they have ZERO relevance NOW !!!

Like I said before ... your not very good at this ... perchance you would consider a more suitable hobby ... train spotting or knitting would probably be more in keeping ...;)
 
Momentum Transfer Analysis of the Collapse of the Upper Storeys of WTC 1


Here are some facts for the people new to physics and the world of mechanical engineering. The following is and excerpt. You can follow the whole thing at this link.

http://www.journalof911studies.com/articles/Journal_5_PTransferRoss.pdf

Author:
The author of this work, Gordon Ross, was born in Dundee, Scotland. He holds degrees in
both Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering, graduating from Liverpool John
Moores University, in 1984.

Energy Summary:
The energy balance can be summarized as
Energy available;
Kinetic energy 2105MJ
Potential energy Additional downward movement 95MJ
Compression of impacting section 32MJ
Compression of impacted section 24MJ
Total Energy available 2256MJ
Energy required;
Momentum losses 1389MJ
Plastic strain energy in lower impacted story 244MJ
Plastic strain energy in upper impacted story 215MJ
Elastic strain energy in lower stories 64MJ
Elastic strain energy in upper stories 126MJ
Pulverization of concrete on impacting floor 304MJ
Pulverization of concrete on impacted floor 304MJ
Total Energy required 2646MJ
Minimum Energy Deficit -390MJ

Conclusion:
The energy balance of the collapse moves into deficit during the plastic shortening phase of the first impacted columns showing that there would be insufficient energy available from the released potential energy of the upper section to satisfy all of the energy demands of the collision. The analysis shows that despite the assumptions made in favor of collapse continuation, vertical movement of the falling section would be arrested prior to completion of the 3% shortening phase of the impacted columns, and within 0.02 seconds after impact.
A collapse driven only by gravity would not continue to progress beyond that point.

LF: Former German Minister Says Building 7 Used To Run 9/11 Attack Guide the planes in, then destroy the crime scene

Former Helmut Schmidt cabinet member, 25-year German Parliamentarian and global intelligence expert Andreas Von Bülow says that ..."the 9/11 attack was run by the highest levels of the US intelligence apparatus using WTC Building 7 as a command bunker which was later demolished in order to destroy the crime scene."

Former German Minister Says... "Building 7 Used To Run 9/11 Attack Guide the planes in, then destroy the crime scene"

Building #7 held offices of the CIA.......

MARVIN BUSH, BUILDING 7 AND FORBIDDEN QUESTIONS Hidden History

The German Minister says he believes the WTC Buildings were rigged with explosives while Marvin Bush was head of security for the airlines and the World Trade Center Buildings


WTC1 went from the top photo to the bottom photo.

Many Americans much of who are prominent physicists, scientists, architects believe likely after an hour was taken to determine where to start the collapse sequence of explosives.

wtcsmoke.jpg


site1103.jpg

Unless they're working in a frictionless vacuum, physics calculations will always differ from real world results
 
Re: Fail ... here too ...

... perchance you would consider a more suitable hobby ... train spotting or knitting would probably be more in keeping ...;)

My great grandma used to knit.....She had a rug loom in her basement too and made many rugs. I still have some of her work.:)

Perhaps I will retire from being on a mission to sway the masses for a new 9/11 investigation.

Hmmmmm, what to do?

The sky is the limit!

Speaking of skies.....maybe I'll just Gaze at the Blue all day like someone else I know.....;)
 
Last edited:
Retirement wishes ...

My great grandma used to knit.....She had a rug loom in her basement too and made many rugs. I still have some of her work.:)

Perhaps I will retire from being on a mission to sway the masses for a new 9/11 investigation.

Hmmmmm, what to do?

The sky is the limit!

Speaking of skies.....maybe I'll just Gaze at the Blue all day like someone else I know.....;)

Happy Retirement ... rug-making ... good job !!! :2wave:

Sure you will be better at it than you are at research and debate.

Btw ... my user name does not refer to me gazing mindlessly into the blue yonder, as you obviously think, but rather my career with the Royal Air Force ... :roll:
 
Re: Retirement wishes ...

Btw ... my user name does not refer to me gazing mindlessly into the blue yonder, as you obviously think, but rather my career with the Royal Air Force ... :roll:

So now you moved on to a propaganda mission to infiltrate petitions to try and destroy the credibility of the many legitimate prominent people on them who want a new and independent investigation into 9/11 and effectively eliminating the petitions?


So now you moved on to a propaganda mission to sway the opinions of the masses and votes from asking for a new and independent investigation?
 
Re: Retirement wishes ...

So now you moved on to a propaganda mission to infiltrate petitions to try and destroy the credibility of the many legitimate prominent people on them who want a new and independent investigation into 9/11 and effectively eliminating the petitions?


So now you moved on to a propaganda mission to sway the opinions of the masses and votes from asking for a new and independent investigation?

Yawn ...

Btw creative ... stop telling lies it was NOT petitions ... it was ONE !!!

And as told to you many times it was to TEST standards ... how does lil'ol' me doing that "stop" anyone from signing ???

Did it stop you ???
 
Back
Top Bottom