[Minnesota] She PITCHES like a man!

[Master Debator]

If there's something medically wrong, yes. The desire to follow a trend is not something medically wrong.

Who's saying that? Can you quote anyone suggesting medicine should follow trends?

There isn't. And whether she wanted either they have a brain abnormality or it's psychological.

Brain abnormalities sound like medical issues to me but I'm not a doctor, are you?

Why would I need to be a medical doctor to understand sterilizing a boy doesn't make them into a girl?

You have to be a doctor to diagnosis medical issues and a doctor to prescribe treatment. That's what all the education and testing is for. I'm trying to discern your level of understanding of medical issues.

What medical issues am I diagnosing?

Brain abnormalities, psychological problems, and recommended treatments. What are being so hilariously frail and pretending you don't know what I'm referring to?

Only if there's a medical condition that is life threatening.

How would you know? What's your level of medical training?

in not pro castration in any instance. If it's necessary, then it's necessary

So you're pro castration when necessary? Why are your arguments getting meeker and meeker as we speak?

People have you don't have to care what I think you don't have to read my posts you don't have to respond.

I don't have any problem with reading. My issue isn't about having to read your posts but in critiquing the things you claim to speak as an authority about.

When you read my posts and respond to that suggests you care what I think.

I am curious why you think you're capable of treating Trans kids but mostly for amusement purposes.

???

There's no such thing as trans kids.

Tell that to the medical community.

Presumably trans people have existed all throughout history. Why weren't they dying of not being castrated in 1957

Who says they weren't?

Prior to anybody offering mutilation to children there weren't a rash of children identifying as the opposite sex and committing suicide over it.

Prior to tracking suicide rates and endeavoring to discern why how would you know they weren't?

I'm going to answer this one more time I don't practice medicine I don't have any education in it.

Then why shouldn't I laugh at you pretending to be as capable as one online?

If you ask me this question again I'm just going to ignore it.

Go ahead. I'm not going to ignore you pretending to know what you're talking about. That I'm going to point at and laugh at all ****ing day.

 

[CLAX1911]

Who's saying that? Can you quote anyone suggesting medicine should follow trends?

I didn't think offering cosmetic surgery to 9 year olds who are otherwise healthy is medically necessary

Brain abnormalities sound like medical issues to me but I'm not a doctor, are you?

Operating on genitals when the problem is cerebral is seems wrong

You have to be a doctor to diagnosis medical issues and a doctor to prescribe treatment.

Agreed list the patients I have diagnosed or prescribed something to.

That's what all the education and testing is for. I'm trying to discern your level of understanding of medical issues.

the problem with appealing to authority is sometimes they can be wrong

Brain abnormalities, psychological problems, and recommended treatments.

In a person that hasn't developed yet?

What are being so hilariously frail and pretending you don't know what I'm referring to?

Frail? Who have I diagnosed?

What's your level of medical training?

Same as it was last time you asked. Appealing to authority is illogical

So you're pro castration when necessary?

No. That it can be a necessary injury.

Why are your arguments getting meeker and meeker as we speak?

Why am I not adding with your misinterpretations?

I don't have any problem with reading. My issue isn't about having to read your posts but in critiquing the things you claim to speak as an authority about.

When did I say I was an authority? I question authority because hierarchy isn't my god.

I am curious why you think you're capable of treating Trans kids but mostly for amusement purposes.

There's no such things as trans kids.

Tell that to the medical community.

Okay hey medical community there's no such thing as trans kids

Who says they weren't?

Evidence.

Prior to tracking suicide rates and endeavoring to discern why how would you know they weren't?

The number of people who killed themselves.

Then why shouldn't I laugh at you pretending to be as capable as one online?

Laugh at whatever false assumptions you make. It has nothing to do with my posts

Go ahead. I'm not going to ignore you pretending to know what you're talking about. That I'm going to point at and laugh at all ****ing day.

Over compensate however you need.

 

[Master Debator]

I didn't think offering cosmetic surgery to 9 year olds who are otherwise healthy is medically necessary

You keep arguing so frail like. What is this strawman you're beating up here? And why aren't you embarrassed to be doing it in public?

Present one case of anyone doing cosmetic surgery on a healthy 9 year old.

Operating on genitals when the problem is cerebral is seems wrong

It seems wrong to you but then again your medical knowledge, by your own admission, is zero.

Agreed list the patients I have diagnosed or prescribed something to.

Again with this hilarious fragility and meekness. Are you or are you not here arguing there is no diagnosis such as trans for children and that gender affirming care is not only the wrong choice but abuse? Are you going to be this meek about your own argument this entire time?

the problem with appealing to authority is sometimes they can be wrong

I'm willing discuss the merits of why doctors and biologists feel the way they do but mostly what I'm doing here is establishing that you are not any sort of authority. I'm establishing that you're completely ignorant when it comes to diagnosing medical issues and prescribing treatment.

In a person that hasn't developed yet?

Are you asking me because you're too frail to make an argument you can't support?

Frail? Who have I diagnosed?

Yes frail. You go ahead and keep pretending you arent here trying to argue you know what's better for trans children than their doctors. The meekness only hurts your own claims.

Same as it was last time you asked. Appealing to authority is illogical

I'm not appealing to authority, I'm establishing that you are not one in any sense.

No. That it can be a necessary injury.

Why am I not adding with your misinterpretations?

When did I say I was an authority? I question authority because hierarchy isn't my god.

Then why are you pretending to know better than their doctors?

There's no such things as trans kids.

Say you, who admits they dont know what theyre talking about. Why are you making these claims when you dont know what you are talking about?

Okay hey medical community there's no such thing as trans kids

It really is amusing watching the hubris from uneducated people who don't realize how silly they look admitting they have no education in a particular area while telling the people who do that they have it all wrong.

Evidence.

The number of people who killed themselves.

Laugh at whatever false assumptions you make. It has nothing to do with my posts

Over compensate however you need.

I don't have to make assumptions. You yourself told me of your ignorance and yet you're also still trying to pretend you know what you're talking about. That's some funny shit.

 

[CLAX1911]

You keep arguing so frail like.

This doesn't make sense. You've made that statement now twice how do you argue frail-like what does that even mean?

What is this strawman you're beating up here? And why aren't you embarrassed to be doing it in public?

Make up your mind am I arguing frail light or am I making a straw man fallacy?

Present one case of anyone doing cosmetic surgery on a healthy 9 year old.

Fair points I'm not sure this sort of thing happens to a 9 year old but giving them castration drugs does

It seems wrong to you but then again your medical knowledge, by your own admission, is zero.

There's no medical reason castrated otherwise healthy 9-year-old.

Again with this hilarious fragility and meekness.

Are you or are you not here arguing there is no diagnosis such as trans for children and that gender affirming care is not only the wrong choice but abuse? Are you going to be this meek about your own argument this entire time?

There are no trans children that's false. I don't entertain that falsehood because it's a lie. Is projecting something onto children.

I'm willing discuss the merits of why doctors and biologists feel the way they do but mostly what I'm doing here is establishing that you are not any sort of authority.

I already established that you're wasting your time.

I'm establishing that you're completely ignorant when it comes to diagnosing medical issues and prescribing treatment.

You're calling me stupid because I don't share your ideology.

Are you asking me because you're too frail to make an argument you can't support?

No I'm asking you because I want you to answer.

Yes frail. You go ahead and keep pretending you arent here trying to argue you know what's better for trans children than their doctors. The meekness only hurts your own claims.

There's no such thing as trans children that is a projection on the children. Like a father who really wants his son to go into football he's projecting his views on to the child.

I'm not appealing to authority, I'm establishing that you are not one in any sense.

No you're not I already established that.

Then why are you pretending to know better than their doctors?

Because I don't stand to make hundreds of thousands of dollars manipulating children.

Say you, who admits they dont know what theyre talking about. Why are you making these claims when you dont know what you are talking about?

No I know what I'm talking about.

It really is amusing watching the hubris from uneducated people who don't realize how silly they look admitting they have no education in a particular area while telling the people who do that they have it all wrong.

Here you're just calling me stupid because I don't share your ideology.

I don't have to make assumptions. You yourself told me of your ignorance and yet you're also still trying to pretend you know what you're talking about. That's some funny shit.

No I established that I'm not a doctor and I don't have to be. That's the only people that can have opinions about this or doctors what the hell are you doing here talking to me?

And don't tell me you're trying to establish something that I've already established before you had the chance.

I'm here stating there's no such thing as trans kids it is projected on to them. Just like how a father can get his son to pretend to like football.