• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Meet the Town That's Being Swallowed by a Sinkhole

Unitedwestand13

DP Veteran
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
20,738
Reaction score
6,290
Location
Sunnyvale California
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Liberal
This is big news.

Meet the Town That's Being Swallowed by a Sinkhole | Mother Jones


If there were ever a reason to oppose fracking, this story provides a good reason.
 
I can't wait till they bring Fracking to Monterey Bay and the eco wack jobs not ape nuts over it.
 
i missed how this sink hole is related to fracking
would you please explain that correlation

It's related to modern mining methods where the concern is geological system damage of which fracking is one of those modern mining methods.
 
It's related to modern mining methods where the concern is geological system damage of which fracking is one of those modern mining methods.

My dad is a engineering geologist so these kind of story's relate to his line of work.

If anything should raise alarm bells over the damage caused by improper mining techniques, it has to be these sinkholes.
 
It's related to modern mining methods where the concern is geological system damage of which fracking is one of those modern mining methods.

and has fracking been found to be responsible for such ecological problems? if so, please point them out
 
If you ask me, Louisiana needs some people in political and public service management who can look beyond their noses at development and ensure that good practice is followed and bad practice isn't allowed.

You need only look at the destruction over a few decades of the Louisiana wetlands through development that led to the Katrina hurricane disaster and the breach of the levies to know these people couldn't manage a fruit stand let alone a city or state.
 
and has fracking been found to be responsible for such ecological problems? if so, please point them out

Right from the OP:
Recently, the drilling process known as fracking has been linked to an increased risk of earthquakes.

If you're not familiar with this, google it and educate yourself. Where it comes to fracking, the possible links with earthquakes are as troubling as the chemical pollution of the land and the water.
 
My dad is a engineering geologist so these kind of story's relate to his line of work.

If anything should raise alarm bells over the damage caused by improper mining techniques, it has to be these sinkholes.

Well, it's pretty convenient to blame sinkholes on mining, particularly in this case - however, how do you explain all the sinkholes in Florida recently?
 
Well, it's pretty convenient to blame sinkholes on mining, particularly in this case - however, how do you explain all the sinkholes in Florida recently?

Some have other causes, however, we know for certain the cause of this one and others like it.
 
The moral to the story is don't live atop a sinkhole...anywhere. And if you do and some nice corporation wants to buy you out....take it.

Remember the guy in Florida that was eaten by a sinkhole? They never found his body and it wasn't caused by fracking.
 
Yeah whose bright idea was to drill for oil on top of a salt cavern

I'm sure it seemed good at the time, and for years it was a win. But there's one thing we know with ceratinty - given time, ALL wells fail. For some reason folks forget this when faced with immediate benefit.
 
Right from the OP:
tell us how this link to earthquakes has been established and what the detrimental effects have been


If you're not familiar with this, google it and educate yourself. Where it comes to fracking, the possible links with earthquakes are as troubling as the chemical pollution of the land and the water.
i have already done so, which is why i ask my questions
i am not suggesting that more monitoring should not be provided by the government to assure the fracking does not have negative consequences on landowners off of the fracking site, but please share with us the data which proves fracking to be a harmful process
 
Well, it's pretty convenient to blame sinkholes on mining, particularly in this case - however, how do you explain all the sinkholes in Florida recently?

Florida's sinkholes are a result of the weathering or dissolution of limestone or dolomite. Florida is basically sand on top of a lot of limestone.
 
Florida's sinkholes are a result of the weathering or dissolution of limestone or dolomite. Florida is basically sand on top of a lot of limestone.

It's why I mentioned it so that the assumption isn't that mining is the cause of sinkholes in general.
 
It's why I mentioned it so that the assumption isn't that mining is the cause of sinkholes in general.

Yes...definitely true, not every sinkhole is due to mining. This one definitely is though. The company drilled too close close to the edge of a salt dome which caused a sidewall of the dome to collapse.
 
Yes...definitely true, not every sinkhole is due to mining. This one definitely is though. The company drilled too close close to the edge of a salt dome which caused a sidewall of the dome to collapse.

Which goes back to my point about lax oversight on the part of the State of Louisiana and the people charged with approving and managing such things. It could simply be an unavoidable accident but likely it was simple negligence with horrible consequences for innocent people.
 

No I agree...to be honest I wouldn't want fracking anywhere around me even if that's irrational. There's just a tendency for un-planned for side effects in almost anything. At the same time...yeah...facking as of now is supposedly safe by a lot of different reports. Mining is safe as well.

Of course like you mention...lax regulations with -fracking or mining equals disaster.
 
Well, it's pretty convenient to blame sinkholes on mining, particularly in this case - however, how do you explain all the sinkholes in Florida recently?

Those are largely believed to be the result of the erosion of the soft rock underground over thousands, if not millions of years.
 

If you truly had already done so all your questions would have been answered. So do so, really this time and stop wasting my time. OR you can just look at the threads you participated in and see that all that info has been sourced and posted already. Do your own homework.
 

ALL mines eventually fail. That should be planned for going into each and every project as well as increased regulation and montioring.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…