• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Judge orders Indiana DoC to give a baby killer his taxpayer-funded gender surgery

Curious, coming from you, I have to say.
I can see why you’re confused. You don’t know what the term means. Me pointing out you refuse to answer a direct yes or no question, is not sea lioning.
 
But we both know that you know it’s impossible for a man to become a woman.
I don't know that. I don't even know what you mean by that or what you think we mean when we say they can because you're being so fragile about the whole thing. 😆
Of course you do.

Not pretending. You know it’s impossible.

Biology shows it’s impossible for a man to become a woman. You know that.

I didn’t call you a name. I said you were lying.
Calling someone a liar is calling them a name. Don't be so fragile about basic shit. 😆
I’ve not made an argument. I’ve pointed out that it’s biologically impossible for a man to become a woman, and that you know that.
That just makes it an argument you lack so much confidence in that you can't even acknowledge it as such. 😆
 
I don't know that.
Of course you do.
I don't even know what you mean by that or what you think we mean when we say they can because you're being so fragile about the whole thing. 😆
You know it’s biologically impossible for a man to become a woman.
Calling someone a liar is calling them a name. Don't be so fragile about basic shit. 😆
I didn’t call you a liar. I said you were lying.
That just makes it an argument you lack so much confidence in that you can't even acknowledge it as such. 😆
I have not made any arguments. It’s a biological fact a man can’t become a woman. The same way hits a biological fact a man can’t become a dolphin. And you know that.
 
Of course you do.

You know it’s biologically impossible for a man to become a woman.

I didn’t call you a liar. I said you were lying.

I have not made any arguments. It’s a biological fact a man can’t become a woman. The same way hits a biological fact a man can’t become a dolphin. And you know that.
I don't know that. I'm not using man or woman as biological terms. Accept that and stop being so fragile about it. 😆
 
Of course you do.
This is a really weird but hilarious hill for you to die on, insisting you know what everyone knows. 😆
That’s what they are.

Pointing out you know a man can’t become a woman isn’t me being fragile. It’s me pointing out what you already know.
But I don't know that. We can have a open disagreement about it if you weren't so intimidated at the prospect.
 
Time to file an appeal to the next level of Court.

Under what law does a person have not only a right to sexual reassignment surgery, but that the State using taxpayer money has to both arrange for and pay for such surgery?

IMO the ACLU (an organization I once upon a time fully supported) is now full of crap.

I bet if it gets to SCOTUS (which it may if the ruling is not smacked down by the Appellate Division) it is likely to be overturned.
having a right or desire doesn't not imply that the government is required to grant or fund it.
 
This is a really weird but hilarious hill for you to die on, insisting you know what everyone knows. 😆
I don’t know why you want to pretend you don’t know a man can’t become a woman. When we both know that you know a man can’t become a woman.
But I don't know that.
Of course you do.
We can have an open disagreement about it if you weren't so intimidated at the prospect.
There’s nothing to disagree on. It’s objectively, biologically impossible for a man to become a woman. The same way it’s impossible for a man to become a cocker spaniel. And you know that.
 
I don’t know why you want to pretend you don’t know a man can’t become a woman. When we both know that you know a man can’t become a woman.
I'm not pretending. I can in fact make that argument because it has nothing to do with biology.
Of course you do.

There’s nothing to disagree on.
Says your fragile psyche.... 😆
It’s objectively, biologically impossible for a man to become a woman. The same way it’s impossible for a man to become a cocker spaniel. And you know that.
Depends on what you mean by man, woman or cocker spaniel and whether you're referring to immutable biological characteristics or mutable social expressions. Care to tell us which you're referring to if you aren't to shy or scared?
 
Ideologically captured organizations don't really matter that much.

I guess it may be a cesspool of stupid in your ideology but I don't ascribe to it.

How much of this was influenced by WPATH
The conspiracy theory forum is over there.----------------->
 
I'm not pretending.
Of course you are.
I can in fact make that argument because it has nothing to do with biology.
It’s explicitly about biology.
Says your fragile psyche.... 😆
You’re confused again. Me pointing out basic biological reality isn’t me being fragile.
Depends on what you mean by man, woman or cocker spaniel and whether you're referring to immutable biological characteristics or mutable social expressions.
You know exactly what each of those mean. Man=adult male. Woman=adult female. Cocker spaniel= a canine
Care to tell us which you're referring to if you aren't to shy or scared?
Scared? 😂
 
Forcing a person to be who they are when they were born and who they grow into is not cruel and unusual punishment

Being transgender is not a choice. She was born transgender because of the effect of the mother hormones on the developing fetal brain. She was not and would never be cisgender. Your idea is a spin on conversion therapy. maybe someone should do it to you if you think its such a good idea to do it to others.
Nobody's convicting him to death. If you commit suicide that's his choice.
Ignoring mental health and allowing someone to commit suicide is a violation of the 8th amendment. You should ask your supposed minister to explain empathy to you. Maybe he will quote Matt 25:40 and 7:12 to you.
 
Of course you are.

It’s explicitly about biology.
For you maybe. What is it about you that you feel the need to pretend so for others?
You’re confused again. Me pointing out basic biological reality isn’t me being fragile.
Me pointing out that the rest of as aren't talking about immutable biological characteristics and you being unable to accept that, is. Clearly. 😆
You know exactly what each of those mean. Man=adult male. Woman=adult female. Cocker spaniel= a canine
Nope.
Yep.
 
I can see why you’re confused. You don’t know what the term means. Me pointing out you refuse to answer a direct yes or no question, is not sea lioning.
Sorry, but, its the exact same thing.

Sealioning (also sea-lioning and sea lioning) is a type of trolling or harassment that consists of pursuing people with relentless requests for evidence, often tangential or previously addressed, while maintaining a pretense of civility and sincerity ("I'm just trying to have a debate"), and feigning ignorance of the subject matter.[5][6][7][8] It may take the form of "incessant, bad-faith invitations to engage in debate",[9] and has been likened to a denial-of-service attack targeted at human beings.[10] The term originated with a 2014 strip of the webcomic Wondermark by David Malki,[1] which The Independent called "the most apt description of Twitter you'll ever see".[2]

"incessant, bad-faith invitations to engage in debate" specifically.

But do please continue with your exchanges with the other poster. In this case, there's some common ground there that you and I share.
 
Being transgender is not a choice.
I can agree with that with the based on this caveat that they're actually transgender and not just doing it as part of a trend.
She was born transgender because of the effect of the mother hormones on the developing fetal brain.
Do that I've seen no evidence to suggest this. It seems largely based on neurosexism
She was not and would never be cisgender. Your idea is a spin on conversion therapy. maybe someone should do it to you if you think its such a good idea to do it to others.
See above
Ignoring mental health and allowing someone to commit suicide is a violation of the 8th amendment.
Allowing someone to commit suicide?
You should ask your supposed minister to explain empathy to you. Maybe he will quote Matt 25:40 and 7:12 to you.
I have empathy for the women in the women's prison that shouldn't be exposed to a violent male regardless of mental disability.
 
The conspiracy theory forum is over there.----------------->
Refuse I'm not the one pretending that a violent male needs to be put in a women's prison after been given maybe sort of kind of some sex reassignment surgery or not.
 
Refuse I'm not the one pretending that a violent male needs to be put in a women's prison after been given maybe sort of kind of some sex reassignment surgery or not.
Do you speak a form of English that doesn't need to be translated when others read it?

Neither the courts nor the state of Indiana are asking for your uneducated opinion on this matter of constitutional law.
 
Do you speak a form of English that doesn't need to be translated when others read it?
No I just make errors. As you do. And since you're wrong you like to attack me for my errors instead of argue in good faith.
Neither the courts nor the state of Indiana are asking for your uneducated opinion on this matter of constitutional law.
Wasn't offering it to them.
 
For you maybe.
For every living thing.
What is it about you that you feel the need to pretend so for others?
Pretend? I don’t understand. You know a man can’t become a woman.
Me pointing out that the rest of as aren't talking about immutable biological characteristics and you being unable to accept that, is. Clearly. 😆
There is nothing else to talk about.
Yep
Nope
 
For every living thing.

Pretend? I don’t understand. You know a man can’t become a woman.

There is nothing else to talk about.

Yep

Nope
If I'm not using man or woman to describe immutable biological characteristics, why exactly not? Are you under some frail impression that we must all adopt your terminology?
 
That’s what they mean, which you know.

It isn’t my terminology.
Words mean whatever we want them to mean. Are you confused about what words are? That's funny. How frail are you going to make yourself seem for the purposes of this argument?
 
Not sort of, they do. We are the ones who come up with them.
You seem to be confused since you're havung a really difficult time wrapping your head around the really simple idea of other people using man and woman to describe things like mutable social expressions and identities rather than biological markers.
I’ve not made an argument. I’ve pointed out that you know a man can’t become a woman, because it’s biologically impossible.
If you're not making an argument when you're telling me what I know are you doing? Fantasizing? What LARPing genre is this?
 
Back
Top Bottom