• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

"I, Racist" & some gaps in the thinking

Holy crap, dude, how are YOU thinking, except of ways to turn your eyes from the suffering of your fellow man? What am I repeating, except my own demand for a tiny bit of recognition from weak, wounded white deniers of history? If you can't admit that black people had their own holocaust, and it was white America that did it, then the monster gene has raised its ugly head for yet another generation.

No wonder all the various forms of anti-intellectualism have huddled together under the conservative tent. It is the last safe haven for those who not only advocate a revisionist history but a revisionist reality. God (if there is one) help you all for your tenacious inhumanity.



I didn't say that black people have no responsibility, so quit paraphrasing the words of your superiors unless you intend to comprehend what they say in the first place. I'm saying that black pride takes on a different meaning, given the context of history. But no, go ahead and interpret my rational words in whatever way makes it easier to believe that they've had a fair shot and that what they've struggled against wouldn't make any group of people into an underclass for generations to come. By all means, climb aboard the conservative denial train and make yourself feel better. Stroke yourself incessantly and repeat the words, "that was then, this is now". Pretend, even as you pridefully exclaim your own heritage that theirs doesn't matter.




Are you an idiot? Are you able to comprehend that what you describe is EXACTLY what happened to black people. They were "saddled" with guilt and shame at being black and were saddled with a sense of diminished expectations...for hundreds of years. How do you develop a positive sense of your self under those conditions? How do parents with no positive sense of self bequeath that to their children?

Look, I'm really tired of having to explain simple concepts to an unwilling audience of ignoramuses, so here's my last attempt for you. They didn't do those things to themselves, do you understand? There has been a long-term policy and culture among the white establishment that black people would not prosper intellectually, financially or socially. Do you deny that? If you do, you are guilty of the equivalent of masturbation of conscience. It may feel good to you but it won't breed any change in the racial divide. To the future of civility your self serving justifications for apathy are useless.

What facts of history are you looking at that allows you to gloss over the historical foundation of contemporary black culture? If we, as white people, are a product of our ancestors, and all they did and didn't do, then so are they. Their ancestors were cattle, though, in this country and you don't have the balls to admit it. If you did, you might have to muster a milligram of human compassion rather than adopt the default, conservative attitude of "I don't give a **** about anyone but myself".

Don't feel guilty- god knows you're not strong enough to handle it- but DO feel something. Understand that this situation was created, it's not the natural condition of black people to be victims and the end of slavery did not mean an end to oppression. Shame on you all for blaming black America for where they find themselves in this society. The self preservation instinct is an insidious component of any people who feel entitled to either exploit or neglect others. Too many survived the civil war, I guess. We'll have to do better next time.

No, I am not an idiot. I was accepted to Stanford in 1972.

How about you? Are you somehow under the impression that all your hyperbolic rhetoric that is so over the top as to approach satire is some sort of indication of a functioning intellect at work?
 
I think one of the main problems is that people think "white society" should do something.

And one of the main problems is that there's a lot of people out there who don't realize that it doesn't matter whether race relations should or should not be an issue...because it IS and issue, and if human history is any indication, it always will be.
 
Who has said there is no racism?

Just because your own views are so extremely simplistic and based upon nothing but a conditioned response, that doesn't mean anybody who does not march in politically correct lock step is equally simplistic.

'simplistic' and 'conditioned'? You know, that might hold water if I hadn't been raised racist in a racist family, for it is within one's family that such conditioning is strongest (Google Rogers and Hammerstein's "You've Got to be Carefully Taught"). But my views came from discovering how very wrong my family and my community were, and doing so even while spending a career in the generally-conservative military - and so my views are not the result of conditioning, not by any stretch of the word.
 
Sure, Santorum wasn't shunned and wound up finishing second... without a job. Meanwhile people like Harry Reid and Joe Biden slip up just as bad and reveal their true colors and not only do they get the same free pass, they wind up as Senate majority leader and Vice President.:roll:

Really? Biden and Reid slipped up "just as bad" as Santorum's "blah people" gaffe? False equivalency, anyone?
 
And one of the main problems is that there's a lot of people out there who don't realize that it doesn't matter whether race relations should or should not be an issue...because it IS and issue, and if human history is any indication, it always will be.

There is a certain amount of research in a number of disciplines that seems to bear that out.
 
I've seen this article in various places recently, and it's very thought provoking. He makes many great points. But, after reading it and pondering it, two things scream out to me that I think are worthy of discussion.

Read the article first, then read my response, and contribute if you desire.


#1) Us vs them...

Maybe that's part of the problem. Black people are too wrapped up in the collective victimhood (which ties into point #2, later) and fail to see themselves beyond that. One can possibly say it's rooted in the past, and I'm sure there's truth to that, but this is just it, the past is gone. It's not changing and it's not coming back.

Thinking individually is not "privilege", it's a mindset choice. As I think about it, people who place themselves and their own individual well-being at some level of primary importance tend to do better than those who don't.

And let's not gloss over the fact that the author does exactly what he criticizes others for doing. By criticizing whites for being "you are you", IOW 'you are not part of us', he has negatively categorized whites as "them". I guess it's all a matter of perspective, which weakens his overall point.

Which, as I said, ties into...

#2) What are you going to do about it?
Legitimately. Constructively. A common theme in these discussions is that they all come off as a one-way street. It's always some variation of "blame whitey". What is pretty much universally lacking from these discussions is what black people are going to do about it. And I mean in a constructive legitimate sense.

Am I saying that whites and/or others are blameless? Phfft, no, not by a long shot. There's a great deal that white society can and should do to make things better. But, whether individually and/or collectively, there has to be something that black people feel they can contribute to their own legitimate positive advancement, as well. Problem is, I'm not hearing that from anywhere in the black community. Not by my black friends or from my white-liberal-guilt-progressive friends, either. I'm not really interested in what white people think on this aspect, I want to hear black people promote some ideas that will cause black people to prosper.

Will someone send him to Africa or Central America so he can live among "diversity".
 
Back
Top Bottom