• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

I had a dream


What, exactly, do you suggest as solutions?


It is (or should be) obvious that simply rewarding failure is not working out well. The all carrot approach did not work any better than the all stick approach, in fact, maybe it made things worse.
 

ah..someone from turkey who is an expert on race relations in a country he's never even been in..great.. :roll:
 
ah..someone from turkey who is an expert on race relations in a country he's never even been in..great.. :roll:

your liberals say something different from what l say ?

no

so lets forget my location
 
I believe those are called false equivalencies. (Great society is responsible for children out of wedlock etc.)

So programs that 'reward' behavior that is not conducive to advancing in society is a 'false equivalency', but it's ok to say that 'whites' are responsible for all those problems? Interesting.
 
your liberals say something different from what l say ?

no

so lets forget my location

It kind of helps to actually know what you're talking about. Rather than parroting what "liberals" say thousands of miles away.

Here..handle your own business before you lecture us.

In Turkey racism and ethnic discrimination are prevalent in its society and throughout its history, and this racism and ethnic discrimination is also institutional against the non-Muslim and non-Sunni minorities.[1][2][3][4][5][6][7] This appears mainly in the form of negative attitudes and actions by Turks towards people who are not considered ethnically Turkish. Such discrimination is predominately towards non-Muslim minorities such as Greeks, Armenians, Assyrians, and others, as well as hostility towards various deviations of Islam such as Alevis, Sufis, and other Muslim non-Turks such as Kurds.

Racism and discrimination in modern Turkey can be traced back to the Ottoman Empire. Such Ottoman Turkish intellectuals such as Ali Suavi have stated in the 1860s that:[8]

Turks are superior to other races in political, military and cultural aspects
The Turkish language surpasses the European languages in its richness and excellence
Turks constructed the Islamic civilization.

With the establishment of the Republic of Turkey, non-Muslim citizens of the country have been subject to numerous instances of state-sponsored discrimination. For instance, many non-Muslims were fired from their jobs and were denied employment by the bureaucracy.[9][10] The State Employee Law enacted in 1926 aimed at the Turkification of work life in Turkey.[11][10] This law defined Turkishness as a necessary condition to become a state employee.
 

That is simply not so. If things (e.g. crime rate and out of wedlock childbrith rate) got worse after a program was implemented that certainly does not indicate that the program was a success. If you reward/subsidize something then you tend to get more of it - that is not some bizarre theory that must be proven. Poverty is a cycle, thus if the program does not break the cycle (the next generation needs it less than the first) then it did not succeed.

We all seem to agree that neither all carrot nor all stick programs will work, yet some seem to want add carrots and the others want to add sticks (to the current mess that all see as not working). It seems to me that by letting all 50 states (and giving DC to MD) start from ZERO (removing all federal income redistributon programs) is the best way to see a good mix of new carrot/stick programs created and tried.
 



l am not parroting anything ,l am pointing out that your argument that l dont know about USA is logically wrong

anyone who isnt too stupid and who is a little interested in world politics may know that the blacks were treated like animals in the past

what was martin lut's dream ?

haha

B]
slavery ended but existed as discrimination

[/B]

whose buses ,schools were isolated from the rest of the society ?

who were banned to marry whites ?

if you trust yourself and can speak turkish ,join a turkish site and dicsuss our problems with me in my language

but this topic is about USA ,not turkey

,sorry l wont apologize to anyone for having knowledge about USA and dicussing any issue about it in english
 
Last edited:
I know what I know. If I choose to keep it to myself, for the sake of political correctness, don't think for a second I'm not aware of the real deal.

It is what it is. And it is on display for the world to see, everyday. The girls with the kaleidoscope eyes can choose to sugar coat or rationalize it or scapegoat it or spin it any way that makes them comfortable. But it doesn't change anything.

It is what it is and I'm not one to let folks pee in my hair and tell me it's raining.

That's all.
 
What, exactly, do you suggest as solutions?
It is (or should be) obvious that simply rewarding failure is not working out well. The all carrot approach did not work any better than the all stick approach, in fact, maybe it made things worse.

I agree. Although, I don't claim to have answers just lots of opinions which I am happy to share.

I think that because white america still has the majority of the power we have a role in repairing these communities, even if you look at it purely pragmatically...it is in our best interest. To begin with we need to address inequities in the quality of education, employment, housing, healthcare and the judicial system. Not just for black communities but for all poor communities. Put a stop to the War on Drugs, waste of time, money and resources. I said earlier that I think the foundation of all social programs should be something similar to the "give a man a fish you feed him for day....." philosophy because if you do not truly empower people to change their own lives you are being self serving. You get to feel like the good guy and they stay stuck where they are. Tip of the proverbial iceberg here but you get my drift.

The black communities need leaders from within that will reach into their communities and redirect kids to more constructive choices. There needs to be real accountability for services and assistance, perhaps volunteer service within your community for assistance. Trade school options etc. (again for all poor communities) I believe this would be a generational effort.
 
So programs that 'reward' behavior that is not conducive to advancing in society is a 'false equivalency', but it's ok to say that 'whites' are responsible for all those problems? Interesting.

There you go again
 

Slavery?

You don't like slavery? Get rid of it in your own country first.

Turkey's sex trade entraps Slavic women

Craig S. Smith, The New York Times, Trabzon, Turkey, 28 June 2005

www.nytimes.com/2005/06/27/world/europe/27iht-turkey.html?_r=2

[accessed 12 September 2011]

The women arrive here by ferry from across the Black Sea, sometimes dozens at a time. Whatever their real names, they are known in Turkey as Natashas, and often end up working as prostitutes in this country's growing sex trade.

Most come of their own free will, but many end up as virtual slaves, sold from pimp to pimp through a loosely organized criminal network that stretches from Moscow to Istanbul and beyond.


.then go to africa and make them stop...they still practice it there, you know...We abolished it 150 years ago here in case you hadn't heard.....


if you trust yourself and can speka turkish ,join a turkish site and dicsuss our problems with me in my language
Sorry. I don't. I do speak Italian pretty fluently and can read it pretty well, and a little french..but no turkish.



sorry l wont apologize to anyone for having knowledge about USA and dicussing any issue about it in english

No one is asking for apologies...and I'll add your english is excellent.
 
Define poor.

Okay....

My dad was the sole breadwinner for our family. Back in the 80s and 90s when we were growing up, he made roughly $20,000 - $23,000 a year. He had 5 people to feed, clothe and protect. I cannot ever remember going out to a "sit down" (as we called it - with waiters/waitresses) restaurant. Ever. The first vacation we ever took was when I was in high school...... and we barely did anything because my dad had scrimped and saved what little he could to take us on our first family vacation. I can only remember one time getting brand new clothes - a dress for Easter. Everything was a hand-me-down from my sister or from the Salvation Army. I was the kid who never had the "cool" stuff at school. I never asked to be in dance or sports because I knew we didn't have the money. I was totally mortified by the car my dad drove because it was very old and very ugly. Our usual Christmas presents were socks, underwear and one or two "luxury" gifts (which weren't really luxury at all). I remember being so excited when I got the Girl Talk game. My friends at school, however, were getting Nintendos, Gameboys, CD players, clothes from the mall, jewelry, etc.

I know what poor is because I've experienced it. I've lived with my parents' anxiety of not knowing if they have enough money for the week. I've lived with the longing to want more, but knowing it wasn't possible at that time.

So.... I did well in school. Not because I had this grand idea that I would be successful and have money someday. I wanted to do well. My parents expected me to do well. I never got into drugs or the party scene at all. I got good grades, was in National Honor Society, got into a great private college and graduated with Bachelor's and Master's degrees (magna cum laude). Because of my specialty area (reading specialist), I make pretty darn good money for only teaching about 10 years.

Actually, when you look at it this way --- 5 people survived on $23,000....

I make more than twice that amount now and I only have me to feed, clothe and protect. I now can buy pretty much anything I want........ and I also give back to the parents who raised me to be the successful woman I am today.

How's that?
 
Last edited:
That is simply not so. .

If things (e.g. crime rate and out of wedlock childbrith rate) got worse after a program was implemented that certainly does not indicate that the program was a success.

Granted but it does not indicated that the program is responsible either.


Not necessarily, you have to consider other factors that could have kept it from being successful.

We all seem to agree that neither all carrot nor all stick programs will work, yet some seem to want add carrots and the others want to add sticks (to the current mess that all see as not working).

Excellent point. This is pretty much what I have been advocating.

It seems to me that by letting all 50 states (and giving DC to MD) start from ZERO (removing all federal income redistributon programs) is the best way to see a good mix of new carrot/stick programs created and tried.

Although you can not make the change to abrupt or the backlash would prove counterproductive.
 



i used to hate tomatoes, once..i was very hungry, and the only thing we had in our pantry was a can of stewed tomatoes i ate them and loved every bite, today i love tomatoes, and get double on my burger.

being hungry makes you appreciate things more.....
 

Many efforts along these lines, e.g. charter school/vouchers, enterpirse zones and "workfare" programs have been suggested. The basic problem is the federalization - i.e. one size fits all simply does not work. Just as many states/cities have established different minimum wage laws they should be free to try different educational and social services programs; but with one huge caveat - they must be funded from their within heir own tax base. The basic problem with all income redistribution programs is that they tend to take money from group A, be run by group B to try to help group C. The lower the level of gov't then the closer the funders, implementors and end users (the ABCs) are to each other. Taking money from NYC and giving it to some tiny town in Texas but having control remain in DC makes absolutely no sense at all.

The basis for all such programs should be to encourage real education (including job training), reduce crime (including child/mother abandonment) and to encourage two parent households. None of these programs should have any federal involvement (funding or control via mandates).
 

We had lots and lots and lots of potatoes. I bet I've peeled a zillion potatoes in my life.

Now I love those little mini potatoes --- drizzle some olive oil on them, chop up rosemary, bake them for 30 minutes or so. Mmmmmmm....
 

Thank you.

I do not mean to disrespect your experience. Really, I don't. We lead our own lives and our struggles are really only relevant to our experience. But I look at it this way, I complain sometimes about my struggle until I see some guy roll by in a wheel chair with no legs and a bag of pee strapped to the back. Perspective, if you will.

Did you ever go to bed hungry. Did you ever have to live on the street. Did your father ever beat your mother or you. Was your father ever so without hope that he turned to alcohol because he could not handle the failure. Did your sisters get pregnant at 15 just to escape. I think you get my point.

Now, we can all say we had it hard. The experiences in the paragraph above are from my life. But I still recognize the advantage of white privilege. Because no one ever denied me the opportunity to change my life. No one ever added the extra burden prejudice for me to carry. I did nothing to deserve it I just got it handed to me and it helped me tremendously.
 



Exactly. I often think the biggest problem is the execution. Oversight is ****ty.
 

"The race merchants" -- rightwing speak for people who refuse to allow conservatives to pretend racism doesn't matter.
 

We should put all the CEOs in the US in an arena and feed them for a week. Good idea. Make good TV too.
 
l appreciate your struggle and determination to earn your life josie ,and your father too.

life is not always easy for many in many aspects

but many people have to suffer worse things during their lifetimes
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…