- Joined
- Sep 10, 2010
- Messages
- 38,198
- Reaction score
- 15,841
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Other
Ok. So we agree on the basics.I'm hesitant to call it instinct. The world that humans evolved in is radically different than the one we started living in about 8,000-11,000 years ago. We evolved to be at least as much cooperative as competitive. Like any organism, bands of humans would fight and compete with each other if there was real scarcity, but we dealt with this conflict in ways that were generally peaceful. We typically just moved on to the next fresh water source, the next meadow, forest, whatever.
Once we started storing grains and farming, our world changed forever. Our populations grew. We lived in much larger groups that needed specialization and special skills and knowledge in order to sustain the growing complexity to make it all work. This created inequality. It also created not just real scarcity, but perceived scarcity. When humans began living in larger, more complex, and less egalitarian society, we began to notice inequality. And ordinary folk regularly fought against their masters whenever the came to this realization. And chiefs, leaders, etc came to a counter-realization: they needed to suppress and dominate people if they were to maintain their status at apex of a complex civilization.
The instinct, or drive I describe began as “first at the fire”. Human beings sort into leaders and followers. But it was more fluid and not the rigid hierarchical systems we watablished after we settled down.
Being good enough to sit closest to the fire meant better food, better mates, better “jobs”. So it was desirable and encouraged bettering oneself. Pro survival. For the individual and the group.
We didn’t evolve with greed. One can only carry so much stuff. No one’s gonna carry your stuff. Food spoiled pretty quickly.
But that desire to be respected and enjoy a better “place”, which made us make ourselves better in the hunter gatherer environment got warped into the early model of what we have today: a world that exists to feed that hunger.
Because it’s a neurochemical addiction like some have for sex or risky sports or gambling.
And Tolerance develops. Which means they cannot ever get enough but won’t stop until no one has more status.
It’s a pickle.