• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Hamas Says It Agrees to Release All Hostages in Gaza

Common Sense 1

Common Sense 1

Supporting Member
DP Veteran
Joined
Jul 8, 2016
Messages
21,683
Reaction score
16,844
Location
United States
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Private

This is in response to a proposal from president Trump.​


Live Updates: Hamas Says It Agrees to Release All Hostages in Gaza​

www.nytimes.com

Live Updates: Hamas Says It Agrees to Release All Hostages in Gaza

The militant group responded to a proposal by President Trump to end its nearly two-year war with Israel.
www.nytimes.com www.nytimes.com

The militant group responded to a proposal by President Trump to end the war in Gaza.

1759522230320.webp
 

Trump gives Hamas a 'last chance' deadline to agree to a peace plan with Israel​


President Trump has given Hamas until Sunday evening to respond to the ceasefire deal the White House proposed earlier this week, which Israel has agreed to.

In a post to Truth Social on Friday morning, Trump said he was giving Hamas a "last chance," or Hamas fighters would be "quickly extinguished." The deadline comes just days before the second anniversary of the conflict.

"If this LAST CHANCE agreement is not reached, all HELL, like no one has ever seen before, will break out against Hamas," Trump wrote on Truth Social.

Updated October 3, 2025
 
Trump talks out his ass enough, when you use the same rhetoric each time and don't follow through, becomes amusing tedious people still take him as the problem. And less so the people that react to his every dog whistle to make something work. Hats off to any American official on the ground level getting any of this in the works.

It won't be enough though. This could be the hostage takers last surrender in general. Once they don't have the collateral that if Trump were to extinguish in the process he claims is the answer here that would hurt him and BB politically for a few days if done, they dont have anything to negotiate. Hamas probably don't see the people wanting to extinguish them as being trustworthy to talk to but let's see if they can pull off the guilty eyes.

Hamas is a cancer fighting a virus here.
 

Hamas agrees to release all Israeli hostages outlined in Trump Gaza peace deal: report​

Hamas says it will release hostages as part of Gaza proposal​

www.foxnews.com

Hamas agrees to release all Israeli hostages outlined in Trump Gaza peace deal: report

President Donald Trump's Gaza proposal prompts Hamas to agree to hostage release following his warning that leaders face death if hostages aren't freed by Sunday.
www.foxnews.com www.foxnews.com


another source for the story
 
redbeer said:
Great, hope it goes to fruition.
Click to expand...

I wonder about the “as field conditions for the exchange are met” and “affirms its readiness to immediately enter into negotiations through the mediators to discuss these details” parts of that response. Hamas is quick to pretend to agree with whatever is presented to them, but then changes their terms for doing so.
 

Who Are the Hostages Still Held By Hamas?​

www.ajc.org

Who Are the Hostages Still Held By Hamas?

More than 22 months after Hamas' massacre of Israelis, Palestinian terror groups are still holding 48 men and women—including two Americans—captive in Gaza. Here is a list of how many hostages Hamas has.
www.ajc.org www.ajc.org

September 2, 2025


More than 22 months after Hamas' massacre of Israelis on October 7, 2023, Palestinian terror groups are still holding 48 men and women—including two Americans—captive in Gaza.

Here are the names of the 48 hostages, what released hostages endured in captivity, how you can take action to help secure the hostages’ release, and how American Jewish Committee (AJC), the global advocacy organization for the Jewish people, is working nonstop to bring them home.

Who are the hostages held by Hamas and other Palestinian terror groups?

Ariel Cunio (27)
Alon Ohel (23)
Eitan Horn (38)
Avinatan Or (31)
Elkana Bohbot (35)
Evyatar David (24)
Bipin Joshi (24)
Ziv Berman (27)
Gali Berman (27)
David Cunio (34)
Eitan Mor (24)
Maxim Herkin (36)
Omri Miran (47)
Bar Abraham Kupershtein (23)
Guy Gilboa-Dalal (23)
Nimrod Cohen (20)
Matan Zangauker (25)
Tamir Nimrodi (20)
Matan Angrest (22)
Segev Kalfon (27)
Rom Braslavski (21)
Yosef-Haim Ohana (24)
Itay Chen (19) - U.S. Citizen
Eliyahu Margalit (75)
Eitan Levi (52)
Sahar Baruch (24)
Joshua Luito Mollel (21)
Tal Haimi (41)
Arie Zalmanowicz (85)
Ran Gvili (24)
Dror Or (48)
Tamir Adar (38)
Ronen Engel (54)
Inbar Hayman (27)
Guy Iluz (26)
Asaf Hamami (41)
Lior Rudaeff (61)
Muhammad Al-Atarash (39)
Meny Godard (73)
Omer Neutra (21) - U.S. Citizen
Yossi Sharabi (53)
Daniel Oz (19)
Daniel Perez (22)
Uriel Baruch (35)
Sontia Ok’Krasari (30)
Sontisek Rintalk (43)
Amiram Cooper (85)
Hadar Goldin (23)
 
ttwtt78640 said:
I wonder about the “as field conditions for the exchange are met” and “affirms its readiness to immediately enter into negotiations through the mediators to discuss these details” parts of that response. Hamas is quick to pretend to agree with whatever is presented to them, but then changes their terms for doing so.
Click to expand...

Yes, that is possible. Guess we'll find out Sunday night into Monday morning. Can't trust a word from Hamas, they are just liars, murderers, and terrorists hiding amongst the Palestinians. Never can understand why the Palestinians just don't fight against Hamas to rid themselves of all the problems, destruction, and death. I haven't forgotten them dancing in the streets on the night of Oct. 7th.
 
Common Sense 1 said:

Who Are the Hostages Still Held By Hamas?​

www.ajc.org

Who Are the Hostages Still Held By Hamas?

More than 22 months after Hamas' massacre of Israelis, Palestinian terror groups are still holding 48 men and women—including two Americans—captive in Gaza. Here is a list of how many hostages Hamas has.
www.ajc.org www.ajc.org

September 2, 2025


More than 22 months after Hamas' massacre of Israelis on October 7, 2023, Palestinian terror groups are still holding 48 men and women—including two Americans—captive in Gaza.

Here are the names of the 48 hostages, what released hostages endured in captivity, how you can take action to help secure the hostages’ release, and how American Jewish Committee (AJC), the global advocacy organization for the Jewish people, is working nonstop to bring them home.

Who are the hostages held by Hamas and other Palestinian terror groups?

Ariel Cunio (27)
Alon Ohel (23)
Eitan Horn (38)
Avinatan Or (31)
Elkana Bohbot (35)
Evyatar David (24)
Bipin Joshi (24)
Ziv Berman (27)
Gali Berman (27)
David Cunio (34)
Eitan Mor (24)
Maxim Herkin (36)
Omri Miran (47)
Bar Abraham Kupershtein (23)
Guy Gilboa-Dalal (23)
Nimrod Cohen (20)
Matan Zangauker (25)
Tamir Nimrodi (20)
Matan Angrest (22)
Segev Kalfon (27)
Rom Braslavski (21)
Yosef-Haim Ohana (24)
Itay Chen (19) - U.S. Citizen
Eliyahu Margalit (75)
Eitan Levi (52)
Sahar Baruch (24)
Joshua Luito Mollel (21)
Tal Haimi (41)
Arie Zalmanowicz (85)
Ran Gvili (24)
Dror Or (48)
Tamir Adar (38)
Ronen Engel (54)
Inbar Hayman (27)
Guy Iluz (26)
Asaf Hamami (41)
Lior Rudaeff (61)
Muhammad Al-Atarash (39)
Meny Godard (73)
Omer Neutra (21) - U.S. Citizen
Yossi Sharabi (53)
Daniel Oz (19)
Daniel Perez (22)
Uriel Baruch (35)
Sontia Ok’Krasari (30)
Sontisek Rintalk (43)
Amiram Cooper (85)
Hadar Goldin (23)
Click to expand...

I didn't know there were that many.

Hope this happens.
 
redbeer said:
Yes, that is possible. Guess we'll find out Sunday night into Monday morning. Can't trust a word from Hamas, they are just liars, murderers, and terrorists hiding amongst the Palestinians. Never can understand why the Palestinians just don't fight against Hamas to rid themselves of all the problems, destruction, and death. I haven't forgotten them dancing in the streets on the night of Oct. 7th.
Click to expand...
“Fight” with what? Israel can’t defeat Hamas with the most advanced tanks and planes money can buy.

Furthermore, why should Palestinians lift a lift a finger to help those carrying out a genocide against them?
 
Tigerace117 said:
“Fight” with what? Israel can’t defeat Hamas with the most advanced tanks and planes money can buy.

Furthermore, why should Palestinians lift a lift a finger to help those carrying out a genocide against them?
Click to expand...

From the beginning.....give them Hamas and the hostages and its over.....they chose Hamas.
 
Of course the MAGA wants to give Trump exclusive credit (not, you know, the war that has largely leveled Gaza and crippled Hamas) and that before anything concrete actually has happened.

Nothing Trump said changed anything. Bibi was clear: he was going to keep the war on even if it completely isolated Israel unless the hostages were released. All Trump said was "I won't stop him from doing that"
 
Tigerace117 said:
“Fight” with what? Israel can’t defeat Hamas with the most advanced tanks and planes money can buy.

Furthermore, why should Palestinians lift a lift a finger to help those carrying out a genocide against them?
Click to expand...

Maybe because of Oct 7th, they should rid themselves of those savage terrorists if there's any hint to being civilized. They chose Hamas instead.....make a stupid choice get a stupid prize.
 
Mr Person said:
Of course the MAGA wants to give Trump exclusive credit (not, you know, the war that has largely leveled Gaza and crippled Hamas) and that before anything concrete actually has happened.

Nothing Trump said changed anything. Bibi was clear: he was going to keep the war on even if it completely isolated Israel unless the hostages were released. All Trump said was "I won't stop him from doing that"
Click to expand...

Jeez, Trump hasn't done anything?.....are you serious or on a rant of TDS?
 
Common Sense 1 said:

Trump gives Hamas a 'last chance' deadline to agree to a peace plan with Israel​


President Trump has given Hamas until Sunday evening to respond to the ceasefire deal the White House proposed earlier this week, which Israel has agreed to.

In a post to Truth Social on Friday morning, Trump said he was giving Hamas a "last chance," or Hamas fighters would be "quickly extinguished." The deadline comes just days before the second anniversary of the conflict.

"If this LAST CHANCE agreement is not reached, all HELL, like no one has ever seen before, will break out against Hamas," Trump wrote on Truth Social.

Updated October 3, 2025
Click to expand...
He really needs a new vocabulary.
 
So, the hostages released, and then what? Does anyone here with an ounce of sagacity believe Hamas won't take an lull in fighting to regroup, re-arm, and recruit new followers?
THEY play the long game. They won't launch another attack next year or the year after, but they will launch another attack on Israel.

Plus I am not convinced the hostages will be released just because Hamas says so.
 
redbeer said:
Maybe because of Oct 7th, they should rid themselves of those savage terrorists if there's any hint to being civilized. They chose Hamas instead.....make a stupid choice get a stupid prize.
Click to expand...
Easy thing to say for a person without someone's gun to their head in all directions.

How should the Palestinians rid themselves of a network of terrorists organizations that don't much care for them?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom