- Joined
- Jul 17, 2020
- Messages
- 35,240
- Reaction score
- 15,275
- Location
- Springfield MO
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Liberal
I was perhaps a bit sloppy in the title of my previous thread, so it got off-track from what I was expecting. As such, I am trying to start over and clarify here.
“Believers” claim that moral authority comes from God and that since atheists “don’t believe in God”, that somehow allows them to simply do whatever they want without respect to ethics.
So my query then becomes from whence do the ethical values of atheists derive if not from God.
I know the answer, of course. This thread is more to provide an education for the theists in this forum, although atheists, like Democrats, have a notoriously rebellious streak in many case and so there may indeed be some debate about the source of ethics.
I have yet to meet a single atheist that believes they can do whatever they want. Where are you getting this from?
Morals are what makes society work. It is as simple as that. They are as a result of evolution. Humans do what they do out of necessity for their own comfort. Naturally there are the psychos who don’t and that’s why we have jails. There is no need to “insert God here”.I was perhaps a bit sloppy in the title of my previous thread, so it got off-track from what I was expecting. As such, I am trying to start over and clarify here.
“Believers” claim that moral authority comes from God and that since atheists “don’t believe in God”, that somehow allows them to simply do whatever they want without respect to ethics.
So my query then becomes from whence do the ethical values of atheists derive if not from God.
I know the answer, of course. This thread is more to provide an education for the theists in this forum, although atheists, like Democrats, have a notoriously rebellious streak in many case and so there may indeed be some debate about the source of ethics.
So, what stops you from doing so? A conscience, perhaps?
A conscience is what stops me from cheating on my wife. It is anecdotal to running a functional society.
True...there are those who seem to be born with no conscience...most have a repulsion for mistreating/hurting others, though...
You just described human beings.
I was perhaps a bit sloppy in the title of my previous thread, so it got off-track from what I was expecting. As such, I am trying to start over and clarify here.
“Believers” claim that moral authority comes from God and that since atheists “don’t believe in God”, that somehow allows them to simply do whatever they want without respect to ethics.
So my query then becomes from whence do the ethical values of atheists derive if not from God.
I know the answer, of course. This thread is more to provide an education for the theists in this forum, although atheists, like Democrats, have a notoriously rebellious streak in many case and so there may indeed be some debate about the source of ethics.
Humans are like a box of chocolates...
So you're born with this goodness in you and if you're raised in a decent environment, you're good, but then you grow and start thinking and exercising your free will with more understanding of things and if no one teaches you religious values you easily slip the slippery slope to the sins your society calls you to
I was perhaps a bit sloppy in the title of my previous thread, so it got off-track from what I was expecting. As such, I am trying to start over and clarify here.
“Believers” claim that moral authority comes from God and that since atheists “don’t believe in God”, that somehow allows them to simply do whatever they want without respect to ethics.
So my query then becomes from whence do the ethical values of atheists derive if not from God.
I know the answer, of course. This thread is more to provide an education for the theists in this forum, although atheists, like Democrats, have a notoriously rebellious streak in many case and so there may indeed be some debate about the source of ethics.
So you're born with this goodness in you and if you're raised in a decent environment, you're good, but then you grow and start thinking and exercising your free will with more understanding of things and if no one teaches you religious values you easily slip the slippery slope to the sins your society calls you to
K
Take out the term "religious" and you're probably onto something.
So you, too, consider homosexual behaviour, revealing clothing in public, fornication, pornography, usury, gossiping, music and alcohol sinful?
You're not "born with goodness". :roll:
Goodness is learned. It's taught. It's part of the culture/environment you grow up in. (Hopefully)
"Religious values" have nothing to do with any of this.
Stoning a person to death is a "religious value" to some.
FGM is a "religious value" to some.
Killing gay men is a "religious value" to some.
Ingenious experiments carried out at Yale University in the US used these measures to look at babies' minds. Their results suggest that even the youngest humans have a sense of right and wrong, and, furthermore, an instinct to prefer good over evil.
Are we naturally good or bad? - BBC Future
You did not use any of those terms in your original post. In fact, you have turned my statement on its head since many of the activities that you list refer to RELIGIOUS viewpoints which atheists may or may not agree with. I said to remove the term religious, but you are using it as a standard instead.
True...there are those who seem to be born with no conscience...most have a repulsion for mistreating/hurting others, though...
Sometimes, not having a conscience is a matter of upbringing. If someone is given lots of material goods, but is deprived emotionally, they tend to turn into sociopaths.
Sometimes, not having a conscience is a matter of upbringing. If someone is given lots of material goods, but is deprived emotionally, they tend to turn into sociopaths.
And yet others do seem to be born that way, regardless of how good their upbringing had been...
I have yet to meet a single atheist that believes they can do whatever they want. Where are you getting this from?
A conscience is what stops me from cheating on my wife. It is anecdotal to running a functional society.
Some, but many have a very strong environmental factor.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?