• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

FREE SPEECH is NOT something you are owed by citizens.

Guyzilla

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
May 26, 2020
Messages
3,673
Reaction score
1,362
Location
menifee calif.
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Liberal
Somehow, those yelling fire in a closed theater, think they have to be allowed to yell fire, without suffering any harm. IF you call a black person a nword, you cannot expect them to join in on your enjoyment of free speech. You are likely to be issued a harsh response. AND SHOULD, as that is how humans learn not to say or act improperly.

We have seen what becomes of a human without any pushback on their prejudices and insults. Trump has been coddled almost since birth, and allowed to spew his venom. And so, he insults, and cannot stop himself.

The only time FREE SPEECH should even be mentioned, as a right, is with regard to GOVERNMENT control. SAME WITH innocent till proven guilty. The right wing has been conflating these rights, to extend to other citizens, which they chide, for offering any opinions. And so, since the government is not allowed to have opinions on your insults and bearing false witness, opinions on the way things should be, you too, citizen, should keep your mouth shut about things that clearly affect you.

Now, if you have insults you just MUST divulge, there is little that can be done to stop you. But what you suffer as a result of YOUR choice, is on you. Those that act against you may even suffer as well for those actions, but to say I should not suffer any harm for my insults and attacks, is ludicrous. In fact, the right winger thinks the gov that they think should have no teeth, is called upon, to protect them as they issue insults and attacks.

The right wing even wants to strip us all of our right to free speech, and consumer choice. WE are told that market control is the proper control, till we on the left actually use that, and they are horrified.

A society that TRULY embraced the concept of no fault slander, would descend into chaos. The society that actually removed all norms, as the right wing wants, would have blood running in the streets.

So be proud, that you have standards. BE proud, that you hold folks to account for their speech and actions. IT IS YOUR PERFECT RIGHT.
 
If you're on a public sidewalk, you can protest with a sign.

You might have to get a permit, though.
 
Somehow, those yelling fire in a closed theater, think they have to be allowed to yell fire, without suffering any harm. IF you call a black person a nword, you cannot expect them to join in on your enjoyment of free speech. You are likely to be issued a harsh response. AND SHOULD, as that is how humans learn not to say or act improperly.

We have seen what becomes of a human without any pushback on their prejudices and insults. Trump has been coddled almost since birth, and allowed to spew his venom. And so, he insults, and cannot stop himself.

The only time FREE SPEECH should even be mentioned, as a right, is with regard to GOVERNMENT control. SAME WITH innocent till proven guilty. The right wing has been conflating these rights, to extend to other citizens, which they chide, for offering any opinions. And so, since the government is not allowed to have opinions on your insults and bearing false witness, opinions on the way things should be, you too, citizen, should keep your mouth shut about things that clearly affect you.

Now, if you have insults you just MUST divulge, there is little that can be done to stop you. But what you suffer as a result of YOUR choice, is on you. Those that act against you may even suffer as well for those actions, but to say I should not suffer any harm for my insults and attacks, is ludicrous. In fact, the right winger thinks the gov that they think should have no teeth, is called upon, to protect them as they issue insults and attacks.

The right wing even wants to strip us all of our right to free speech, and consumer choice. WE are told that market control is the proper control, till we on the left actually use that, and they are horrified.

A society that TRULY embraced the concept of no fault slander, would descend into chaos. The society that actually removed all norms, as the right wing wants, would have blood running in the streets.

So be proud, that you have standards. BE proud, that you hold folks to account for their speech and actions. IT IS YOUR PERFECT RIGHT.

When a person seeks to silence somebody else through a boycott or whatnot, it means that person doesn't believe in free speech. It is simple as that.
It's a cultural concern.
 
When a person seeks to silence somebody else through a boycott or whatnot, it means that person doesn't believe in free speech. It is simple as that.
It's a cultural concern.

BS... Nobody is silencing Unanue... Let him speak all he wants... He is not entitled to my business...
 
Somehow, those yelling fire in a closed theater, think they have to be allowed to yell fire, without suffering any harm. IF you call a black person a nword, you cannot expect them to join in on your enjoyment of free speech. You are likely to be issued a harsh response. AND SHOULD, as that is how humans learn not to say or act improperly.

We have seen what becomes of a human without any pushback on their prejudices and insults. Trump has been coddled almost since birth, and allowed to spew his venom. And so, he insults, and cannot stop himself.

The only time FREE SPEECH should even be mentioned, as a right, is with regard to GOVERNMENT control. SAME WITH innocent till proven guilty. The right wing has been conflating these rights, to extend to other citizens, which they chide, for offering any opinions. And so, since the government is not allowed to have opinions on your insults and bearing false witness, opinions on the way things should be, you too, citizen, should keep your mouth shut about things that clearly affect you.

Now, if you have insults you just MUST divulge, there is little that can be done to stop you. But what you suffer as a result of YOUR choice, is on you. Those that act against you may even suffer as well for those actions, but to say I should not suffer any harm for my insults and attacks, is ludicrous. In fact, the right winger thinks the gov that they think should have no teeth, is called upon, to protect them as they issue insults and attacks.

The right wing even wants to strip us all of our right to free speech, and consumer choice. WE are told that market control is the proper control, till we on the left actually use that, and they are horrified.

A society that TRULY embraced the concept of no fault slander, would descend into chaos. The society that actually removed all norms, as the right wing wants, would have blood running in the streets.

So be proud, that you have standards. BE proud, that you hold folks to account for their speech and actions. IT IS YOUR PERFECT RIGHT.

OK, we (via our government) have created some "protected classes" to make that (bolded above) illegal and have expanded that considerably by use of the "cancel culture" however, if a black person calls a white person a racist, Karen or cracker then that (race based?) insult is not illegal or even likely to be subject to the (privately imposed) "cancel culture" since a member of a "protected class" would likely assert that they can't be fired for issuing their own (race based?) insults.
 
BS... Nobody is silencing Unanue... Let him speak all he wants... He is not entitled to my business...

Agreed, but I think it's....a thin line, slippery slope...whatever you want to say....

CEO of XXXXX comes out and says he supports Trump, feels blessed to have him as President......now if you as an individual choose to be offended by that and choose not to buy their products, so be it, you have that right....I don't think anyone objects to that, I think the objection comes in when you see concentrated efforts, to get mass boycotts, in order to hurt this business etc, when you have members of Congress who are telling you to be offended and do something etc.....thats where I think a line gets crossed.
 
Agreed, but I think it's....a thin line, slippery slope...whatever you want to say....

CEO of XXXXX comes out and says he supports Trump, feels blessed to have him as President......now if you as an individual choose to be offended by that and choose not to buy their products, so be it, you have that right....I don't think anyone objects to that, I think the objection comes in when you see concentrated efforts, to get mass boycotts, in order to hurt this business etc, when you have members of Congress who are telling you to be offended and do something etc.....thats where I think a line gets crossed.

Right wingers have fought mightily against consumer protections, and all consumer power, they fight unions, they generally fight all power of citizens. So you get what you get.
 
Right wingers have fought mightily against consumer protections, and all consumer power, they fight unions, they generally fight all power of citizens. So you get what you get.

Your right, because I specifically said only the left did, and whatever....that response is so ****ing moronic it's not worth a response..
 
Agreed, but I think it's....a thin line, slippery slope...whatever you want to say....

CEO of XXXXX comes out and says he supports Trump, feels blessed to have him as President......now if you as an individual choose to be offended by that and choose not to buy their products, so be it, you have that right....I don't think anyone objects to that, I think the objection comes in when you see concentrated efforts, to get mass boycotts, in order to hurt this business etc, when you have members of Congress who are telling you to be offended and do something etc.....thats where I think a line gets crossed.

Individuals are free to call on other individuals to not buy products of companies they disagree with for any reason they want. There is no line to cross. Free speech and free association are rights in our constitution...
 
Agreed, but I think it's....a thin line, slippery slope...whatever you want to say....

CEO of XXXXX comes out and says he supports Trump, feels blessed to have him as President......now if you as an individual choose to be offended by that and choose not to buy their products, so be it, you have that right....I don't think anyone objects to that, I think the objection comes in when you see concentrated efforts, to get mass boycotts, in order to hurt this business etc, when you have members of Congress who are telling you to be offended and do something etc.....thats where I think a line gets crossed.

I think that is a fair point and I largely agree with you.

There is also a need for business owners, managers and employees to ensure that politics doesn't get in the way of business. Comments that businesses and their owners, managers and employees make in regards to politics, in most circumstances is simply unnecessary. Unfortunately, people don't have a filter and simply cannot help themselves but to politicize business that doesn't need to be politicized.
 
Individuals are free to call on other individuals to not buy products of companies they disagree with for any reason they want. There is no line to cross. Free speech and free association are rights in our constitution...

Just because you have a right to do something, doesn't mean it's right to do.....but you don't care about that, do you?
 
I think that is a fair point and I largely agree with you.

There is also a need for business owners, managers and employees to ensure that politics doesn't get in the way of business. Comments that businesses and their owners, managers and employees make in regards to politics, in most circumstances is simply unnecessary. Unfortunately, people don't have a filter and simply cannot help themselves but to politicize business that doesn't need to be politicized.

Mostly agree to that, especially in this day and age.....but it's absolutely idiotic to me, that offering support of someone, can result in total destruction of one's livelihood.......
 
Just because you have a right to do something, doesn't mean it's right to do.....but you don't care about that, do you?

People do the wrong thing, in my opinion, every day. What are you suggesting we do about this?
 
Mostly agree to that, especially in this day and age.....but it's absolutely idiotic to me, that offering support of someone, can result in total destruction of one's livelihood.......

Showing support of a man that cages children, rips apart families, and kills citizens thru idiocy, is not a simple endorcement.
 
Showing support of a man that cages children, rips apart families, and kills citizens thru idiocy, is not a simple endorcement.

So where was this cancel culture when people supported Obama? You realize he did the same ****ing thing, right?
 
People do the wrong thing, in my opinion, every day. What are you suggesting we do about this?

Kill off most everyone and start over......barring that....you stop letting the inmates run the asylum, which is what is happening now.
 
Kill off most everyone and start over......barring that....you stop letting the inmates run the asylum, which is what is happening now.

Agreed.... Trump should be voted out in November... Can I send you a Biden bumper sticker?
 
Agreed.... Trump should be voted out in November... Can I send you a Biden bumper sticker?

Not at all, in fact, Im willing to bet the only reason you can muster to vote for Biden...is because he's not Trump, which is a really ****ty reason to vote for someone, isn't it?
 
Not at all, in fact, Im willing to bet the only reason you can muster to vote for Biden...is because he's not Trump, which is a really ****ty reason to vote for someone, isn't it?

Or indicative of how poor Trump is as president...
 
BS... Nobody is silencing Unanue... Let him speak all he wants... He is not entitled to my business...

Like I said-- the culture of free speech is being assaulted.
 
Or indicative of how poor Trump is as president...

Again, you aren't voting for something, you are voting against something....it's sad that the only slogan the Democrats can come up with, the only person to run against Trump can run on is....well...I'm not him.

Be it indicative on how Trump has done or not, people don't vote against something, they vote for something, and right now, there's nothing to vote for the Democratic party
 
Again, you aren't voting for something, you are voting against something....it's sad that the only slogan the Democrats can come up with, the only person to run against Trump can run on is....well...I'm not him.

Be it indicative on how Trump has done or not, people don't vote against something, they vote for something, and right now, there's nothing to vote for the Democratic party

You have no idea why I am voting for Biden (offer still stands for a Biden bumper sticker)...
 
You have no idea why I am voting for Biden (offer still stands for a Biden bumper sticker)...

Because he isn't Trump......it's literally the only thing Biden has said......I'm not him, vote for me...lol
 
Back
Top Bottom