• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Fetterman on Biden’s Israel Criticism: Hamas Is ‘Responsible for All’ Civilian Casualties, Israel Wants to ‘Minimize’ Them

anatta

DP Veteran
Joined
Oct 20, 2013
Messages
24,861
Reaction score
10,591
Location
daily dukkha
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
I like!
n Friday’s broadcast of “CNN NewsNight,” Sen. John Fetterman (D-PA) responded to President Joe Biden’s criticism of Israel’s military response to October 7 by stating that Hamas hides behind civilians. He further stated that Hamas is “responsible for all” the deaths of Palestinian civilians while Israel wants to “minimize” civilian deaths and the conflict would end if Hamas surrendered and he doesn’t know why more people aren’t talking about them surrendering.


Host Abby Phillip asked, “So, you have, over the last several months now, been such a staunch supporter of Israel. You’ve backed how the State of Israel and the IDF [have] conducted this war inside of Gaza. President Biden also said last night during that press conference that the IDF operation in Gaza has been ‘over the top.’ Those are his words. Is the President wrong?”


Fetterman responded, “No, I’m not saying it’s wrong. I’m saying that’s his opinion. I’m not necessarily going to agree with that. I do understand that Israeli intelligence believes that Sinwar is actually hiding there, because that’s what these cowards do. They hide behind civilians and children and women like that, as well, too. So, I believe that it’s very critical that they destroy and eliminate Hamas for there to be real, true peace there in Gaza.”


Phillip then asked, “Do you have any concerns about Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s plans, it seems, to move more than 1.3 million people out of the Rafah area. That’s in southern Gaza. That’s basically where Israel told Gazan civilians to go. Are you concerned about what an operation there would mean for the civilian population that’s already displaced?”


Fetterman answered, “Of course I’m concerned. The death of any one innocent Palestinian is a tragedy, and that’s been. But we also must remember that all of the blood [on] the hands are all on Hamas’ hands as well, too. They’re responsible for all of that. And I don’t know why there [are] not more people talking [about why Hamas must surrender]. Why don’t they bring back the last hostages as well, too?”


Phillip then cut in to ask, “But is it something that you would support? Do you think that this is wise on the part of Israel to do what they, it sounds like, are planning to do?”


Fetterman answered, “Well, if they believe that Sinwar is hiding there, then I — it seems that could be reasonable…to eliminate the leadership, because he’s effectively the [bin Laden] of…October 7…I know that they really and I believe they want to minimize any [kind] of death of civilians as well, too. But right now I’d say, if they just surrendered — if Hamas just surrendered, all of this would be over.”
 
Fetterman. What a clown. The biggest disappointment and bait-and-switch con-job since Tulsi Gabbard.
 
By your logic the UK and US are responsible more for WWII than Germany is.

The “strategic bombing” campaigns of World War Two universally failed to destroy enemy morale and force them out of the war.
 
By your logic the UK and US are responsible more for WWII than Germany is.

Lots of blame to go around that brain-laundered U$ apologists/Republicrats won't/can't admit to.
 
The “strategic bombing” campaigns of World War Two universally failed to destroy enemy morale and force them out of the war.

That is one way to make my point for me. So, how many more should Hamas have killed *and* how much of Europe should be speaking German right now for you to be morally happy?
 
Lots of blame to go around that brain-laundered U$ apologists/Republicrats won't/can't admit to.

The irony is, I agree that there is plenty of blame to go around. Not that many would admit that.
 
That is one way to make my point for me. So, how many more should Hamas have killed *and* how much of Europe should be speaking German right now for you to be morally happy?

Uh....no, it doesn’t, because it demonstrates the strategic bombing campaign actively failed to achieve a major part of its rationale and the US and UK doing it should have been seriously re-thought.

Germany had no ability to invade the UK, and once it failed to knock out the Soviets with the first punch their defeat was essentially inevitable.
 
Uh....no, it doesn’t, because it demonstrates the strategic bombing campaign actively failed to achieve a major part of its rationale and the US and UK doing it should have been seriously re-thought.

Germany had no ability to invade the UK, and once it failed to knock out the Soviets with the first punch their defeat was essentially inevitable.

And again, by your logic Germany has less culpability in WWII than the US and UK. We get it.
 
Israel committing war crimes doesn’t magically go away because they cry “but Hamas” a bunch.

Again, your logic changes much of interpretation of history. Keep going.
 
Again, your logic changes much of interpretation of history. Keep going.

Again, historians have made it quite clear strategic bombing doesn’t actually destroy civilian morale and force a surrender. It didn’t work in World War Two, it didn’t work in Korea, and it didn’t work in Vietnam.

By your “logic”, the Blitz was no big deal.
 
Again, historians have made it quite clear strategic bombing doesn’t actually destroy civilian morale and force a surrender. It didn’t work in World War Two, it didn’t work in Korea, and it didn’t work in Vietnam.

By your “logic”, the Blitz was no big deal.

So what works with Hamas? Allowing Israel to be wiped off the map?
 
Israel committing war crimes doesn’t magically go away because they cry “but Hamas” a bunch.

It seems that many brain-laundered, warmongering Republicrat fools can't get that through their skulls. UGH.
 
Do Magas still consider him a vegetable?
 
Back
Top Bottom