• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Example of Socialism in the United States

Bucky

DP Veteran
Joined
Dec 5, 2015
Messages
28,611
Reaction score
6,368
Location
Washington
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Living in Seattle I get to witness first hand the destructive nature of socialism. Seattle somehow elected a socialist on the Seattle City Council. We are talking a true socialist who belongs in the Socialist Alternative, a Trotskyist political party. I wish I was making this up but it is true. She's an economics professor. Seriously.

Here are some of her radical ideas:

On climate change:


Socialist Seattle Politician Kshama Sawant: We Need a Radical Militant Nonviolent Climate Movement | Democracy Now!

Changing Columbus Day:


Seattle Swaps Columbus Day For 'Indigenous Peoples' Day' : Code Switch : NPR

She truly is a radical, dangerous women. Anti-police, Anti-business type person. She recently voted against building a new arena in Seattle. She will defend a Black Lives Matter Activist over a cop any day of the week. She defends rent control and allowing homeless people to reside on sidewalks.
 
The Columbus Day thing is completely valid issue, as after all it celebrates a genocidal maniac child rapist who discovered the Bahamas. For some reason Americans have an entire day dedicated to him. Should the Congo celebrate Leopold Day or Germany celebrate Hitler Day?
 

Personally I'm totally against Trotskyism, but let's set that aside. What damage has she allegedly wrought to Seattle? Your opening statement, to wit, was "I get to witness first hand the destructive nature of socialism." Either renaming a public holiday and fighting for democracy has now been redefined to be "destructive" or else you don't know what you're talking about. I'd wager it's the latter.
 

Why do you hate your ancestors?
 
Pretty sure she's not a Trotskyist, SA might be one of those big tent socialist parties.

A free day off for the kids is a free day off.

EDIT:

Is the forum looking weird for anyone else here?
 
Last edited:

thats radical too you?
 



How can you call yourself a 'centrist' and post BS like you've posted in this comment?

:lol:

Fill us in.
 

You do sound as though you are afraid of her.

She is speaking her mind...championing the issue she advocates.

Why would that frighten you...unless, perhaps, you think they might become popular among the majority of people?
 
Well, I see socialism right in my very own immediate family!

It's called MediCare.

And after a long career of running her beauty shop from her late 20's until she was 72, all the while paying taxes as a productive citizen, it allows my mom to rest comfortably in her waning twilight years without bankrupting her or us.

Yeah - that socialism is a bitch, ain't it?
 
Now that's a bit harsh, no?

Alright, Columbus Day *was* a give-away in the States to appease the burgeoning Italian-American community. It still is, along with in my city, the separately celebrated "Venetian Night" flotilla (I'm not sure if other waterfront cities with significant Italian-American populations do the latter).

And I suppose they could've went with Amerigo Vespucci as an alternative, and I think a valid argument could be made for him of sorts. But I suppose each man simply represented their native city state's ethos, with Vespucci being the more academic Florentine observer & thinker to Columbus' brash Genovese mercantile oriented exploratory leadership.

But unlike Leif Erikson's voyages a half a millennia earlier, Columbus opened the door for permanent European interaction with the New World. For better or worse, he was a man of his place and time. I think he's getting the short end of the stick, here. Over 3 centuries later the first President of the United States was a slave owner (and many after him), and we don't let that blemish his otherwise positive deeds.

I won't deny Columbus was a tyrannical governor in the new world, but I do not believe a comparison to Leopold or Hitler is an equivalency. I can kinda' see what you're getting at with Leopold, but still don't see it.
 

Thank you for the post FT.

She is a rebel-rouser that has been arrested for disorderly conduct. She fights for policies that hurt our state - and supports candidates that would hurt the United States. A mandatory $15 minimum wage, fighting against a mythical foe in global warming, etc.

You can see the SA's goals right here. So how many of these policy would bankrupt America:

About SA | Socialist Alternative

 

Columbus is remembered as a symbolic figure, the Discoverer. Hitler and Leopold II are remembered primarily for the great evil they did.

As the Warden of the Mint, Isaac Newton had sent a lot of people to gallows, for mere counterfeiting. But it would be weird to demand renaming The Newton's Laws of Motion lest we celebrate such barbarism....
 
I'm still waiting for the OP to show me some example of actual "socialism".
 
Dragonfly said:
I'm still waiting for the OP to show me some example of actual "socialism".
Click to expand...

Here you go:

Free, high quality healthcare for all. Replace the failed for-profit insurance companies with a publicly funded single-payer system as a step towards fully socialized medicine.
Click to expand...

Capitalism produces poverty, inequality, environmental destruction and war. We need an international struggle against this system.
Click to expand...

 
Give the leftists enough time they will have Seattle looking like Detroit in a few years.
 
OP, she expressed an opinion and you expressed one as well. We move on.
 
A minimum guaranteed weekly income of $600/week for the unemployed, disabled, stay-at-home parents, the elderly, and others unable to work.
Click to expand...

She essentially wants to give $28,800 to people for doing nothing. This is in addition with unemployment benefits, disability benefits, Social Security, etc they already receive. Can you say, insolvent?

Free, high quality healthcare for all. Replace the failed for-profit insurance companies with a publicly funded single-payer system as a step towards fully socialized medicine.
Click to expand...

Not possible.

Socialist Seattle Politician Kshama Sawant: We Need a Radical Militant Nonviolent Climate Movement
Click to expand...

This is a war against oil, corporations and businesses. All against what? A fight against a mythical opponent in global warming which may or may not be caused my humans.

The federal government should bail out states to prevent cuts and layoffs. A massive increase in taxes on the rich and big business, not working people.
Click to expand...

She's friends with Bernie Sanders. This idea she supports the 99% and fights against the 1% is a farce. A "massive increase in taxes" on the rich is essentially anyone in the middle class or above.
 

She sounds like a smart woman. You're lucky to have her.
 

Chomsky, we all know Medicare is a ponzi scheme. It is the definition of that. I hate robin hood/socialist policies like this.
 
Frank Apisa said:
She sounds like a smart woman. You're lucky to have her.
Click to expand...

I am unsure how a socialist can be a professor in economics when socialists do not understand basic economics 101.
 

Give them John Cabot day, he actually discovered part of North America. He was not a product of time as the Spanish later tried to persecute him for his crimes so the likeness to Nazis can continue and are perfectly valid.
 
Last edited:
Paleocon said:
Why do you hate your ancestors?
Click to expand...

Not mine, I would rather celebrate John Cabot, also Italian and actually discovered North America but with money from the English or how about Jacques Cartier, famous explorer who also helped discover North America.
 

I don't have a problem with Columbus Day, and I wholeheartedly support her stance on public arenas which are nothing but crony capitalism for wealthy team owners. They don't make any economic sense, and so as an economics professor, she's just voting with the evidence on those boondoggles. Their only justification is a lot of people want a team in their city and are willing for taxpayers to heavily subsidize their entertainment options. IMO, if the team wants public subsidies, let the team be publicly owned like it is in Green Bay, instead of letting the benefits flow to a small group of wealthy owners. At least the city should demand an ownership share if it's going to put up half or more of the cost of a stadium for its use.
 
Carjosse said:
Give them John Cabot day, he actually discovered part of North America. He was not a product of time as the Spanish later tried to persecute him for his crimes so the likeness to Nazis can continue and are perfectly valid.
Click to expand...
Alright, fair enough.

You do seem to have a good sense of history.

I'll respect your opinion.
 
Bucky said:
Chomsky, we all know Medicare is a ponzi scheme. It is the definition of that. I hate robin hood/socialist policies like this.
Click to expand...
To the bolded: No I don't, beyond your unsupported assertion. Please explain.

And I like this policy.

So what is the free-market healthcare solution for my octogenarian mother? What do you propose?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…