• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......[W:124]

Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Or it may be that they see too many problems with single payer.

Yeah, the Republicans saw a lot of problems with Obamacare and they did not give one vote in support for it.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Yeah, the Republicans saw a lot of problems with Obamacare and they did not give one vote in support for it.

The Democrats couldn't get enough support in their own party to pass single payer even as an alternative to the insurance mandate. A veteran might understand -- whatever he or she likes or doesn't like about the VA is what people will like or not like about single payer. They work pretty much the same way except that the VA is more lavishly funded than single payer will be.

I mean to say, look at how low the government allowed the VA to get for a while. Look at how low they've allowed Medicaid to get. They've pretty much proven that they can't be trusted to run a health care system.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

What would you suggest as a way of doing this? I'm interested in your alternative plan, I already know what you think of Obama, Democrats, Liberals and Obamacare. But I'm looking for a suggested alternative so I can support it.

For starters what we had was better than Obamacare.

How about being able to buy health insurance across state lines. How about tort reform. How about clinics that are staffed with nurse practitioners and have Dr. volunteers and have interns give a yr to the clinics that are across the country. These clinics would take all the emergency cases except the sever cases. This would greatly reduce the Emergency room cases. If a person came to an emergency room that had the snivels they would be refused and sent to a clinic. For starters. Their are many more items that can be addressed.

But while you champion Obamacare, Businesses, the American People, the economy is a disaster because of Obamacare.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

What would you suggest as a way of doing this? I'm interested in your alternative plan, I already know what you think of Obama, Democrats, Liberals and Obamacare. But I'm looking for a suggested alternative so I can support it.

Here's an idea: Instead of a mandate people will be allowed to buy insurance or not as they please. If they don't have insurance they automatically get catastrophic coverage from the government paid for through their income tax as a percentage of their income. Nondeniability will be handled through government subsidies.

A Death Panel, aka Payment Advisory Board, would issue recommendations to state insurance boards concerning coverage and reimbursement as a means of cost control.

The advantage is that nobody has to go to a website to get insurance. They get coverage by default and it gets sorted out at income tax time. The insurance companies deal with the government and the people or businesses deal directly with insurance companies.

No, it's not a libertarian solution, but I don't think we can get to a libertarian solution from where we are now.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

For starters what we had was better than Obamacare.

How about being able to buy health insurance across state lines. How about tort reform. How about clinics that are staffed with nurse practitioners and have Dr. volunteers and have interns give a yr to the clinics that are across the country. These clinics would take all the emergency cases except the sever cases. This would greatly reduce the Emergency room cases. If a person came to an emergency room that had the snivels they would be refused and sent to a clinic. For starters. Their are many more items that can be addressed.

But while you champion Obamacare, Businesses, the American People, the economy is a disaster because of Obamacare.

Here's an idea: Instead of a mandate people will be allowed to buy insurance or not as they please. If they don't have insurance they automatically get catastrophic coverage from the government paid for through their income tax as a percentage of their income. Nondeniability will be handled through government subsidies.

A Death Panel, aka Payment Advisory Board, would issue recommendations to state insurance boards concerning coverage and reimbursement as a means of cost control.

The advantage is that nobody has to go to a website to get insurance. They get coverage by default and it gets sorted out at income tax time. The insurance companies deal with the government and the people or businesses deal directly with insurance companies.

No, it's not a libertarian solution, but I don't think we can get to a libertarian solution from where we are now.

OK. First, I am not a champion of Obamacare. I'm not a champion of any legislation that gets much over 50 pages. I'll guess that not one person actually understands Obamacare, it's the product of committees, all of whom are of vested interest, in one form or another.

That being said, I think a lot of your ideas are good. Why can banks be everywhere but not insurance companies? Anything with less lawyers is good too. Rational guidelines instead of case by case drama.

I'm pretty sure we consume all these medical resources one way or another. So there certainly were simpler, more comprehensible approaches. Unfortunately, we now have this confusing law in place. I hope it works considering how much has already been invested without a single patient being seen yet.

I'm totally in favor of death panels. They sound oh so cruel but it's a real issue with end of life medical care exceeding the rest of your lifetime care.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

OK. First, I am not a champion of Obamacare. I'm not a champion of any legislation that gets much over 50 pages. I'll guess that not one person actually understands Obamacare, it's the product of committees, all of whom are of vested interest, in one form or another.

That being said, I think a lot of your ideas are good. Why can banks be everywhere but not insurance companies? Anything with less lawyers is good too. Rational guidelines instead of case by case drama.

I'm pretty sure we consume all these medical resources one way or another. So there certainly were simpler, more comprehensible approaches. Unfortunately, we now have this confusing law in place. I hope it works considering how much has already been invested without a single patient being seen yet.

I'm totally in favor of death panels. They sound oh so cruel but it's a real issue with end of life medical care exceeding the rest of your lifetime care.

Question, how do you describe a person with an pre-existing recondition? Is this a person that is in their late 20's and has chose to not have health insurance and now has a medical condition that needs costly care? Is it a person that was born with a life medical condition? I'm asking what qualifies a person to be considered one with an existing condition. I think this question will have many different meanings by many different people. Maybe Obamacare clarifies with a definition, although I doubt it.

Is it possible to not ever buy health insurance and then get sick when your 58 and call up Obamacare and get whatever insurance you need without ever paying a dime before. If this the case why would anyone buy insurance, just wait until you need it.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

A crucial weekend for the troubled website that is the backbone of President Barack Obama's healthcare overhaul appears to be off to a shaky start, as the U.S. government took the HealthCare.gov site offline for an unusually long maintenance period into Saturday morning.

Just hours before the Obama administration's self-imposed deadline to get the insurance shopping website working for the "vast majority" of its users by Saturday, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) announced that it was taking down the website for an 11-hour period that would end at 8 a.m. EST on Saturday.

For the administration and its Democratic allies, the stakes are enormous.

The healthcare overhaul is Obama's signature domestic achievement, a program designed to extend coverage to millions of Americans and reduce healthcare costs. To work, the program must enroll millions of young, healthy consumers whose participation in the new insurance exchanges is key to keeping costs in check.

Obama's fellow Democrats who are up for re-election in Congress already have shown signs of distancing themselves from the president and his healthcare program. If the website does not show significant improvement soon, some Democrats - particularly the dozen U.S. senators who are from states led by conservative Republicans and who are up for re-election next year - might call for extending Obamacare's final March 31 enrollment deadline for 2014.

That would delay the fines that are mandated by the law for those who do not have insurance by that date, a scenario that insurers say would destabilize the market. It also would fuel Republicans' arguments that Obamacare, and its website, are fatally flawed and should be scrapped.

Eleventh-hour checks were not encouraging, said Matthew Hancock, an independent expert in software design who said he could tell within hours of the site's launch that its problems were the results of poor system design and bugs, rather than the heavy traffic that the administration blamed initially.

"Whenever you have a date and a number, you need to be pretty sure that you can hit that date and that number," Engates told Reuters.....snip~

Crucial weekend for Obamacare website begins with a shutdown


Reuters is reporting that is a shaky start for Team Obama and the Democrats. They have to rely on hoping it works. Any trouble.....well you see what the Democrats will do with Obamacare. Which will play Right into the elections. Who's on the seat of their pants more now? Team Obama or the Democrats?

No young people.....and it's no go. Already Obama and his team think by shutting the system down for periods of time will help them. Then by giving out a number and date. Nothing like keeping people hanging on to try and count numbers.....huh?

In a way even though I don't like the law, I do hope they fix the web site so we can see what actually happens. So far we have been dealing in theories and suppositions as to what will happen. Sooner or later this thing will have to stand on its own or not. But so much of it has been pushed back and so many exemptions granted it is like the Democrats are afraid that if it was implemented all at once the weight of the world or should I say more accurately, the voters would come down upon them.

Regardless, lets have the web site fixed so we can see what will happen for sure. I have had enough delays, enough putting the hard stuff off and enough exemptions that I wonder if the law actually means anything at all.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Question, how do you describe a person with an pre-existing recondition? Is this a person that is in their late 20's and has chose to not have health insurance and now has a medical condition that needs costly care? Is it a person that was born with a life medical condition? I'm asking what qualifies a person to be considered one with an existing condition. I think this question will have many different meanings by many different people. Maybe Obamacare clarifies with a definition, although I doubt it.

Is it possible to not ever buy health insurance and then get sick when your 58 and call up Obamacare and get whatever insurance you need without ever paying a dime before. If this the case why would anyone buy insurance, just wait until you need it.

There has always been a definition of pre-existing as any condition that existed prior to the writing of the insurance policy. Someone that is born under an already existing policy (of their parents) would not be subject to pre-ex limitations until they change policies by going to a new carrier.

Most insurance policies, prior to Obamacare, exclude payments for pre-existing conditions during the first two years of the policy. After that, the pre-existing condition is paid as normal. An insurance company that underwrites the issue of their policies can choose not to issue the policy based on what they locate... Or they may charge higher rates to cover the risk they face in covering it. The reason for pre-ex exclusions was to not incentivize people to skip insurance until they come down with an expensive condition and the insurance was needed.

I'm not sure how Obamacare will address that - as the fees are not nearly enough IMO. If I didn't have kids, I would be the first to pay the fine and skip the insurance until I needed it. I would then sign up for a policy when it is needed (I am having medical issues) since I couldn't be denied the policy at that time. That, I believe, will be a large problem.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

There has always been a definition of pre-existing as any condition that existed prior to the writing of the insurance policy. Someone that is born under an already existing policy (of their parents) would not be subject to pre-ex limitations until they change policies by going to a new carrier.

Most insurance policies, prior to Obamacare, exclude payments for pre-existing conditions during the first two years of the policy. After that, the pre-existing condition is paid as normal. An insurance company that underwrites the issue of their policies can choose not to issue the policy based on what they locate... Or they may charge higher rates to cover the risk they face in covering it. The reason for pre-ex exclusions was to not incentivize people to skip insurance until they come down with an expensive condition and the insurance was needed.

I'm not sure how Obamacare will address that - as the fees are not nearly enough IMO. If I didn't have kids, I would be the first to pay the fine and skip the insurance until I needed it. I would then sign up for a policy when it is needed (I am having medical issues) since I couldn't be denied the policy at that time. That, I believe, will be a large problem.

This is exactly what I'm asking. How does Obamacare qualify a person with a pre-existing condition. I'm with you, why buy insurance if you can buy it at the time when you get cancer. I hear all this "how great Obamacare is that people with pre-existing conditions can now get insurance." Well, why buy insurance until you need it.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

In a way even though I don't like the law, I do hope they fix the web site so we can see what actually happens. So far we have been dealing in theories and suppositions as to what will happen. Sooner or later this thing will have to stand on its own or not. But so much of it has been pushed back and so many exemptions granted it is like the Democrats are afraid that if it was implemented all at once the weight of the world or should I say more accurately, the voters would come down upon them.

Regardless, lets have the web site fixed so we can see what will happen for sure. I have had enough delays, enough putting the hard stuff off and enough exemptions that I wonder if the law actually means anything at all.

Is over 5 million people and millions more to come getting cancellations by their insurance company a theorie or suppositions as what will happen. I agree with the delays, the exemptions, you are taxed and you are not, stuff. We also know the $2,500 a yr you are going to save on your insurance was a lie. All I see is stories of higher premiums and higher deductibles. Plus you can't keep your insurance if you want to. Period. And you can't keep your Dr. if you want to. Period. These are all not suppositions or theories.

I don't know when you would call the game over. But it's clear to me the game is over.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

This is exactly what I'm asking. How does Obamacare qualify a person with a pre-existing condition. I'm with you, why buy insurance if you can buy it at the time when you get cancer. I hear all this "how great Obamacare is that people with pre-existing conditions can now get insurance." Well, why buy insurance until you need it.

I guess they are hoping that the rest of us taxpayers pay enough for the young people's insurance that it's cheaper for them to buy the policy with the tax payer subsidies then it is to pay the fine. If that is the thought process, what a mess.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

I guess they are hoping that the rest of us taxpayers pay enough for the young people's insurance that it's cheaper for them to buy the policy with the tax payer subsidies then it is to pay the fine. If that is the thought process, what a mess.

I just found this:

https://pcip.gov/Whos_Eligible.html

To qualify for PCIP, you must:

Have a pre-existing condition
Be a U.S. citizen, or live in the U.S. legally
Have been without health coverage for the last 6 months

You are NOT eligible for PCIP coverage if:

You have other insurance coverage, even if it doesn’t cover your medical condition
You’re enrolled in a state high risk pool
You have Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP, VA or TRICARE coverage
You have job-based coverage, including COBRA, or continuation of coverage, even if it’s about to end
You have a limited benefit plan

There is more gobble goop but nothing that would deny you coverage if you never had health insurance in the past. So screw buying health insurance, wait until you have a problem and call Obamacare and get insurance at the standard rate and the next day tell them you have cancer or you had a heart attack and need insurance NOW. They have to insure you and pay the bill. Now that is a deal, all provided by your tax payer. Really what's the big deal about all these millions of people getting cancellation notices, who cares, just wait and when you need someone to pay the bill call Obamacare.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Is over 5 million people and millions more to come getting cancellations by their insurance company a theorie or suppositions as what will happen. I agree with the delays, the exemptions, you are taxed and you are not, stuff. We also know the $2,500 a yr you are going to save on your insurance was a lie. All I see is stories of higher premiums and higher deductibles. Plus you can't keep your insurance if you want to. Period. And you can't keep your Dr. if you want to. Period. These are all not suppositions or theories.

I don't know when you would call the game over. But it's clear to me the game is over.

The game is never over until the fat lady sings or the law is repealed.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

The game is never over until the fat lady sings or the law is repealed.

Sit back and relax, everything you see is theories and suppositions. I see what is really happening to the American people and more. But hey remain in denial until the fat lady sings, while the rest of us move onto a better solution.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Sit back and relax, everything you see is theories and suppositions. I see what is really happening to the American people and more. But hey remain in denial until the fat lady sings, while the rest of us move onto a better solution.

I've been around politics way too long to take anything for granted. Repeal at this point in time looks like it may never happen or if it does it is so far down the road it won't mean anything.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Question, how do you describe a person with an pre-existing recondition? Is this a person that is in their late 20's and has chose to not have health insurance and now has a medical condition that needs costly care? Is it a person that was born with a life medical condition? I'm asking what qualifies a person to be considered one with an existing condition. I think this question will have many different meanings by many different people. Maybe Obamacare clarifies with a definition, although I doubt it.

Is it possible to not ever buy health insurance and then get sick when your 58 and call up Obamacare and get whatever insurance you need without ever paying a dime before. If this the case why would anyone buy insurance, just wait until you need it.

You make a good point. I suppose that's why they are making it mandatory to have insurance. Most people want insurance to protect themselves from financial ruin. Only people with nothing to lose would be motivated to avoid insurance. Even now, I think local hospitals treat people with no money and no insurance.

In 2500 pages, they had room for a definition, I suspect.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

You're 100% right. I worded that 100% wrong. What I meant was "employer-provided health insurance." People who just go to work for a company and automatically get enrolled in their group policy (usually sans even limited-time exclusions for pre-existing conditions) don't understand what so many of the rest of us have gone through to maintain our health insurance . . . if it was even available at any price.

If you quit your job and get another, under the old system, you had immediate health insurance coverage...even if you'd just had surgery for a cancer of some type. Those who have to purchase their own? That would be our nation's entrepreneurs and those companies too small to avail themselves of group coverage. They couldn't get insurance at any price once even a completely cured cancer was in their health history.

I could give you Old-Way Health Insurance 101 information, but it's lengthy. Suffice to say that, sans Illinois' ICHIP program (subsidized), I was paying $850/month for a $5,200 deductible policy when I left American Family three years ago. My premium was scheduled to raise -- at it's anniversary date -- over 30%. Could I shop around for a cheaper policy? No, because I was uninsurable at that point. So my health insurance (because I have health issues) used to cost $850 x 12 + $5,200 = $15,400 a year before the 30% increase. How many people could pay that and avoid bankruptcy? I'd venture not too many.

That dilemma is what so many people who work for others and had their health insurance provided by their employer have never understood. (No offense.)
I thank you for your cordial reply and take no offense at it. Particularly since I don't find it pertains to me or most people who "just go to work" for companies that offer health insurance as you say. I believe you are operating under some basic misconceptions and making presumptions about what other people think out of hand. Unless you have some psychic window into the minds and thoughts of people other than yourself. Please take no offense but if you do have a crystal ball, I for one don't think it is a reliable source for any claims of clairvoyance.

While I appreciate your anecdotal relation and have no doubt about the sincerity of it, I fail to see how this addresses or explains your "just sailing along" claim. In an equally anecdotal relation on my own part, I have found that most people have at one time or another (particularly in their younger years or while in college) not "sailed along" but were without insurance and thus were able to fully grasp and appreciate their change in fortune once they did get insurance. Also many people have attempted to start and make a go of their own business and unfortunately this is sometimes met with failure. Which leads to a greater appreciation of employer provided health insurance in my experience and is hardly befitting the description of "just sailing along" as you stated.

I again thank you for your cordial reply. I do however admit that I don't find claims like yours, as to what other people "think" or "feel" reliable or relevant. As it is a leap of logic and presumption on your part that in my opinion ignores or rejects the real world experience that most people have as they age and move up from scholastic pursuits and into the workplace. The idea that most people (as seemed to be your presumption) don't have any idea about all of these realities simply becasue they "just go to work" and are thus "just sailing along" seems to my mind at least suggestive of a preexisting ax to grind on your part. If you have some scholarly source to cite that supports your claim about how and why other people think or feel on this topic I'd enjoy reading it and will certainly amend my thinking on the matter if you should. :peace
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

I thank you for your cordial reply and take no offense at it. Particularly since I don't find it pertains to me or most people who "just go to work" for companies that offer health insurance as you say. I believe you are operating under some basic misconceptions and making presumptions about what other people think out of hand. Unless you have some psychic window into the minds and thoughts of people other than yourself. Please take no offense but if you do have a crystal ball, I for one don't think it is a reliable source for any claims of clairvoyance.

While I appreciate your anecdotal relation and have no doubt about the sincerity of it, I fail to see how this addresses or explains your "just sailing along" claim. In an equally anecdotal relation on my own part, I have found that most people have at one time or another (particularly in their younger years or while in college) not "sailed along" but were without insurance and thus were able to fully grasp and appreciate their change in fortune once they did get insurance. Also many people have attempted to start and make a go of their own business and unfortunately this is sometimes met with failure. Which leads to a greater appreciation of employer provided health insurance in my experience and is hardly befitting the description of "just sailing along" as you stated.

I again thank you for your cordial reply. I do however admit that I don't find claims like yours, as to what other people "think" or "feel" reliable or relevant. As it is a leap of logic and presumption on your part that in my opinion ignores or rejects the real world experience that most people have as they age and move up from scholastic pursuits and into the workplace. The idea that most people (as seemed to be your presumption) don't have any idea about all of these realities simply becasue they "just go to work" and are thus "just sailing along" seems to my mind at least suggestive of a preexisting ax to grind on your part. If you have some scholarly source to cite that supports your claim about how and why other people think or feel on this topic I'd enjoy reading it and will certainly amend my thinking on the matter if you should. :peace

Many people have no idea what it's like to purchase individual insurance. That's a fact. Especially senior citizens, the group that is rallying the most against the ACA. While my experience is also anectodotal and also not exclusive to all seniors I can tell you that they are overall an ignorant lot about what insurance is like, having coasted along on their employer plans and many receiving either post-employment sponsored insurance, medicare, or medicaid.

"Keep the government out of my medicare" is just the tip of the iceberg...
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

I never had any expectation that the website would be functional by today. In speaking with an acquaintance of some considerable technical expertise and experience with both website and cloud coding and construction and considerable experience in working for the federal government, I believe the website will still not be "ready for prime time" by even the end of February. No matter the operational status of the webiste young healthy people won't be signing on for $350 plus a month health insurance when that same amount will put them in a seriously sweet automobile or fuel enldess iPad iPod and recreational purchases. ;) .


Mornin' AS. :2wave: Well Obama and Team do have expectations. Despite their efforts to keep moving the goalposts. It is as you say.....even should they get the site up and functional. It will take them at least another two months to go full operational. They still don't have the payment methods worked out either.

Also just because it is Obama's signature legislation.....it doesn't mean that it has to be accepted by the people. It can be throw out at anytime, once the entire nation speaks out and makes the move.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

In a way even though I don't like the law, I do hope they fix the web site so we can see what actually happens. So far we have been dealing in theories and suppositions as to what will happen. Sooner or later this thing will have to stand on its own or not. But so much of it has been pushed back and so many exemptions granted it is like the Democrats are afraid that if it was implemented all at once the weight of the world or should I say more accurately, the voters would come down upon them.

Regardless, lets have the web site fixed so we can see what will happen for sure. I have had enough delays, enough putting the hard stuff off and enough exemptions that I wonder if the law actually means anything at all.

Mornin' Pero. :2wave: Unfortunately they wont have it fixed for a couple more months. Now we will play the waiting game with those that were given numbers and a time. See if they can get back in. It's a stall tactic. He has to hope his Raw Kool-Aid eaters listen to him and don't crash the site.....while rushing to save him and his pathetic Signature Legislation. Even Valerie Jarrett was out speaking to the Media to lie some more and give her support. Now this one.....is where the Republicans should start focusing upon too.

This will get under Obama's skin in the worse way. I would go full tilt after Jarrett. Especially with FP and Flounder's Care-Package.

Whats really enjoyable is knowing Obama is sweating his ass off,.....worrying about if it will work. If it will work. I like when he is focused on If. IMO it gives a real good insight into where he was with his Whole Care-Package himself. As to also how much he was actually involved in.

Same thing with the Democrats.....especially Reid and Pelosi. Wherein we want their names always to go down in history as the 2 Biggest ****-ups this country has ever seen. Or had in it's History. Their lucky it wasn't back when this country was first started. As both.....would have been hung if not shot dead on the spot where they Opened their mouths......to Speak.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

I thank you for your cordial reply and take no offense at it. Particularly since I don't find it pertains to me or most people who "just go to work" for companies that offer health insurance as you say. I believe you are operating under some basic misconceptions and making presumptions about what other people think out of hand. Unless you have some psychic window into the minds and thoughts of people other than yourself. Please take no offense but if you do have a crystal ball, I for one don't think it is a reliable source for any claims of clairvoyance.

While I appreciate your anecdotal relation and have no doubt about the sincerity of it, I fail to see how this addresses or explains your "just sailing along" claim. In an equally anecdotal relation on my own part, I have found that most people have at one time or another (particularly in their younger years or while in college) not "sailed along" but were without insurance and thus were able to fully grasp and appreciate their change in fortune once they did get insurance. Also many people have attempted to start and make a go of their own business and unfortunately this is sometimes met with failure. Which leads to a greater appreciation of employer provided health insurance in my experience and is hardly befitting the description of "just sailing along" as you stated.

I again thank you for your cordial reply. I do however admit that I don't find claims like yours, as to what other people "think" or "feel" reliable or relevant. As it is a leap of logic and presumption on your part that in my opinion ignores or rejects the real world experience that most people have as they age and move up from scholastic pursuits and into the workplace. The idea that most people (as seemed to be your presumption) don't have any idea about all of these realities simply becasue they "just go to work" and are thus "just sailing along" seems to my mind at least suggestive of a preexisting ax to grind on your part. If you have some scholarly source to cite that supports your claim about how and why other people think or feel on this topic I'd enjoy reading it and will certainly amend my thinking on the matter if you should. :peace

Well, apparently you take exception to my use of "just sailing along".

It has been my real world experience that most people are unaware of what the individual health insurance market forces have been, how expensive individual health insurance is and how difficult (if not impossible) it can be to purchase. Most people get that education when they, as an example, leave a job to start their own business...and, with their healthy little selves (as they see it) find that they are uninsurable. Or find that they cannot leave their jobs as they'd planned because insurance isn't available to them at any price. Or that certain conditions they have will be excluded from their 'new insurance.' Or perhaps they learn (quickly) when they attempt to retire early. Or are terminated and have to pay their full COBRA premium.

If you have a clear understanding of these things, more power to you. That sentence then...just sailing along...did not apply to you.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Many people have no idea what it's like to purchase individual insurance. That's a fact. Especially senior citizens, the group that is rallying the most against the ACA. While my experience is also anectodotal and also not exclusive to all seniors I can tell you that they are overall an ignorant lot about what insurance is like, having coasted along on their employer plans and many receiving either post-employment sponsored insurance, medicare, or medicaid.

"Keep the government out of my medicare" is just the tip of the iceberg...
I would not quibble with the idea that some people have no idea what it's like to purchase individual insurance. Just as some do and in some or if you prefer many cases, this is a factor that lead them to decide to seek employment where they can get and qualify for it based upon their knowledge of the individual market. That is a fact too. I'll need to see some source that supports your claim that the group rallying the most against ACA is senior citizens. This is the problem with making axiomatic all encompassing claims such as yours. It rejects and ignores out of hand the simple fact that by nature it is senior citizens who often have the most experience and knowledge about matters like this based upon their age and accumulated knowledge of life in the real and business world. If in fact it is seniors who are rallying the most, it is likely due to their knowledge and experience. Particularly when many senior citizens understand that it is the very involvement of the government in medical care via the programs you listed that is a very large and real part of the problem. As well as a strong competent in what is wrong with our current system and why it is so in need of real reform. It is senior citizens who know first hand of the fraud and waste (well documented) in medicare and medicaid, not their younger more ignorant countrymen and women. Who have no practical experience and can only point to anecdotal relations and reporting of the same. Rather than first hand practical experience dealing with these programs. Which is why many judiciously argue against more government intrusion into a field already deeply effected by incompetent government intervention. I find your comment that they or anyone simply "coast along" fraught with condescending implication. "Keep the government out of my medicare" is an oxymoron.

Mornin' AS. :2wave: Well Obama and Team do have expectations. Despite their efforts to keep moving the goalposts. It is as you say.....even should they get the site up and functional. It will take them at least another two months to go full operational. They still don't have the payment methods worked out either.

Also just because it is Obama's signature legislation.....it doesn't mean that it has to be accepted by the people. It can be throw out at anytime, once the entire nation speaks out and makes the move.
I'd say that the recent poor decision by democrats to enact the nuclear option may be the signal biggest mistake I have seen in some time. One that could actually lead the way (depending upon the next midterms) to opening the door for the repeal of the ACA. Because apparently the democrats can't conceive of the day that they will ever (in the future of this country) ever possibly be in the minority again.:doh
 
Last edited:
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

You make a good point. I suppose that's why they are making it mandatory to have insurance. Most people want insurance to protect themselves from financial ruin. Only people with nothing to lose would be motivated to avoid insurance. Even now, I think local hospitals treat people with no money and no insurance.

In 2500 pages, they had room for a definition, I suspect.

It's not mandatory, yes you have to pay a fine if you don't have insurance. But that is far cheaper than buying health insurance. So you pay the fine and when you get sick call up Obamacare and all is good. Except for the tax payer.
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Well, apparently you take exception to my use of "just sailing along".

It has been my real world experience that most people are unaware of what the individual health insurance market forces have been, how expensive individual health insurance is and how difficult (if not impossible) it can be to purchase. Most people get that education when they, as an example, leave a job to start their own business...and, with their healthy little selves (as they see it) find that they are uninsurable. Or find that they cannot leave their jobs as they'd planned because insurance isn't available to them at any price. Or that certain conditions they have will be excluded from their 'new insurance.' Or perhaps they learn (quickly) when they attempt to retire early. Or are terminated and have to pay their full COBRA premium.

If you have a clear understanding of these things, more power to you. That sentence then...just sailing along...did not apply to you.
Well yes I thought that was clear from the start and I've clarified why. Virtually everyone I know that has employer provided health insurance sees precisely what their employers contribution to their monthly bill is. So how this leaves the same people as you say, ignorant of the true cost of the same does not follow your logic. The same goes for anyone that has ever lost a job and dealt with the very Cobra plans you reference. Sticker shock is quickly arrived at and just as quickly imparts a grim and certain knowledge about the true cost of health insurance. So at the end of the day your assumption that most people don't share your knowledge of the individual market is just that. As I said, it seems to me that you bring an axe to grind here. Once more if you have some scholarly source to cite that supports your claim about how and why other people think or feel on this topic I'd enjoy reading it and will certainly amend my thinking on the matter if you should.:peace
 
Re: Crucial Weekend for Obamacare Website begins with a Shutdown......

Well yes I thought that was clear from the start and I've clarified why. Virtually everyone I know that has employer provided health insurance sees precisely what their employers contribution to their monthly bill is. So how this leaves the same people as you say, ignorant of the true cost of the same does not follow your logic. The same goes for anyone that has ever lost a job and dealt with the very Cobra plans you reference. Sticker shock is quickly arrived at and just as quickly imparts a grim and certain knowledge about the true cost of health insurance. So at the end of the day your assumption that most people don't share your knowledge of the individual market is just that. As I said, it seems to me that you bring an axe to grind here. Once more if you have some scholarly source to cite that supports your claim about how and why other people think or feel on this topic I'd enjoy reading it and will certainly amend my thinking on the matter if you should.:peace

Ask me if I care whether or not you "amend your thinking" on this matter, Arthur. If you don't like anecdotal opinions and real-world insights from real virtual people, you're going to be Grumpy Cat most of the time on Debate Politics.

grumpy-cat-nope.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom