• We will be taking the server down at approximately 3:30 AM ET on Wednesday, 10/8/25. We have a hard drive that is in the early stages of failure and this is necessary to prevent data loss. We hope to be back up and running quickly, however this process could take some time.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Confederate monuments[W:1182]

Re: Confederate monuments




I commented earlier on the twisted warped reality southern confederate apologists have created for themselves.
 
Re: Confederate monuments


in an insurrection it is the aim of a group of people with a plan to take over a government cease it for their own purposes, the south had no such plan before the war.

in the whiskey rebellion, people selling whiskey were by law to lay a tax on that whiskey and that tax money be collected, but they refused to lay the tax

the people of that rebellion stayed where they were, they did not move against any government be it state or federal, they thumped their noses at government until Washington marched on them
 
Re: Confederate monuments

And Po PO has been told this before, but refuses to learn.

The matter was settled at the Convention. The Constitution is

"In toto and forever."


James Madison ^ He made it clear at the NY convention, when NY asked explicitly for a right to secede. He and Hamilton said: NO. No right exist.

A vote was taken. It was agreed.

Similarly, it had been proposed and rejected by the Virginia ratifying convention.
 
Re: Confederate monuments

ok, but what i what rebutting was that all blacks in the south were not subservient, as some would like to believe

But the vast majority of them were. New Orleans was an outlier.
 
Re: Confederate monuments


The Supreme Court identified a loophole in Texas v. White. A State cannot unilaterally decide to leave the Union, but the decision implies that a State can secede with consent of the Union presumably through an act of Congress.
 
Re: Confederate monuments

But the vast majority of them were. New Orleans was an outlier.

i am not doubting that, but the idea which some people have in their minds as if every black was a beat down human being and laced the scares on their backs in silly
 
Re: Confederate monuments


Unless, of course, you are Bill O'Reilly.


https://www.theatlantic.com/politic...the-long-tradition-of-slavery-apology/493223/

The United States is not Ancient Rome. It is irrelevant that the Romans approved of slavery; the people of 1860 were not living in ancient times.
 
Re: Confederate monuments

Tell us about your user name.

What exactly are you trying to imply? Do you actually think that the tank in my profile picture is a Tiger I?

Do you actually want to hear the story of why I chose this particular user name, or are you simply Godwin-ing?
 
Re: Confederate monuments

can you explain why Britain had slavery up into the 19th century

Why they had slavery in their colonies? Because in England itself it was banned earlier.

Mostly it was because just like in the south the plantation system was in use in many of these countries, and that system required large numbers of workers. The English weren't too concerned with the moral aspect until later.
 
Re: Confederate monuments

may have been?

even that does not make a connection to a government operation

Well, considering that this was well over a hundred years ago, there's no "smoking gun"---- but we can judge probabilities.
 
Re: Confederate monuments


slavery did not end until 1833 in the empire.

but for some reason its not talked about much
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…