• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Would You Stand Up Against Hitler and his 3rd Reich?

Would you have stood up against Hitler and his 3rd Reich?

  • Total voters
    34
Northern Light said:
It doesn't even do that. It's been proven.
Click to expand...

You need to do better than that, and by the way, the thread is about Hitler, so maybe you could do it in a COVID thread.
Yeah, it definitely does a good job preventing most people from dying of COVID, and you just saying "it doesn't" means nothing.
 
More misinformation bs. The Covid vaccines absolutely greatly reduce the chance that, once infected, you will be hospitalized or dead by a factor of 10-11.
Unfortunately they aren’t sterilizing vaccines. So the aren’t particularly great at preventing infections or transmission. There is some benefit in those areas, but not much.
Those are the facts whether you like it or not.
 

No they don't. The most hospitalized population per capita at this time is the vaccinated. Lookup any CDC, NIH or WHO data on that and you will discover I am telling the truth. People are still on ventilators... the overwhelming majority are vaccinated. The reason is that the unvaccinated mostly have natural immunity now, which is more robust, so their cases are dropping.

They were never sterilizing vaccines so that comment is irrelevant. We knew that already. Despite that, government officials, the FDA and CDC claimed 100% efficacy at stopping spread of the virus when the vaccine first hit the market. Then it was 80%, then 50% and it kept getting lower until now they admit it doesn't stop viral spread at all.

You can't just say "those are the facts whether you like it or not"... science doesn't work that way. It's built upon cumulative data and repeated experiments. The current data shows that the vaccine doesn't reduce severity or stop spread. It basically doesn't work. It's because the vaccine is for outdated strains. The virus mutates too quickly and there doesn't appear to be much cross-immunity in the vaccinated population because they have only been immunized against the spike protein, not the whole virus. Natural immunity is superior because it creates immunity to every protein in the virus... there are around 28 IIRC. Immune imprinting in the vaccinated is preventing the immune system from forming a comprehensive adaptive response to the whole virus. That's why the vaccinated are the ones getting hospitalized now.

Just curious, are you qualified to read science?
 
LetsGoBrandon said:
Actually Joe Biden is more akin to an alzheimers ward in a convalescent home.
Click to expand...
And yet he beat the jackass by over 5 million votes in his landslide victory.
Must be incredibly embarrassing to the supporters of the orange pustule.
 
Checkerboard Strangler said:
You need to do better than that, and by the way, the thread is about Hitler, so maybe you could do it in a COVID thread.
Yeah, it definitely does a good job preventing most people from dying of COVID, and you just saying "it doesn't" means nothing.
Click to expand...

You're the one who has drawn this into a conversation about covid. I was merely taking about the psychology of indoctrinated populations and how they marginalize certain groups of people on command. Maybe if you want to stay on topic you should stop posting irrelevancies. You're biased because you happen to agree with demonizing a segment of the population. You showed your ace already on that one, an ace that I disproved with one sentence. Unlike you, I'm unbiased. I see that the government policy has been incorrect because I am qualified to read science and I am reading it all the time. It shows, to me, that a high level of indoctrination has happened.

There is functionally no difference between the psychology of Germans in the 1940s and Americans with how they treated the unvaccinated. The government used mass formation techniques (extreme fear followed by a one-solution) to alter psychology on a population level. It worked.

You basically degraded the unvaccinated for spreading the virus. Then when I pointed out that the vaccine doesn't stop the spread of the virus, you switched goalposts and said that the vaccinated were protected from severe illness. You don't see your own cognitive dissonance, even you're lead right to it. This is an example of mass formation, the psychology I am actually trying to talk about.

Are you capable of admitting that the vaccinated and unvaccinated both spread the virus? If you're not, then mass formation has hijacked your mind.
 
Ethel2 said:
And yet he beat the jackass by over 5 million votes in his landslide victory.
Click to expand...
Joey 'man of dementia did not actually beat anyone. He barely even campaigned. It was all set up for him. He's just a puppet.
Ethel2 said:
Must be incredibly embarrassing to the supporters of the orange pustule.
Click to expand...
I don't know of any orange pustules other then Al Gore in the 2000 race (First debate).
 
Yup. I am a licensed physician.
You are wrong: the existing vaccines absolutely reduce the chances of serious illness by a factor of around 10. It’s true that nowadays more vaccinated people are dying from covid than the unvaccinated. There are a couple of reasons for this: first, more vulnerable people tend to be vaccinated more often. Vaccinated or not the vulnerable remain vulnerable. Second, there are a LOT of vaccinated people. If there are 1000 vaccinated people and 10 unvaccinated people, for example, logic dictates that more vaccinated people than unvaccinated will become seriously ill.
Are YOU qualified to read science?
 
LetsGoBrandon said:
Joey 'man of dementia did not actually beat anyone. He barely even campaigned. It was all set up for him. He's just a puppet.

I don't know of any orange pustules other then Al Gore in the 2000 race (First debate).
Click to expand...
Pretty funny
There were two candidates for president. One lost and the other got his rump handed to him.
Your guy lost -“by a lot”.
 

Yes, I'm a scientist. I do medical research on the regular.

I know that you're not a real doctor (or you're a lousy one) because you just made the same critical statistical error that all lay people pretending to be doctors make: you conflated per capita with absolute numbers. You'll notice in my post that I said per capita.

Any medical professional worth their salt knows the difference.

Nice logic there "doc".
 
Ethel2 said:
Pretty funny
There were two candidates for president. One lost and the other got his rump handed to him.
Your guy lost -“by a lot”.
Click to expand...
The reality is that Sleepy Joe with no charisma out id Obama and Clinton who were loaded with charisma, and the democrats enjoyed no down ticket support from such a margin. The question is how many of those votes were legitimate. To roughly half the population, it does not pass the smell test.
As for how Trump did? He garnered millions more votes in 2020 then he did in 2016. Technically, he lost, however at least his votes were legitimate.
 
Get your facts straight. It’s not a matter of opinion that the existing vaccines markedly reduce the chance of hospitalization and death. I won’t debate facts here with you or with anybody else. But I will provide this article to support the facts I have presented here:

COVID Vaccine Effectiveness Data Show Protection Gained by Boosters

COVID Vaccine Effectiveness Data Show Protection Gained by Boosters
www.cdc.gov

Btw. since you have questioned whether or not I am a licensed doctor let’s make a little wager: if I can prove to you through an independent arbiter that I am a licensed physician then you agree to make a small donation to the charity of my choice. If the arbiter isn’t convinced then I will make a donation to the charity of your choice.
Deal?
 
Trumptards wouldn't. That much we know.

Trumptards would be eager to join up.
 
“Technically he lost”=he lost.
 
Ethel2 said:
“Technically he lost”=he lost.
Click to expand...
Fairly or unfairly, yes he lost. Personally I lost faith in the election when sever swing states fast tracked unsecure mass mailout balloting in the lead up to the election. As far as I am concerned, the 2020 election did not pass the smell test. However it's done. I look forward to the 2024 election.
 
LetsGoBrandon said:
As far as I am concerned, the 2020 election did not pass the smell test.
Click to expand...

That was the stench of all the bullshit that Crooked donnie was slinging. Thats what you smelled. Nothing more than that.
 
Checkerboard Strangler said:
I am not going to relitigate the COVID controversy in a thread about Hitler.


Wrong.
Here's your post where you first brought it up.
Click to expand...

There's no talking to you. You've already decided to intentionally misunderstand me despite numerous attempts to critically explain my POV to you. I won't cater to your cognitive dissonance.

You should know though that clinging to an unscientific opinion because the government has instructed you to do so is identical to what Hitler did with German people, through mass formation. Take care.
 

Yeah clinging, that must be it....the government "instructed" me.
Had nothing to do with me almost dying first time I contracted the virus (Feb2020) and then surviving (vaccinated-boosted) my second bout Aug2022) as nothing more than three days of the sniffles. (sarcasm)

Good riddance, antivaxxer, go lick some handrails.
THE CONTINUING FAILURE OF PEOPLE WITH SELF-FLUFFING HANDLES
 

The CDC's own statements are currently being disproven by not only peer reviewed data, but other nations such as the UK, Denmark, Norway, and Germany who have pulled the vaccine for certain demographics, such as pregnant/breastfeeding women, children and adolescents. In Denmark it's anybody under 30.

I'm not interested in playing a gambling game with you, nor will I let you bait and switch this conversation into something irrelevant. Whether you're a doctor or not doesn't actually matter. You display an abysmal level of critical thinking unbecoming of somebody who is supposed to be trained in medical science.

All you have to day is compare the per capita hospitalization rate of the unvaccinated with the per capita hospitalization rate of the vaccinated. This is a simple level statistics operation that anybody in a first year stats course could do. If you don't understand that, then it is frightening that you're a clinician (assuming you actually are one).
 
2000Mules said:
Would you have stood up against Hitler and his 3rd Reich?
Click to expand...
I'd like to think so, assuming I had the chance.

My concern that Trump was heading in that direction is one of the reasons I voted against him.

And now he's basically confirmed my decision in multiple ways, most recently by stating that we should get rid of all the laws including the constitution.
 
This has nothing to do with “the government’s instructions “. You have swallowed the misinformation bs hook line and sinker. It’s obvious that you haven’t a clue about medicine. Therefore, there’s no talking to you about this subject.
Are you ready to accept the deal I offered you?
Regardless, I am done with this topic as it’s an off topic discussion.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…